Retainage Explained: Benefits, Laws, and Best Practices

Author

Reads 8.1K

A Person in Black and White Plaid Jacket Holding Banknotes
Credit: pexels.com, A Person in Black and White Plaid Jacket Holding Banknotes

Retainage is a common practice in the construction industry, but what exactly is it? Retainage is a percentage of the payment due to a contractor that is withheld by the owner or project manager until certain conditions are met, such as completion of the project.

This practice is often used to ensure that the contractor completes the project to the owner's satisfaction and that any defects are corrected. In some jurisdictions, retainage is also used to protect the owner from potential losses due to contractor insolvency.

The amount of retainage can vary, but it's typically between 5% to 10% of the total contract value. This means that if a project has a contract value of $100,000, the contractor might be due $5,000 to $10,000 in retainage.

What is Retainage?

Retainage is a practice used by project owners to ensure quality work is completed before releasing full payment to a contractor.

In an attempt to remedy poor performance, project owners came up with the practice of retainage.

Credit: youtube.com, What is retainage in construction? [best practice + recovery options 2020]

Retainage involves withholding a portion of what is owed to a contractor for work performed until the contract is complete.

Project owners use retainage to offset completion costs in case the contractor falls into default.

Today, retainage rates typically fall between 5-10%.

The conditions for retainage still largely remain the same as they did in the 1840s.

If the work performed isn’t of sufficient quality or doesn’t match the scope of work, the project owner is within their right to withhold a portion of funds from any final payments.

On a similar theme: Contractor Payment Terms

History and Purpose

The practice of retainage has a rich history that dates back to the construction of the United Kingdom railway system in the 1840s. This was a time of rapid expansion, with hundreds of new construction companies entering the market to capitalize on the opportunity.

The size of the railway project increased demand for contractors, which led to the entrance of new contractors into the labor market. These new contractors were inexperienced and unable to successfully complete the project.

Credit: youtube.com, Understanding Retainage in the Construction Industry

The railway companies began to withhold as much as 20% of contractors' payments to ensure performance and offset completion costs should the contractor default. This was not intended to make the contractor and its subcontractors finance the project.

Retainage provisions have become a common approach in construction projects to mitigate the risk of something not going according to plan. The concept of retainage is unique to the construction industry and attempts to do two things: provide an incentive to the contractor or subcontractor to complete the project and protect the owner against any liens, claims or defaults.

Here are the key benefits of retainage:

  • Quality assurance: Retainage incentivizes the general contractor, along with any applicable subcontractors, to complete work to the satisfaction of the owner.
  • Defect correction: By withholding a portion of payments, retention provides the owner or general contractor with financial leverage to ensure the contractor addresses any defects, deficiencies or incomplete work.
  • Project completion: Retainage motivates contractors to complete their work within the agreed-upon schedule to avoid abandoning or leaving projects unfinished.

Impact and Benefits

Retainage, also known as retention, is a payment system used in the construction industry where a portion of the payment is withheld until the project is complete and satisfactory. This system is intended to encourage efficiency and productivity, but it has its drawbacks.

The contractor has a financial incentive to complete the project as early as possible to release the first moiety payment, and to minimize defects to achieve the second payment. Retentions held against sub-contractors are also a key source of cash for main contractors.

Consider reading: Complete Contract

Credit: youtube.com, Health impact of Semen retention explained by Dr of Chiropractic ®Fascial Manipulation Specialist.

Sub-contractors often complain about the system, citing a lack of a firm date on which retention monies will be paid. A 2017 British government report noted that more than half of contractors had experienced late or non-payment of retention monies.

Retainage offers several benefits for both owners and contractors, including risk mitigation, quality control, dispute resolution, and cost mitigation. For contractors and subcontractors, agreeing to retainage prior to engaging on a project often means an owner will not require a performance bond or other financial guarantee, resulting in significant cost savings.

The benefits of retainage can be summarized in the following ways:

  • Risk mitigation: Retainage helps mitigate the financial risks associated with contractor and subcontractor defaults, delays and/or incomplete or defective work.
  • Quality control: As a practice retainage encourages contractors to maintain a high quality of work throughout a project.
  • Dispute resolution: Retainage provides a financial cushion for owners to address disputes, deficiencies or disagreements that may arise during a project.
  • Cost mitigation: For contractors and subcontractors, agreeing to retainage prior to engaging on a project often means an owner will not require a performance bond or other financial guarantee.

Development and Laws

Retainage has a long history, dating back to the 1840s in the UK, where railway construction saw a rapid increase in contractors with little experience, leading to a rise in insolvencies and a drop in workmanship standards.

In the UK, railway companies began withholding 20% of payments to contractors as a security against incomplete and defective works, a practice that spread across the industry by the mid-19th century.

Credit: youtube.com, Retainage - LawPigeon Construction Law with Kelly Davis Esq

The 1994 Latham Report recommended legislation to protect retention monies held by a party, but this recommendation was omitted from the Construction Act 1998, and it wasn't until the Construction Act 2011 that the practice was reformed somewhat.

In the US, federal laws don't govern retainage on private sector construction projects, but state laws vary significantly, with some states having prompt payment laws that regulate how much can be withheld from contractors.

For example, in California, retainage is capped at 5% in the public sector, and in Texas, owners must hold retainage funds in an interest account.

In New Mexico, retainage is prohibited entirely for both private and public projects, but contractors in New Mexico may still encounter retainage in a different form, such as a "close out" line item in the schedule of values that allocates funds for completion.

Development in UK

In the UK, the 1840s saw a rapid increase in railway construction, but also a rise in insolvencies and a drop in workmanship standards.

Credit: youtube.com, Demystifying Building Regulations For UK Property Development | Landmark Estates

This led to railway companies withholding a minimum of 20% of payments to contractors as a security against incomplete and defective works.

The practice of withholding retention monies had spread across the industry by the mid-19th century.

The 1994 Latham Report recommended legislation to protect retention monies, but its recommendation was omitted from the Construction Act 1998.

The Construction Act 2011 reformed the practice by making it illegal to link the release of retention under one contract to that of a second.

This change ended the practice where contractors would refuse to release retention to sub-contractors until they had been paid it themselves by the client.

The 2018 collapse of contractor Carillion had a dramatic effect on the industry, resulting in £250 million in unpaid retention being lost when the business went into liquidation.

Broaden your view: Miller Act

The Law

State laws have a significant impact on how retainage is structured and applied to contracts. You must know how your state handles retainage and be on the lookout for any unique requirements.

Workers smoothing concrete on a construction site with heavy machinery equipment.
Credit: pexels.com, Workers smoothing concrete on a construction site with heavy machinery equipment.

In Texas, owners must hold retainage funds in an interest account, which can be invaluable in the event that funds are mishandled. In a worst-case scenario, you may need to enact your lien rights, but this should only be done when all other options have been exhausted.

Almost all states have prompt payment laws and other statutes that set retention limits and payment deadlines. These laws also set a deadline for the payment of retainage, though the timeline is typically based on the payment to the contractor's hiring party.

In California, state law caps retainage at 5% prior to completion and acceptance of the project. On public jobs in California, final and retainage payments are due to the prime contractor within 60 days of the project's final completion.

Retainage laws vary from state to state, with some states having vague regulations and others setting clear limits. In some rare circumstances, withholding money from contractors can actually be required by state law.

The U.S Department of Labor and the Fair Labor Standards Act make it clear that contractors and project owners must comply with their state's retainage laws. However, retainage laws vary significantly from state to state, with contrasting sets of requirements.

Indian construction workers at a site in Rasulpur, showcasing traditional attire and teamwork.
Credit: pexels.com, Indian construction workers at a site in Rasulpur, showcasing traditional attire and teamwork.

In California, retainage is capped at 5% in the public sector, and a contractor may substitute securities instead of retainage payments or request that payments be made into an escrow account. For private projects, retainage must be released within 45 days of the "date of completion."

In Texas, there's no maximum rate of retainage for public projects, but contracts with a retainage amount that's 5% and under $400,000 in contract value must have retainage funds deposited in an interest-bearing account. In the private sector, for any work that's eligible for a mechanic's lien, the project owner is required by law to retain 10% of either the contract price or the value of the work completed.

In New Mexico, retainage is prohibited for both private and public projects. However, contractors in New Mexico still encounter retainage in a different form, through a "close out" line item in the schedule of values that allocates funds for completion.

The contract between the owner and the general contractor, or that between the contractor and the subcontractor, is the most important thing governing the use of retainage on a project.

Here's an interesting read: Pension Funds Amendment Act, 2024

Alternatives and Strategies

Credit: youtube.com, Retention in Construction | The Good, The Bad & The Alternatives

You can use a trust account as an alternative to standard retainage provisions, where the owner withholds retainage and places it in a trust account with a trustee who has a fiduciary relationship to the contractor.

A trust account allows the contractor to have some control over its money and can even invest the retainage at the contractor's direction, freeing up funds that would normally sit idle in an escrow account.

Another option is to allow the contractor to supply substitute security to the owner, such as a performance bond, bank letter of credit, or a security of, or guaranteed by, the United States.

Performance bonds and letters of credit are two main alternatives owners or general contractors typically request in lieu of holding retainage on a construction contract.

A different take: Account Stated

Contractual Basis

The contractual basis of retainage is an important aspect to understand. The Joint Contracts Tribunal (JCT) contracts system allows for a reform of retentions by permitting the employer to hold retention monies in trust.

Construction workers engaging in tasks at an outdoor building site with safety hats and equipment.
Credit: pexels.com, Construction workers engaging in tasks at an outdoor building site with safety hats and equipment.

The 1998 revision of the JCT contract allowed contractors to request that clients hold the money in a separate bank account, and also permitted the use of retention bonds.

The 2016 JCT contract takes it a step further, allowing for retention-free projects.

The NEC Engineering and Construction Contract, introduced in 1993, has no allowance for retentions in its core clauses. However, retentions can be introduced by clients through variant clauses, known as "x clauses".

Here are some key contractual basis facts to keep in mind:

The specifics of retainage are usually detailed in the construction contract between the project owner and the contractor. This contract should clearly outline the retainage percentage, the schedule for progress payments, and the conditions under which the retained funds will be released.

Enforcement and Payment

Retainage is a crucial aspect of construction projects, and understanding how it works can make a big difference for contractors and subcontractors. Retainage provisions are typically set forth in the construction contract, and the amount withheld from the contractor or subcontractor should be determined on a case-by-case basis.

Credit: youtube.com, Understanding Construction Retainage: What It Is & Why It's Used

Retainage can be structured in various ways, with 10% being the most commonly used amount. Some contracts may start with a 10% retainage and reduce it to 5% once the project is 50% complete. This allows for a gradual release of funds as the project progresses.

Retainage is usually withheld from each progress payment, not just upfront. On a $100,000 contract with 10% retainage, the contractor would deduct $1,000 from each payment application, assuming 10 progress payments. This can help manage cash flow, but it's essential to understand the retainage process to avoid any issues.

Contractors have a right to collect payment, including retainage, at the end of the project. It's crucial to understand rights, responsibilities, and options when negotiating retention and collecting payment.

Here's an interesting read: Progress Billing Software

Abuse and Common Issues

Retainage abuse is a common issue in the construction industry. Subcontractors often bear the brunt of retainage provisions, especially those performing work early on in the project.

An elderly man with a beard reading a letter at a cozy indoor setting.
Credit: pexels.com, An elderly man with a beard reading a letter at a cozy indoor setting.

Contractors frequently withhold more retainage from subcontractors than they are being withheld from, causing significant financial distress. This can lead to delays in project closeout.

The owner's right to withhold retainage is often passed down to subcontractors, but they may not be able to recover the amount withheld until the project is substantially complete. This can take years, depending on the project size.

Contractors may withhold retainage at a greater percentage than the owner has withheld from them, causing a delay in the project closeout. This can create a situation where the contractor has to fund the balance of the payment from its own cash flow.

Abuse of retainage is common in the construction industry, often used as a means to "stay ahead" of subcontractors. This can involve underpaying contractors for work done and then withholding retainage.

High percentages of retainage are often withheld from contractors, and the money is held for a very long time. Contractors may have to make formal demands for retainage to receive their funds.

The rules and requirements surrounding retainage vary by state and project type, making it essential to understand the specific laws and regulations. Small mistakes can put contractors at risk for withholding money improperly or losing their retained funds.

Calculating and Managing Retainage

Credit: youtube.com, Retainage Options for Accounts Receivable - Acumatica Construction Edition

Calculating retainage is a straightforward process. You can calculate it by taking the agreed-upon percentage out of each payment. For instance, if you have a $50,000 contract with a 5% retainage, you'll withhold $500 from each of the five progress payments.

To calculate the total retainage amount, you multiply the contract price by the retainage percentage. In this example, that's $50,000 * 0.05 = $2,500. The retainage withheld from each progress payment is then $2,500 / 5 payments = $500.

You should plan and budget around retainage, considering it as a sunk cost. This means anticipating gaps in cash ahead of time and reallocating funds or scheduling labor more efficiently.

How Is Calculated?

Calculating retainage is relatively straightforward. You simply take the agreed-upon percentage out of each payment.

To calculate retainage, you can use the following formula: Total retainage amount = Contract price * Retainage percentage. For example, a $50,000 contract with a 5% retainage would be $50,000 * 0.05 = $2,500.

Construction Site Along The Road
Credit: pexels.com, Construction Site Along The Road

Retainage can be withheld from each progress payment, as seen in the example where $500 is withheld from each of the five progress payments. The total retainage amount withheld from all payments would be $2,500.

You can also use a table to calculate retainage, like this:

In this example, the total retainage amount withheld from all payments would be $2,500, and the total payment less retainage would be $47,500.

Factor It Into Your Cash Flow

Factor it into your cash flow needs. You can't budget jobs based on the face value of payments because retainage reduces the amount of cash coming in on each payment.

You must budget around the amount you'll receive less retainage. For example, a $10,000 payment at 10% retainage will result in a $1,000 gap.

Consider withheld funds as sunk costs as you're budgeting and bidding. This way, you can reallocate funds or schedule in a more labor-efficient manner.

Credit: youtube.com, Navigating the Retainage Payment Maze: How Retainage Impacts Cash Flow in Construction Projects

You can also look into and instigate financing options early so you can secure cash for job phases where you need it most. This is especially important if profit margins are tight, which they often are.

In certain situations, you may need to seek financing options to meet your cash needs. Better to identify and plan for this ahead of time rather than halfway through a job.

You can also look into subcontractor performance bonds or retainage bonds as a unique alternative to traditional retainage.

Work with an Accountant

Working with an accountant can be a huge relief for business owners, especially when it comes to managing retainage. They can help with payment apps, tax considerations, and cash flow management.

As a business owner, you can't do it all on your own, and an accountant can point you in the right direction. Consider creating a contingency or emergency fund to supplement cash shortages created by retainage.

This reserve of cash can be a lifesaver in the event that you never receive your retainage payments. In that case, it can help you bear the brunt of lost income without it wreaking havoc on your operations.

If this caught your attention, see: Legal Help with Debt Collectors

Streamlining Processes from Planning to Payments

A busy construction site with scaffolding, steel structures, and workers.
Credit: pexels.com, A busy construction site with scaffolding, steel structures, and workers.

Retainage can be negotiated in contracts, allowing for flexibility in withheld amounts over the length of the contract. This can be a game-changer for contractors who need to cover up-front costs for construction materials with lower margins.

Variable retainage can be used to reduce withheld amounts as the contract progresses, or even pay out entirely once the contractor's portion of work is complete. This can help contractors manage their finances more effectively.

Contractors can negotiate a better retention percentage by making concessions in another part of the contract, or they may choose to walk away from the project entirely if they don't agree with the suggested rate.

Having the right legal forms on hand can make a big difference in getting paid for your work. You may need to send specific notices and legal documents to maintain your rights to claim retainage.

It's common for retainage to get withheld from contractors on construction jobs. Retainage is often required to be held by the general contractor, owner, developer, or lender until the project is complete and all work is satisfactory.

Close-up photo of hands holding a blank black card, perfect for mockup or template purposes.
Credit: pexels.com, Close-up photo of hands holding a blank black card, perfect for mockup or template purposes.

Sending a free retainage demand letter can be a good way to remind them of their obligation to pay you. This letter can help you stay ahead of the game and prevent them from sitting on the retainage waiting for you to take action.

Free retainage forms and legal notices are available to help you navigate this process.

You might enjoy: Legal Help on a Contract

Frequently Asked Questions

Is retainage an asset?

Yes, retainage can be classified as a contract asset, representing an entity's right to future consideration. This classification applies when the right to payment is dependent on factors other than time.

Archie Strosin

Senior Writer

Archie Strosin is a seasoned writer with a keen eye for detail and a deep interest in financial institutions. His work often delves into the history and operations of Missouri-based banks, providing readers with a comprehensive understanding of their roles in the local economy. A particular focus of his research is on Dickinson Financial Corporation and Armed Forces Bank, tracing their origins and evolution over the decades.

Love What You Read? Stay Updated!

Join our community for insights, tips, and more.