The Rise and Fall of Brandless Everyday Essentials

Author

Reads 12K

A beautiful minimalist arrangement of a jade roller, brush, and cosmetic tube on a white background.
Credit: pexels.com, A beautiful minimalist arrangement of a jade roller, brush, and cosmetic tube on a white background.

Brandless Everyday Essentials was a line of products that aimed to disrupt the traditional retail model by offering affordable, high-quality essentials without the brand markup. The brand focused on simplicity and transparency, with a minimalist approach to packaging and labeling.

In 2018, Brandless launched its Everyday Essentials line, which included over 300 products, from household items to personal care products. The products were sold directly to consumers through the brand's website and select retail partners.

The brand's goal was to make everyday essentials more accessible and affordable for everyone, with prices starting at just $3. The products were designed to be free from artificial preservatives, flavors, and colors, making them a popular choice for health-conscious consumers.

Expand your knowledge: Animoca Brand Unicorn

Worth a look: PlanetOut Inc.

What Went Right

Brandless was a millennial-friendly direct-to-consumer (“DTC”) consumer-packaged-goods (“CPG”) company selling everything from $3 quinoa puffs to $200 blenders.

They received heavy media attention upon launch for their universal $3 price point for all food and personal care products.

Broaden your view: TSG Consumer Partners

Credit: youtube.com, Purpose-Driven Disruption - Tina Sharkey

The founders are impressive, with CEO and Co-Founder Sharkey being a former executive at BabyCenter and AOL, and Co-Founder Ido Leffler being a serial entrepreneur with a history of successful startups.

Fellow DTC ‘rat pack counterparts’ to Brandless — including Warby Parker, Away, and Glossier — have all raised similar sums of money to Brandless.

Brandless and Facebook both raised similar amounts of capital in a similar time frame.

The founders' experience and reputation likely played a role in Brandless' early success and media attention.

Brandless' innovative approach to pricing and product offerings generated significant buzz and interest in the market.

Their ability to scale and maintain a strong brand presence in the competitive DTC space was a notable achievement.

Here's an interesting read: Jd Vance Founders Fund

Financial Issues

Brandless had a major issue with cash flow troubles.

Their average order value was only $34, which is less than the $39 needed for free shipping.

Brandless relied heavily on paid and influencer marketing, but customer acquisition costs in those channels have increased significantly over the last 2-3 years.

A whopping 70% of Brandless' first-time customers placed only a single order, and only 20% returned in the next quarter.

This suggests that Brandless was hemorrhaging cash, depending on post-first order customer lifetime value and high purchase frequency to become profitable.

Recommended read: Capital One Spark Cash

Cashflow Troubles

Credit: youtube.com, Cash Flow Problems? Understand what REALLY impacts your cash

Scaling a business before unit economics make sense can lead to financial troubles, especially for companies selling physical goods.

Many eCommerce and DTC companies struggle with poor unit economics, particularly those relying on paid and influencer marketing to acquire customers.

Customer acquisition costs (CAC) in paid and influencer marketing have increased significantly over the last 2-3 years.

Brandless' average order value was reported to be only $34 in 2018, less than the $39 needed for free shipping.

Low margin products combined with a low average order value can lead to cash hemorrhaging.

Only 20% of customers who placed their first order with Brandless in Q2 2018 returned in Q3, and 70% of first-time customers placed only a single order.

Getting rid of low-margin products, such as food, can be a sign of unit economic issues.

Brandless' decision to jump on the CBD trend and release pricey CBD personal care products, some of which were over $60, was a massive departure from their initial low-price strategy.

$50M Funding: Everyday Essentials for $3 Each

Stacked orange plastic products displayed in a retail store setting.
Credit: pexels.com, Stacked orange plastic products displayed in a retail store setting.

Imagine being able to stock up on everyday essentials for just $3 each. Recently, a company received $50M in funding to make this a reality.

This innovative approach to affordability is a game-changer for many families who struggle to make ends meet.

With a budget of just $3 per item, you can stock up on non-perishable food items, toiletries, and household supplies.

In fact, a common grocery list includes items like rice, pasta, canned goods, and toilet paper – all of which can be purchased for under $3 each.

Readers also liked: Just Eat Takeaway.com

An Impossible Valuation

Brandless is a prime example of investors applying a pure technology valuation to a non-technology company, which is a flawed strategy. This approach is leading to negative consequences, as seen in Casper's down round IPO in January.

A pure technology company can exponentially grow profits at scale with little to no incremental cost, but Brandless, which sells physical goods, can't achieve this.

Facebook is a great example of a pure technology company, but Brandless is not.

Peer competitors to Brandless, like Thrive Market and Public Goods, have raised far less money and are still in operation.

Thrive Market is thriving, despite the challenges faced by Brandless.

Market Competition

Credit: youtube.com, Brandless Is Disrupting the Grocery Store With $3 Products | NowThis

SoftBank's troubles had a significant impact on Brandless, accelerating existing issues at the company. SoftBank was also heavily invested in WeWork, which failed to go public in September, leaving SoftBank with a huge write-off.

The failed WeWork IPO likely put pressure on SoftBank to scrutinize its other investments, including Brandless. This increased pressure likely contributed to Brandless' existing problems.

Amazon's purchase of Whole Foods just before Brandless launched was a major setback for the company, as it highlighted the intense competition in the market.

A unique perspective: SoftBank Group

SoftBank Woes and Amazon Competition

SoftBank's troubles accelerated existing issues at Brandless, making it harder for them to succeed.

SoftBank, Brandless' biggest backer, was also the biggest investor in WeWork, which failed to go public last September.

The failed WeWork IPO resulted in SoftBank being forced to give WeWork a $9.5B lifeline or take a pricey write-off on their $10.4B investment.

Post-WeWork IPO, SoftBank likely placed heavy pressure and scrutiny on the rest of its portfolio companies, including Brandless.

Amazon's purchase of Whole Foods one month before Brandless launched is a classic example of bad timing for Brandless.

See what others are reading: Ripple Labs Ipo

Can an Internet-Born Competitor to P&G Succeed?

Credit: youtube.com, Unilever vs. P&G: How CPG Giants Fight Competition from Innovative Startups

To succeed, an internet-born competitor to P&G needs to maintain a profitable average order value and recoup customer acquisition costs within 60 days to manage cash flow. Brandless attempted to recoup some CAC quicker by launching a subscription model in 2019.

A digitally-native CPG conglomerate can succeed if it can charge a premium for higher quality products and manage cash flow effectively. Thrive Market charges a $60 annual upfront membership fee to help cover CAC and manage cash flow.

Scaling too quickly before being ready can hurt a business, as Brandless found out. Scaling before they were ready would have only hurt the situation further.

A profitable business model is critical for success, and unit economics play a big role in determining this. Even with great marketing, business models whose profitability won't grow exponentially as revenue does can struggle.

It's not impossible for an internet-born competitor to P&G to succeed, but it's a tough game. Brandless made some big swings, but only hindsight can tell us that some key swings were a miss.

For more insights, see: International Business Companies Act

Wrongly Positioned as Generic Brand

Credit: youtube.com, Bowman’s Strategy Clock: Navigating Competitive Positioning

Positioning is key to standing out in a crowded market. Brandless, a company that aimed to provide high-quality products at fair prices, got it wrong.

Their name was meant to position the company as a modern brand, but it ended up being perceived as an anti-brand or generic brand by consumers. This perception put Brandless in the same category as cheap private label brands.

The reaction on Twitter after the shutdown news showed that many consumers saw Brandless as a generic brand, not a unique brand. This was a major misfire, as Brandless had a strong value proposition that got lost in the name.

Brandless' actual differentiation was making high-quality, sustainable products for less, but this message got lost in the generic brand perception. They had a solid competitive advantage with their sustainable business practices and catering to popular wellness lifestyles.

It's hard to course correct when your very name becomes a liability, but it's not impossible.

A different take: Megmilk Snow Brand

Brand Strategy

Credit: youtube.com, Being a Brand in a Brandless Category (Teaser): The Brave Marketer Podcast (S510)

The Brandless-as-a-Brand strategy was a case study in what happens when your brand name becomes one of your biggest liabilities.

Brandless positioned itself against the "brand tax", throwing weight behind a launch campaign aimed at eliminating this perceived cost.

The campaign was a masterclass in startup PR, but it ultimately backfired.

The name Brandless was intended to position the company as a more modern brand, not as a generic brand.

However, consumers misunderstood the brand's positioning and saw Brandless as an anti-brand or generic brand, similar to those from Amazon or Target.

This perception put Brandless in the business of making generic goods for cheap, which was not a game they could easily win.

The brand's unique selling proposition was defined by consumers on price and distribution, areas where Brandless had no sustainable advantage.

A different take: Alm. Brand

Customer Loyalty

Loyal customers expect high-quality basics at a simple and lower price point.

Brandless had loyal fans, but a sudden shift in product offerings and elimination of the popular food line was a blow to customer loyalty.

Credit: youtube.com, Brandless Haul

The average order value at Brandless needed to increase from $48 to $70 or $80, according to CEO John Rittenhouse.

This drastic change in product offerings was a calculated move, but it ultimately led to a backlash from loyal customers.

A quick look at third-party review website TrustPilot shows the discontentment among customers.

The sudden shift in product offerings may have been an irrecoverable blow to customer loyalty.

Company Issues

Brandless struggled with a series of leadership issues, starting with the departure of CEO and Co-Founder Tina Sharkey in early 2019.

Sharkey had previously stepped down as CEO, leaving the board of directors altogether later that year.

The company laid off 13% of its workforce following Sharkey's departure.

New CEO John Rittenhouse, a former COO of Walmart, stepped down after only a six-month tenure in late 2019.

The constant change in leadership may have contributed to the company's struggles.

Brandless' reliance on a "brandless as a brand" strategy may have misfired, but it's difficult to say for certain.

Credit: youtube.com, Brandless co-founders want to offer fewer options -- not more

The company's unprofitable unit economics only got worse as they scaled.

Brandless received heavy media attention upon launch for their universal $3 price point for all food and personal care products.

This strategy may have been a key factor in their downfall, but it's not the only issue at play.

The company's founders, including CEO Sharkey and Co-Founder Ido Leffler, are experienced entrepreneurs with impressive backgrounds.

However, even the most experienced founders can't guarantee success.

A different take: Founders Fund

What Is Brandless?

Brandless is a company that sells products without a brand name, aiming to cut out the costs associated with traditional branding. They claim to save customers around 40% of the "BrandTax".

Their model is simple: everything in their store costs just $3. This makes it easy to shop and budget.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the website where everything is $3?

Brandless is an online store offering a wide range of products at affordable prices, all for $3 or less. Explore their website for everyday essentials and more at unbeatable prices

Is Brandless a good brand?

Brandless is a good choice for those prioritizing product efficacy over brand name, offering effective products at reasonable prices. Their products deliver well, making them a great option for those seeking quality without the premium price tag.

Sean Dooley

Lead Writer

Sean Dooley is a seasoned writer with a passion for crafting engaging content. With a strong background in research and analysis, Sean has developed a keen eye for detail and a talent for distilling complex information into clear, concise language. Sean's portfolio includes a wide range of articles on topics such as accounting services, where he has demonstrated a deep understanding of financial concepts and a ability to communicate them effectively to diverse audiences.

Love What You Read? Stay Updated!

Join our community for insights, tips, and more.