
Relational contracts are a type of agreement that relies on the ongoing relationship between parties to determine the terms of the contract. This means that the contract is not just a written document, but also includes unwritten understandings and expectations that arise from the relationship.
The key characteristic of relational contracts is that they are flexible and adaptable, allowing the parties to adjust the terms of the contract as needed. For example, a contract between a manufacturer and a supplier may include a clause that allows for price adjustments based on market fluctuations.
In a relational contract, the parties often rely on trust and good faith to resolve disputes and make decisions. This can be seen in a contract between a landlord and a tenant, where the landlord may rely on the tenant's good faith to pay rent on time.
Relational contracts can be more effective than traditional contracts in certain situations because they allow for a more nuanced and flexible approach to problem-solving.
Suggestion: Good Faith (law)
Examples

Relational contracts are used in various industries, including construction and public services. The Integrated Form of Agreement (IFoA) is a notable example in the US, developed for Sutter Health projects in California and used by other healthcare providers.
In the UK, the High Court recognized a relational contract between the Post Office and its sub-postmasters in 2019. This contract imposed an implied duty of good faith on both parties.
Relational contracts can be found in various forms, such as the Alliancing Agreement in Australia, the Integrated Project Delivery Agreement in the US, and the New Engineering Contract (NEC) in the UK.
The following examples illustrate the use of relational contracts:
- Integrated Form of Agreement (IFoA) (USA)
- Alliancing Agreement (Australia)
- New Engineering Contract (NEC) (UK)
In addition to these examples, relational contracts have been used in government projects, such as the transformation of a former weapons facility to a wildlife refuge in the US.
Approach and Methodology
Relational contracts are not just about getting a deal done, but about building a strong relationship with your contracting partners. This approach is particularly useful in complex situations where traditional, transactional contracts may not be sufficient.

In such cases, relational contracts can aid the contracting process by allowing for adaptation and flexibility. For example, when dealing with complex goods and services like delivering social support to a vulnerable population, relational contracts can help navigate the challenges of specifying exactly what is needed, how much it will cost, and how to verify delivery.
Relational contracts can also help maintain focus on overarching goals, rather than getting bogged down in specific methods of reaching them. This is especially important in changeable environments, where external forces may change the requirements of a service or the ability of a provider to deliver it at the expected cost.
To make relational contracts work, it's essential to focus on the relationship rather than the deal. This involves creating and nurturing a partnership, rather than maintaining an arms-length relationship.
Here are the 9 Tenets of Relational Contracts:
- Communication
- Risk management
- Open problem-solving
- Avoidance of blame culture
- Collaborative working across agreement parties
- ‘Gain and pain’ sharing
- Common goals & objectives
- Clear performance metrics
- Pursuit of continuous improvement
These tenets provide a foundation for building strong relationships with contracting partners. By following these principles, you can create a framework for relational contracts that fosters collaboration, trust, and mutual benefit.
Trust and Partnership

Developing trust is a crucial aspect of relational contracts. It allows for cooperation and communication between parties, making it easier to adapt to changing circumstances.
In relational contracts, trust can be built over time through mutual commitment and extensive cooperation. This is particularly important in complex or rapidly changing environments, where rigid contracts can be limiting.
Relational contracts can be more accommodating than traditional contracts, allowing for flexibility and adaptability. This is in contrast to traditional contracts, which can be overly prescriptive and restrictive.
Developing trust in a relational contract requires investment from both parties. This can include time and resources spent on building relationships and negotiating during the contract.
Relational contracts can be more practical than traditional contracts, especially in complex or rapidly changing environments. This is because they allow for flexibility and adaptability, rather than trying to anticipate every contingency.
A finding that a contract is relational can have a significant impact on how the contract is interpreted. This can make it more difficult to rely on a very narrow, strict construction.
Recommended read: Time and Materials

Obligations of good faith are often implied in relational contracts. This means that parties should avoid conduct that is commercially unacceptable.
In summary, trust and partnership are essential components of relational contracts. They allow for cooperation and communication, flexibility and adaptability, and can lead to better outcomes for both parties.
Broaden your view: Relational Capital
Challenges and Risks
Relational contracts can be a great way to build trust and long-term relationships with partners, but they're not without their challenges. Opportunism is a major risk, where one party may try to advance their own interests at the expense of others.
Relational contracts can sometimes appear like improper collusion, which can complicate scrutiny of public contracts and make it harder to identify and protect against corruption. Even without actual corruption, the mere accusation can undermine the contractual relationship.
Strict procurement rules can make it harder to build trust-based, long-term relationships with a provider. These rules aim to limit corruption and maximize value for money, but they can also create obstacles for relational contracts.
You might like: How to Make a Legal Contract without a Lawyer

Interpreting the meaning of relational contracts can be tricky, as parties may come to different conclusions about what the shared principles actually mean. This can lead to misunderstandings and disputes.
Power asymmetries exist in all contracts, but they can be magnified in relational contracts where one party has more power than the other. This can lead to abuse by the more powerful party.
Building trust in relational contracts requires a significant investment of time and resources, which can be a barrier for some parties. This investment may not be feasible for parties required to make large and specific investments.
Relational contracts also come with transaction costs, such as building trust and undergoing negotiations during delivery. These costs must be weighed against the benefits of a relational approach.
Staff turnover can be a major setback for relational contracts, as the trust that sustains them is grounded in personal relationships between individuals. Frequent or dramatic changes in key stakeholders can disrupt the process of building and maintaining trust.
Here are some of the challenges with relational contracts:
- Opportunism
- Scrutiny and corruption
- Restrictive procurement rules
- Misunderstanding
- Unequal power dynamics
- High up-front investment
- Transaction costs
- Staff turnover
Trust and Opportunism

Trust is a crucial element in relational contracts, but it's not a free ride. Developing and maintaining trust comes with a cost, referred to as transaction costs.
These costs include the time and effort needed to build trust before and during a contract, as well as the ongoing negotiations that can arise. The more complex or innovative the product or service, the higher the transaction costs are likely to be.
In complex situations, relational contracts can be a practical solution to avoid the impossible task of anticipating every contingency. However, the costs of trust-building and negotiation must be weighed against the benefits of contracting relationally.
Broaden your view: Secured Transaction
Misunderstanding and Misinterpretation
Misunderstanding and Misinterpretation can be a significant challenge in relational contracts.
A commitment to shared principles can help parties navigate uncertainty, but it's a big assumption that they'll agree on what those principles mean.
Parties may believe they agree on a set of principles, but their organisational backgrounds and priorities can influence how they interpret them.

Judgment is required to interpret what broad principles mean in practice, and vagueness can provoke disputes.
For example, putting the service user at the heart of all decisions can be open to interpretation, especially when it comes to balancing the number of people served and the intensity of service provided.
Unless accompanied by specific stipulations, such vagueness can lead to disputes that work against a productive relationship.
Are Opportunism's Consequences Intolerable After Trust Breach?
Opportunism can lead to severe consequences after a trust breach, such as a complete breakdown of relationships.
Trust is a fragile thing, and once it's broken, it's extremely difficult to repair.
Research has shown that trust breaches can lead to a permanent loss of trust, making it challenging to regain the trust of others.
In fact, a study found that 60% of people who experience a trust breach will never fully trust the other person again.
A single instance of opportunism can have long-lasting effects on relationships, making it essential to address the issue promptly.
The consequences of opportunism can be so severe that they may even lead to the end of a business partnership or a friendship.
Ultimately, the consequences of opportunism after a trust breach can be intolerable, making it crucial to prioritize trust and transparency in all interactions.
Related reading: Legal Remedies for Breach of Contract
Shared Principles in Written Documentation
Shared principles are explicitly stated in written contract documentation, forming a key part of a relational contract.
These principles dictate the overarching aims of the collaboration and the way organisations will behave and interact with one another.
Relational contracting experts David Frydlinger, Oliver Hart, and Kate Vitasek have articulated six principles that parties should commit to in order to guide the terms of the relationship and avoid a breakdown.
The authors argue that if both parties adhere to these principles, the scope for conflict ought to be minimised.
In the case of a 'formal relational contract', principles would form the basis for judicial intervention, with the courts being asked to interpret whether a particular principle had been breached by a party's actions.
Whether principles are really enforceable in this way is the subject of debate, and may depend on the legal traditions of a particular country or context.
By committing to shared principles, parties can create a framework for addressing grievances and building a positive relationship based on mutual understanding and respect.
Featured Images: pexels.com


