
Investing in a Variable Universal Life (VUL) policy for your retirement can be a complex decision. A VUL policy can provide a guaranteed death benefit, which may be appealing to those who want to ensure their loved ones are taken care of.
The cash value of a VUL policy can grow over time, potentially providing a source of retirement income. However, this growth is not guaranteed and may be affected by the performance of the underlying investments.
To make an informed decision, it's essential to consider the fees associated with a VUL policy. As mentioned in our previous section, VUL policies often come with high fees, which can eat into your returns.
Ultimately, whether or not to invest in a VUL policy for your retirement depends on your individual financial goals and circumstances.
Broaden your view: Internal Rate of Return Decision Rule
Here's an interesting read: Is Clm a Good Investment
Benefits and Advantages
Variable universal life (VUL) insurance offers significant tax advantages compared to investment accounts. This is because VUL products are taxed in the same manner as other forms of permanent life insurance.
One of the key benefits of VUL is its ability to provide lifelong coverage, which can be especially important for families with long-term financial obligations. You can control how your cash value is invested and reallocate it over time.
A VUL can be a good choice for someone who wants to grow their cash value faster than they could with a whole life policy. This is because VULs allow you to invest in a variety of assets, giving you the potential to see higher returns.
Funding a VUL well in the early years of the contract is crucial to making money. This reduces insurance charges and gives the investment accounts the most time to compound in growth.
Here are some key benefits of VUL:
- Both VUL and whole life insurance are types of permanent life insurance.
- Both build cash value.
Overall, VUL offers flexibility and control over how your cash value is invested, making it a potentially attractive option for those who want to customize their coverage and potentially see higher returns.
How It Works
A whole life policy typically offers a guaranteed, though modest, rate of return. This means you can expect a certain level of growth in your investment, but it might not be the highest.
Variable universal life insurance policies, on the other hand, offer a chance to earn greater returns, but they come with the risk associated with the stock market. This means your investment can grow significantly, but it can also decline.
You can use the cash value of your policy during your lifetime, or leave it to your loved ones. Either way, it's usually tax-free. This is a great benefit, as you won't have to worry about paying taxes on your investment gains.
The policy acts as a retirement savings tool that offers a death benefit should you pass away prematurely. This means your loved ones will receive a payout, even if you're not around to collect it.
Here are the key features of variable universal life insurance:
- Premium payments and investment options can be adjusted over time to align with your changing priorities and goals.
- Each time you pay your premium, expenses are taken out and the rest is allocated to the investment options you have selected.
- Expenses (including the cost of insurance) are deducted from your premiums.
- The performance of your investments is added or subtracted from your policy's cash value on a daily basis.
Pros and Cons
Variable universal life (VUL) insurance has its advantages and disadvantages. One of the main benefits is that it can provide lifelong protection for your loved ones, along with premium and death benefit flexibility.
The fees associated with VUL are transparent, allowing you to view the expenses and charges that your policy incurs, as well as the performance of your investments on your annual policy statement.
You can also build cash value that will grow tax-deferred and can be used for anything, anytime. VUL can also be a way to reach other financial goals faster if you're willing to accept market risk.
Here are some key benefits of VUL:
- Lifelong protection for your loved ones
- Premium and death benefit flexibility
- Transparent fees
- Cash value grows tax-deferred
- Can be used to reach other financial goals
- Guaranteed death benefit for a certain period of time (if certain conditions are met)
Pros and Cons
Variable Universal Life (VUL) insurance offers a range of benefits that make it an attractive option for many people.
You can have lifelong protection for your loved ones, along with the flexibility to adjust your premiums and death benefit as needed. This gives you more control over your policy and the opportunity to build a higher death benefit over time.
One of the key advantages of VUL is that its fees are transparent, allowing you to see exactly what you're paying for and how your investments are performing. You'll receive an annual policy statement with all the details.
The cash value of a VUL policy can grow tax-deferred, giving you a potential source of funds for any purpose. This can be a game-changer for people who want to reach their financial goals faster.
However, VUL might not be right for everyone, particularly those who are uncomfortable with market risk. The cash value of your policy could fluctuate based on the performance of your investments.
If you're willing to accept market risk, VUL can be a great way to reach your financial goals. You might also have the option of a guaranteed death benefit for a certain period of time, as long as you pay your premiums and meet certain conditions.
To help you decide if VUL is right for you, here are some key points to consider:
People who have a long-term perspective and are interested in monitoring their policy performance might find VUL to be a good fit.
Disadvantages

VUL might not be right for you if you don't like market risk, as your policy's cash value could fluctuate based on the performance of the underlying investment options you choose.
Your policy could lapse if your cash value is ever too low to cover policy costs, unless the death benefit guarantee is active or additional premium payments are made.
VUL policies can be limiting in terms of investment options, and even if you have a good selection now, it may not be the same in the future.
The annual operating expense of the investment choices can range from 0.5% to 2.6% per year, which can eat into your policy's cash value.
Here are some potential drawbacks to consider:
- Your policy's cash value could fluctuate based on market performance.
- Your policy could lapse if your cash value is too low to cover policy costs.
- Investment options may be limited and not include new or emerging asset classes.
- Annual operating expenses can range from 0.5% to 2.6% per year.
Taxation and Financial Planning
A VUL policy offers significant tax advantages over other investment accounts. This is because VUL products are taxed in the same manner as other forms of permanent life insurance.
With a VUL policy, your premium payments cover the cost of life insurance, the selling agent’s commissions, and the insurance company’s costs and margin. Whatever is left goes toward a cash value, which can be invested in a selection of mutual fund-like subaccounts.
The value of the policy will grow over time, as long as you continue making premium payments and have positive investment returns. This investment growth is tax-deferred until you take withdrawals from the policy.
You can withdraw up to the total amount of your contributions to the policy tax-free, and then any remaining withdrawals are added to your taxable income for the year.
Taxation of
A VUL policy's taxation is its primary advantage. The IRS considers withdrawals to come out basis first, meaning you can withdraw up to the total amount of your contributions to the policy tax-free.
Withdrawals from a VUL policy are taxed as income, but only on the investment growth, not the contributions. This is because the contributions are considered tax-free.
You can avoid taxation by taking withdrawals as loans against the accumulated cash balance. Policy loans accrue interest but are not taxable as income.
Here's a breakdown of how VUL policy taxation works:
This tax-free savings claim is a major benefit of a VUL policy. By taking withdrawals as loans, you can avoid paying taxes on the investment growth.
The ability to re-allocate or re-balance investments within a VUL policy without incurring taxes is another overlooked benefit. This means you can move money between investment divisions without paying taxes on liquidations of securities with gains.
Investment Options in Northwestern Mutual Policy
Northwestern Mutual's variable universal life insurance policy offers 59 investment options to choose from, which can be tailored to fit your individual financial goals and risk tolerance.
You can select individual investment options or choose from pre-packaged solutions that have a mix of different assets.
Each investment option has its own focus, goals, and advisor(s), so it's essential to understand what you're investing in before making a decision.
The pre-packaged solutions can make it easier to choose investments, as they're designed to work with a particular asset allocation model.
You can also opt for the Strength and Stability (SAS) account, which can reduce the amount of risk you take on by providing a fixed account option backed by Northwestern Mutual's general account investment portfolio.
With the SAS account, you can transfer 5-50 percent of your net premiums and cash value to the fixed account, while the rest remains in the investment options you select.
It's worth noting that you're limited to the investment options offered by the policy, so it's essential to review the options carefully before making a decision.
Intriguing read: Mutual Fund Portfolio Analysis
Cost of
The cost of variable universal life insurance (VUL) can be a significant drawback. It's not uncommon for a large portion of your premium payments to go towards administrative and insurance fees, leaving a relatively small amount in cash value.
In one example, a client's policy had a $6,866 administrative and insurance fee in the first year, leaving $43,134 in cash value. This doesn't even account for the operating expenses of the investment options.
The returns on VUL policies can be low, especially in the first few years. Assuming a 6.5% net return on the investment options, the policy illustration showed an ROI of 3.91% after year 1, 3.08% after year 2, and 2.60% after year 3.
Low policy returns are a common characteristic of VUL policies, and it's not just limited to the first few years. By year 30, the net return to the policyholder was only 4.98% per year, thanks to the annual increases in the cost of insurance.
Broaden your view: The Payout Ratio Equals Cash Dividends Divided by Net Income.
Protection and Security
Having a guaranteed death benefit is a key feature of variable universal life insurance. This means that your loved ones will receive a set amount of money, no matter what happens to the cash value of your policy.
The cost of insurance and other policy charges will still need to be paid out of your policy's cash value, but this is a standard part of VUL policies.
Readers also liked: Net Discretionary Cash Flow
Policy Lapse
Lapse of a VUL policy can have significant tax implications. If the policy's value exceeds your total contributions, you'd have a gain in the policy, taxed as income.
This gain could be substantial, especially if you're using a VUL policy as a tax-free deferred comp vehicle. In one client's case, the policy illustration showed a balance of $1.8M in the year they turned 80.
The most common reason a VUL policy lapses is if there's not enough cash value left to pay policy expenses. This cash value is subject to volatile market performance, making it a risk.
If you've taken a significant amount of money out of a VUL policy before experiencing negative investment returns, it's possible the policy could be at risk of lapse.
Consider reading: Enterprise Value vs Market Cap
VULs as Deferred Comp Plans?
A VUL policy can theoretically work as a deferred comp plan, but it's not a straightforward solution. Several stars would need to align for this to be true.
You'd need to be in a high tax bracket, or expect future tax rates to skyrocket, based on our national debt level or some other reason. The benefits of a VUL policy would need to outweigh the extra costs over the rest of your life.
You'd need to already be maxing out your contributions to all the tax-advantaged retirement account options available to you. The benefits of these accounts will trump the benefits of VUL policies any day of the week after costs.
You'd need to find a policy that offers solid, inexpensive investment options. You'd probably be using them for a very long time.
In my experience, it's quite rare to find a situation where variable universal life would be a good fit as a retirement account or personal deferred comp plan.
Discover more: How to Find Profitability Index
Protection

Variable universal life insurance provides a guaranteed death benefit, giving you peace of mind for your loved ones.
The cost of insurance and other policy charges will still need to be paid out of your policy's cash value, so it's essential to consider these expenses when choosing a VUL policy.
You can choose from a variety of investment options to grow the cash value of your VUL policy, giving you flexibility in your premiums and death benefit amount.
The cash value of a VUL policy grows the same way as a whole life policy, but it also gives you the flexibility to adjust your premiums and death benefit amount.
With a VUL policy, you can build cash value tax deferred, allowing for compound growth since the money you don't pay in taxes can continue to be invested.
The cash value of a VUL policy has the potential to go down in value, so it's crucial to carefully consider the investment options and policy charges before making a decision.
Worth a look: Fair Value Gap Thinkorswim
What Happens to Death Benefit in a Market Downturn?

Your death benefit could decrease if the market goes down, depending on the policy options you've selected.
Working with a financial advisor can help you build a VUL policy that best fits your needs and goals.
A death benefit guarantee can ensure your death benefit stays in-force for the duration of the guarantee, as long as premiums are paid.
This guarantee can provide peace of mind, knowing your loved ones will receive a certain amount when you pass away.
Comparison and Analysis
Indexed Universal Life (IUL) and Variable Universal Life (VUL) insurance are both types of permanent life insurance that offer a death benefit and cash value.
IUL's cash value mimics market performance by using a market index, such as the S&P 500, which means it has limited downside risk due to a floor on returns.
VUL, on the other hand, lets you invest its cash value in various investment options, similar to mutual funds, giving you a greater chance for higher returns but also increasing the risk of losing your principal.
Consider reading: Investors Assess Cash Flows before
Many IULs have a cap on returns, so you might not get the most from strong market performance, limiting the potential for growth.
VUL is more suitable for those with a higher risk tolerance and a desire for potentially greater growth, making it a better option for those who can afford to take on more risk.
Suggestion: Country Risk Premium Aswath Damodaran
Popularity and Worth
A VUL policy can be a good investment option for those looking for flexibility and control over their finances. It allows you to adjust premiums to fit your changing budget, which is a big plus.
If you value having more say in how your money is invested, a VUL policy might be right for you. This is because it offers more investment options compared to traditional insurance policies.
A VUL policy also has the potential for higher growth, which is a major advantage for those looking to grow their wealth.
Why It's Popular
A VUL policy is a great option for those who want more control over their insurance costs. This is because VUL policies allow you to adjust premiums to fit your changing budget.

One of the biggest advantages of VUL policies is that they offer more say in how your money is invested. This can be a game-changer for those who want to take a more active role in managing their finances.
If you're looking for a policy with the potential for higher growth, a VUL policy might be worth considering.
Worth It?
Proceed with caution when considering variable universal life, as it may not be the best option for everyone. Separating your insurance and investing vehicles is often a better approach.
Variable universal life policies can be complex and may not provide the returns you expect. It's essential to evaluate the policy carefully before making a decision.
The moral of the story is that variable universal life may not be worth it, especially if you're considering it as a retirement account or personal deferred comp plan.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is VUL ever a good idea?
While VUL policies can provide tax benefits and flexibility, they may not be the most efficient way to accumulate wealth, especially for equity investments. Consider exploring alternative options that align with your financial goals and tax situation before investing in a VUL policy.
Featured Images: pexels.com


