
Management entrenchment can have a significant impact on shareholder value, as seen in the case of Enron, where the company's executives manipulated financial statements to hide debt and inflate profits, ultimately leading to a massive loss for investors.
The consequences of management entrenchment can be severe, with companies experiencing declining stock prices, reduced investor confidence, and even bankruptcy.
A key factor contributing to management entrenchment is the presence of golden parachutes, which can provide executives with a significant financial incentive to prioritize their own interests over those of shareholders, as seen in the case of Tyco International's former CEO, Dennis Kozlowski, who received a $100 million severance package.
This can create a situation where executives become insulated from accountability, making it difficult for shareholders to hold them responsible for poor performance or unethical behavior.
Recommended read: Good Case Management Practices
What is Management Entrenchment
Management entrenchment is a phenomenon where executives prioritize their own interests over the well-being of the company and its shareholders. This can lead to a range of negative consequences, including decreased productivity and profitability.
Executives who are entrenched in their positions may engage in behaviors that benefit themselves, but harm the company. For example, they may pursue unnecessary acquisitions to grow their own power and influence.
Empire building is a common sign of entrenchment, where executives focus on expanding their departments or teams, rather than driving value for the company. This can lead to a bloated and inefficient organization.
Personal perks are another indication of entrenchment, where executives use company resources to fund their own lavish lifestyles. This can include expensive offices, luxury travel, or other benefits that are not aligned with the company's goals.
Strategic obstruction is a more subtle sign of entrenchment, where executives block changes or initiatives that could threaten their control or influence. This can include blocking restructuring efforts, mergers and acquisitions, or leadership changes.
Here are some common signs of management entrenchment:
- Empire building: Pursuing unnecessary acquisitions to grow headcount or budget, not value.
- Personal perks: Investing in lavish offices or executive benefits.
- Strategic obstruction: Blocking restructuring, M&A deals, or leadership changes that threaten their control.
Prevention and Mitigation
Management entrenchment is not a rare issue, and it's something that companies and investors can take steps to prevent.
One way to do this is by implementing concrete strategies to guard against management entrenchment. Three such strategies include using poison pills, supermajority voting requirements, and staggered board elections.
A Case Study: An Unseen Fire

Entrenchment can start with a single manager, not just CEOs or founders. This subtle form of entrenchment can fly under the radar until it's too late.
A manager, recently hired after being dismissed from a previous role, can join a new company with a hidden agenda. He may replace competent team members with familiar allies from past jobs, creating a closed circle of loyalty.
By purchasing a modest amount of equity, the manager can project alignment with shareholders, but not enough to feel real downside risk. This can be a clever tactic to gain influence without taking on too much responsibility.
As the manager restructures reporting lines, other departments funnel through his own, consolidating his influence. Top performers may leave, morale drops, and productivity erodes. Favoritism replaces meritocracy, and a dysfunctional culture takes hold.
By the time senior leadership realizes the damage, it's too late. The fire is already spreading, and the shareholders foot the bill.
How to Prevent
Preventing management entrenchment requires a proactive approach. Management entrenchment is not rare—and it is preventable.
Companies can use concrete strategies to guard against it. Three strategies include having a diverse board of directors, implementing a poison pill, and establishing a robust shareholder rights plan.
A diverse board of directors can help prevent management entrenchment by bringing different perspectives to the table. This can lead to more informed decision-making and a reduced likelihood of management entrenchment.
Implementing a poison pill can also be an effective strategy. A poison pill is a provision that makes it difficult for an outside entity to acquire a majority of a company's shares.
Establishing a robust shareholder rights plan is another key strategy. This plan can help protect shareholders' interests and prevent management from abusing their power.
For your interest: Retirement Plan Portfolio Manager Tiaa Management Fee
Best Practices and Commitment
To prevent management entrenchment, it's essential to have a clear and well-defined succession plan in place. This plan should identify potential successors and provide a clear path for them to take over leadership roles.
Expand your knowledge: Credit Counseling Debt Management Plan
A company that failed to do this, as seen in the case of the CEO who held onto power for 20 years, can lead to stagnation and a lack of innovation. This can result in the company falling behind its competitors.
Regular performance reviews and feedback can help prevent the buildup of power and keep management accountable. By doing so, you can identify areas for improvement and make necessary changes before it's too late.
A different take: How to Check Battery Capacity of Power Bank
Build Culture Decentralized
Building a decentralized culture is crucial to preventing entrenchment in an organization. This approach dilutes the ability of any one person to dominate or distort a company's operations.
Decentralization requires managers to earn authority through execution, not internal maneuvering. It makes it harder for entrenched behavior to scale across departments.
A healthy, non-political workplace is characterized by reduced "rancor" - a subtle but important signal of a company's well-being. This is evident in the culture of Capital Cities, which outperformed the S&P 500 by nearly 10 percentage points annually from 1966 to 1995.
For more insights, see: Kyc Registered - Modify Kyc
To achieve decentralization, companies should hire deliberately, at every level. This means placing enormous emphasis on recruitment and developing a rigorous hiring framework to reduce risk.
Early-stage companies, in particular, cannot afford to delegate hiring to others too quickly. The wrong hire in a critical role can quietly corrode a company from within.
Require Co-Investment
Requiring co-investment from management is a best practice that can greatly benefit a company. This approach creates real ownership, which is a key factor in aligning interests between shareholders and management.
Family-run businesses often outperform peers due to this reason, as they make up 30-40% of large global companies according to Credit Suisse.
Corporate Governance Commitment
Corporate governance is crucial for the success of any company. Boards of directors should take a close look at the size of bidder termination fees and examine fees in comparable deals.
Research suggests that high bidder termination fees are associated with destruction of shareholder value and lead to more entrenchment. This means that managers who implement high fees might be trying to ensure the completion of deals that benefit themselves, but not the company.
Check this out: How to Avoid Currency Conversion Fees
Family-run businesses often outperform peers because the operator is also an owner, creating real ownership and aligning incentives with long-term value creation. This is a great example of how corporate governance can be effective when ownership and management are aligned.
Managers who are not yet entrenched can enter into deals that benefit themselves, even if the board and shareholders have the power to reject them. They can do this by using their discretion over transaction contracts and implementing bidder termination fees.
Shareholders should elect board members with experience in deal law and not be constrained by serving on multiple boards. This can help prevent collusion between managers and their deal advisers.
Conclusion and Practical Implications
Entrenchment-increasing deals can have devastating effects on shareholders, leading to destruction of shareholder value and more entrenchment. The study by Bates and Lemmon (2003) found a link between high bidder termination fees and the completion of such deals.
High bidder termination fees can serve as a device for managers to ensure the completion of entrenchment-increasing deals. This is particularly concerning when managers have a high probability of being replaced.
Board members should carefully negotiate the size of bidder termination fees, examining fees in comparable deals to ensure fairness. They should also be aware of potential collusion between managers and their deal advisers.
Shareholders should elect board members with experience in the legal aspects of a deal and who are not time-constrained, serving on no more than one or two boards outside the firm. This can help prevent entrenchment and promote more responsible deal-making.
Regulators should consider limiting the size of bidder termination fees to prevent their misuse by managers. By taking these steps, we can help prevent the destructive effects of entrenchment-increasing deals and promote a healthier corporate governance environment.
Recommended read: Can Quickbooks Automatically Add Credit Card Fees
Cost and Governance
Management entrenchment can be a costly issue for companies, with one study showing that entrenched executives can cost their companies up to 30% more than their non-entrenched counterparts.
Executive compensation packages can be a major driver of entrenchment, as seen in the case of a major tech firm where the CEO's compensation package was valued at over $200 million. This kind of compensation can make it difficult for boards to remove executives who are not performing.
Research has shown that companies with entrenched executives tend to have lower returns on equity and lower stock market performance. For example, a study of 200 large-cap companies found that those with entrenched CEOs had a 10% lower return on equity than those without.
In some cases, entrenched executives can even use their power to influence the company's governance structure, making it more difficult for shareholders to hold them accountable.
Research and Contribution
We contribute to current research in management entrenchment by demonstrating how CEOs can exploit their discretion over contracts to undertake entrenchment-increasing M&A deals.
This complements Masulis, Wang, and Xie (2007) and prior theoretical work by Shleifer and Vishny (1989).
Our research adds to the M&A literature by investigating how bidder termination fees affect the acquirer's stock returns at deal announcement.
We also introduce a novel measure to better capture potential wealth effects should bidder termination fees be paid.
Prior literature scales termination fees by transaction value; we scale bidder termination fees by an acquiring firm's market capitalization to assess the potential negative economic impact on an acquirer's value.
Excessively high bidder termination fees are associated with shareholder value destruction if a deal is meant to be entrenchment-increasing, signaling agency problems between managers and their shareholders.
Our results deliver an argument to closely monitor the setting and to restrict the size of bidder termination fees.
This research contributes to the growing literature at the intersection of law and finance.
Suggestion: Investment Manager Research
Featured Images: pexels.com


