Pre-packaged Insolvency Explained: Eligibility, Process, and Benefits

Author

Reads 1.5K

Christmas gift boxes and decorations on table
Credit: pexels.com, Christmas gift boxes and decorations on table

Pre-packaged insolvency is a relatively new and flexible way to deal with insolvency in the UK. It allows struggling businesses to sell off their assets to a new company while avoiding the lengthy and costly administration process.

Eligible businesses are those with a turnover of less than £25 million and no more than 50 employees. This is a key factor in determining whether a pre-packaged insolvency is viable.

The process starts with a pre-packaged administration, where an administrator is appointed to oversee the sale of the business's assets. This can be done quickly, often within a few days, to minimize disruption and preserve the business's value.

Pre-packaged insolvency offers several benefits, including the ability to sell off assets quickly and avoid the stigma of traditional insolvency proceedings. It also allows the business to continue trading with a new company, potentially preserving jobs and minimizing the impact on employees and customers.

For another approach, see: Administration (British Football)

What is PPIRP?

Credit: youtube.com, What is a pre-packaged insolvency resolution process?

A pre-packaged insolvency resolution, or PPIRP for short, is a plan that allows for the restructuring of a corporate debtor with creditors and stakeholders before declaring insolvency or bankruptcy.

This type of resolution is a quasi-formal process that provides a balance between an informal dialogue and a formal insolvency resolution process.

It's a hybrid mechanism that combines characteristics from the existing Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) mechanism.

The purpose of PPIRP is to achieve an equilibrium between informal and formal processes, making it a more economical and efficient way to resolve insolvency.

The Indian government recognized the importance of pre-packaged insolvency regimes and established a subcommittee to explore a legal structure for PPIRP under the Code.

The subcommittee submitted a report in October 2020, recommending a particular legal structure for managing pre-pack under the Code.

Broaden your view: Corporate Bankruptcy Laws

Eligibility and Application

To be eligible for Pre-packaged Insolvency and Reorganization Process (PPIRP), a corporate debtor must be classified as a Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprise under the Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006.

Credit: youtube.com, Webinar On "Pre-Packaged Insolvency Resolution Process for MSME"

The corporate debtor must have defaulted on payments as defined in Section 4 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC). They must not have undergone PPIRP or Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) in the past three years.

To initiate the process, approval is required from unrelated financial creditors holding at least 66% of the financial debt. The directors or partners must also declare that the process will not exceed 90 days and propose a resolution professional (RP).

A special resolution or partner’s approval with at least 75% support is necessary, along with a report submission and required documents to the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI).

Process and Timeline

The PPIRP application must be filed within 14 days of filing CIRP, but this timeline can be impractical due to the need for obtaining all necessary approvals and documentation.

A condonation of delay application could be a potential solution to this issue, as it would allow for flexibility in meeting the 14-day deadline.

Credit: youtube.com, Pre Pack Insolvency | My Insolvency

The PPIRP completion time is a maximum of 120 days, which is significantly shorter than the Code's standard CIRP timeframe.

This expedited resolution process preserves strained assets' value and prevents deterioration, making resolution efficient.

Here are the benefits of a pre-packaged insolvency resolution process:

  1. Cost Effectiveness: Avoids lawsuit costs and reputation damage by choosing this "out of court" procedure.
  2. Expeditious Resolution: Guarantees an expedited resolution process with a shorter time frame than the Code's standard CIRP.
  3. Maximised Value of Assets: Prevents assets' depreciation over a longer period by eliminating the time required to complete the process.

Moratorium Declaration and Public Announcement

On April 22, 2021, a moratorium declaration was made to pause all new fossil fuel project approvals.

This declaration was made in response to the urgent need to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and mitigate the worst impacts of climate change.

The moratorium was announced publicly to raise awareness about the importance of taking immediate action to address the climate crisis.

A public announcement was made to inform the public about the moratorium and its implications.

The moratorium declaration was a significant step towards reducing greenhouse gas emissions and promoting sustainable development.

It marked a shift in policy direction, prioritizing the health of the planet and its inhabitants over fossil fuel interests.

The public announcement was an opportunity for governments and stakeholders to engage with the public and discuss the implications of the moratorium.

Intriguing read: B of a Pre Approval

PPIRP Timeline Issue

Credit: youtube.com, Pre-Packaged Insolvency Resolution Process (PPIRP) IBC Case Laws | IBC Laws

The PPIRP timeline issue is a crucial aspect of the process. The IBBI requires the PPIRP application to be filed within 14 days of filing CIRP.

This seems impractical due to the need of obtaining all necessary approvals and documentation. The Supreme Court's rationale on filing of CIRP by FC and OC can be a potential solution.

A condonation of delay application could be a viable option to address the timeline issue. This would allow for flexibility in meeting the 14-day deadline.

Benefits and Analysis

A pre-packaged insolvency (PPIRP) can be a cost-effective option for companies in financial distress. This is because it avoids the need for a receiver or administrator to be appointed, which can save on disruption expenses.

One of the key benefits of PPIRP is that it allows for an expedited resolution process, with a maximum completion time of 120 days. This is significantly shorter than the 270-330 days required for a standard corporate insolvency resolution process (CIRP).

Credit: youtube.com, What Is Pre-packaged Chapter 11? - Your Bankruptcy Advisors

The PPIRP process also helps to maximise the value of assets by preventing their depreciation over a longer period. This is because it eliminates the time required to complete the process, which can be a significant advantage in preserving the value of assets.

Here are the key benefits of PPIRP:

  • Cost-effectiveness: avoids disruption expenses, lawsuit costs, and reputation damage
  • Expeditious Resolution: maximum completion time of 120 days
  • Maximised Value of Assets: prevents depreciation over a longer period

Intended Benefits of PPIRP

The intended benefits of PPIRP are quite impressive. A PPIRP (Pre-Packaged Insolvency Resolution Process) is a cost-effective way to resolve corporate debt, avoiding lawsuit costs and reputation damage.

This "out of court" procedure saves time and money by not requiring the transfer of management from the debtor to the resolution applicant. Disruption expenses are also minimized.

A pre-pack guarantees an expedited resolution process, with a maximum completion time of 120 days. This preserves the value of strained assets and prevents deterioration.

Here are the key benefits of PPIRP at a glance:

  • Cost Effectiveness: Avoids lawsuit costs and reputation damage
  • Expeditious Resolution: Completion time of 120 days
  • Maximised Value of Assets: Prevents depreciation over a longer period

PPIRP maximises the value of assets by eliminating the time required to complete the process, which would otherwise lead to depreciation over a longer period.

Analysis

Two businessmen in suits discussing a project using a digital tablet during a business meeting indoors.
Credit: pexels.com, Two businessmen in suits discussing a project using a digital tablet during a business meeting indoors.

In the analysis of the benefits, it's clear that regular exercise has a significant impact on mental health. Exercise has been shown to reduce symptoms of anxiety and depression by releasing endorphins, also known as "feel-good" hormones.

Physical activity has also been linked to improved sleep quality, with studies suggesting that regular exercise can help reduce sleep latency and increase sleep duration.

Exercise has been shown to improve cognitive function, particularly in older adults, with studies indicating that physical activity can improve memory and processing speed.

Insolvency Resolution

Pre-packaged insolvency provides a distinct process that merges the advantages of informal dialogue with the assurance of an official insolvency proceeding.

This process is often referred to as a 'pre-pack', and it enables out-of-court remedies to be acknowledged under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) while ensuring proper safeguards for all parties involved.

The pre-pack procedure is an efficient alternative insolvency resolution process for MSMEs with a minimum default amount of INR 10 lakh and a maximum of INR 1 Crore.

Credit: youtube.com, What is Pre Packaged Insolvency Resolution Process? | MSME | Rohit Pradhan

The Central Government and the IBBI have published notifications and rules to have the pre-pack procedure in place.

Pre-pack administration facilitates a quick and relatively smooth transfer of a business, allowing the business to continue uninterrupted.

Carrying out business during insolvency can be difficult without funding or regulatory compliance, but pre-packs offer a solution to this problem.

The speed of sale of the company is one of the major advantages of pre-pack administration, resulting in higher returns for creditors compared to alternative routes into insolvency.

Pre-pack administration also offers transparency, reduced cost of administration, and business continuity.

Legislative Framework and Decisions

The Pre-packaged Insolvency Resolution Process (PIRP) is governed by specific rules to ensure a smooth and efficient process.

The PIRP shall not be instituted in situations where a Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) application under Sections 7, 9, or 10 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) is pending at the time the Amendment Ordinance goes into effect.

Related reading: Consumer Proposal Process

Credit: youtube.com, The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Amendment) Ordinance, 2021

The Central Government of India has set a minimum threshold of Rs. 10 Lacs as the amount of default required to initiate the PIRP, which is a key requirement for the process to begin.

The entire restructuring process has been shortened to minimize value stripping of assets.

The debtor has a total of 120 days to get approval for the proposed resolution plan, while the Committee of Creditors (CoC) must submit the resolution plan within the initial 90 days.

The Resolution Professional and the Appointed Authority have an additional 30 days to either approve or modify the original resolution plan.

If the base resolution plan is not approved in the specified time period, the Resolution Professional is obligated to submit an application for termination of PIRP.

Recommended read: Dbs Debt Consolidation Plan

Legislative Framework

The PPIRP process is governed by Sections 54A to 54M of the IBC. This framework is designed to provide a clear structure for the process.

A minimum threshold of Rs. 10 Lacs is required as the amount of default to initiate the PIRP. This ensures that only significant debts are eligible for restructuring.

Credit: youtube.com, 10-10 Webinar: The New Legislative Framework (NLF)

The duration for the entire restructuring process has been shortened to 120 days. This is a significant reduction from previous timelines.

The debtor has 120 days to get approval for the proposed resolution plan. This plan will serve as the tentative outline for reorganisation.

The CoC must submit the resolution plan within the initial 90 days. This is a tight deadline that requires careful planning.

The RP and the AA have an additional 30 days to either approve or modify the original resolution plan. This allows for some flexibility in the process.

If the base resolution plan is not approved in the specified time period, the resolution professional must submit an application for termination of PIRP. This ensures that the process remains on track.

Landmark Judicial Decisions

In the realm of PPIRP, landmark judicial decisions have played a significant role in shaping the legislative framework. Currently, there have been eight petitions submitted, with six accepted and one withdrawn before a decision was made.

Credit: youtube.com, How Do Landmark Cases Influence Changes in Law or Policy? - Justice System Explained

The NCLAT has reaffirmed the NCLT's ruling to consider objections during the admission procedure. This means that if an application is made under section 54C and doesn't meet the legal requirements, anyone with a claim in PPIRP can identify the flaw and object to the acceptance of such an application.

A total of five instances are still pending, with just one case having been resolved through PPIRP as of March 01, 2023. There are currently four unresolved cases.

The NCLAT concluded that there was a failure to comply with regulations in getting consent from the FCs for the necessary paperwork of the PPIRP application. This was the case with Krrish Realtech, which retracted its application after the NCLAT's decision.

The duration from the date of filing and the date of withdrawal was 137 days. The NCLT Ahmedabad accepted the application for beginning of PPIRP for GCCL Infrastructure and Projects Limited on 14 September 2021, but the procedure is still awaiting a decision from the NCLT.

Here are the cases that are admitted and pending:

  • The case of Krrish Realtech, which lodged an appeal with the appellate tribunal, requesting for the concerns be addressed subsequent to the acceptance of the said PPIRP application.
  • The case of GCCL Infrastructure and Projects Limited, which is still awaiting a decision from the NCLT due to the BRP's merger plan being under investigation.

Criticism and Overview

Credit: youtube.com, What is pre pack administration? #businessstructure #insolvency #debtmanagement #liquidation

Pre-packaged insolvency has its fair share of critics, who point out that the process can favor the interests of the company's management team and secured creditors over those of unsecured creditors.

A review from Wolverhampton University identified several criticisms of pre-pack sales, including the speed and secrecy of the transaction, which often leaves unsecured creditors in the dark.

Critics argue that the consideration paid for the business may not have been maximized due to the absence of open marketing, and that credit may have been incurred inappropriately prior to the pre-pack.

This lack of transparency and oversight can lead to unsecured creditors receiving little or no return on their investment.

Pre-Pack Overview

Pre-pack administration is a process that allows a company to restructure its debt and assets without going into liquidation.

It's a relatively quick process, typically taking around 2-4 weeks to complete.

The pre-pack process involves the sale of a company's assets to a new buyer, often a connected party, and the transfer of liabilities to the buyer.

On a similar theme: Hudson's Bay Trading Company

A professional woman in a business suit reviews legal documents at her office desk.
Credit: pexels.com, A professional woman in a business suit reviews legal documents at her office desk.

This can be a good option for companies that are struggling financially but have a valuable business that can be sold.

Pre-packs can be used to rescue companies that are on the verge of insolvency, but they can also be used by companies that are performing well but want to restructure their debt.

In some cases, pre-packs can be used to avoid a formal insolvency procedure, which can help to protect the company's reputation and relationships with customers and suppliers.

The pre-pack process is often used in conjunction with other insolvency procedures, such as a Company Voluntary Arrangement (CVA).

Consider reading: Pre Roll Company

Criticism

Criticism of pre-pack sales is a valid concern, as a review from Wolverhampton University highlights.

A general concern is that the pre-pack administrator may favor the interests of the company's management team and secured creditors over those of unsecured creditors.

The speed and secrecy of the transaction often lead to a deal being executed without the knowledge of unsecured creditors, offering them little or no return.

There's a suspicion that the consideration paid for the business may not have been maximized due to the absence of open marketing.

Credit may have been incurred inappropriately prior to the pre-pack, and this may not be fully investigated.

United States and COVID

Credit: youtube.com, COVID-19: Solicitors solvency and pre pack administration

The United States has a unique approach to pre-packaged insolvency, often referred to as pre-packaged bankruptcy. A conventional bankruptcy case is one where the debtor files for Chapter 11 relief without prior agreement on a plan of reorganization with creditors.

In pre-packaged cases, plan proponents secure enough creditor support to confirm the plan before filing for Chapter 11. This requires a significant amount of planning and coordination to ensure that the necessary approvals are in place.

The airline industry is a notable example of companies operating under Chapter 11 protection, with over half of the industry's seating capacity in 2006 belonging to airlines in Chapter 11. This highlights the complexity and scale of Chapter 11 cases.

Pre-packaged plans of reorganization often involve impairing one or more classes of creditors, meaning they receive less than full payment. To ensure confirmation, plan proponents must secure support from at least two-thirds in amount and more than one-half in number of an impaired class.

A significant example of pre-packaged insolvency in the United States is the General Motors bankruptcy in 2009. A new entity was formed to acquire profitable assets, and the remaining pre-petition creditor claims were paid from the former corporation's assets.

Take a look at this: Preit Chapter 11

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the pre insolvency process?

The pre-insolvency process is a faster resolution mechanism for businesses in financial distress, where the debtor and creditors negotiate a plan to avoid formal insolvency proceedings. This process allows for a quicker and more controlled resolution to financial difficulties.

What is the difference between pre-pack administration and liquidation?

Pre-pack administration allows your business to continue operating, while liquidation means permanently ceasing all operations. The key difference lies in preserving business value versus closing the company

James Hoeger-Bergnaum

Senior Assigning Editor

James Hoeger-Bergnaum is an experienced Assigning Editor with a proven track record of delivering high-quality content. With a keen eye for detail and a passion for storytelling, James has curated articles that captivate and inform readers. His expertise spans a wide range of subjects, including in-depth explorations of the New York financial landscape.

Love What You Read? Stay Updated!

Join our community for insights, tips, and more.