How to Check for Extraneous Solutions?

Author Mollie Sherman

Posted Sep 6, 2022

Reads 129

Clear Light Bulb

In solving a system of equations, we are looking for the values of the variables that make all of the equations true. However, sometimes we can find so-called "extraneous solutions" - values of the variables that make one or more of the equations true, but not all of them. In other words, these are values that satisfy one equation but not the others.

There are a few different ways to check for extraneous solutions. One way is to plug the values back into the equations and see if they work. If they do, then they're probably not extraneous. However, this method can be time-consuming, so there are a few shortcuts that can be used.

For example, if we are solving a system of two equations with two variables, we can graph the equations. If the lines intersect at one point, then we know that the point of intersection is a solution to both equations (and so it's not extraneous). However, if the lines are parallel, then there is no solution to the system - meaning that any purported solution is actually extraneous.

Similarly, if we are solving a system of three equations with three variables, we can use the Elimination Method. This involves solving two of the equations for one of the variables, and then eliminating that variable from the third equation. If we end up with a true statement, then we know that there is no solution to the system and any purported solution is extraneous.

Of course, these are just a few of the methods that can be used to check for extraneous solutions. There are many others, and the best method to use will depend on the specific system of equations that you're working with. However, these methods should give you a good starting point.

What is an extraneous solution?

An extraneous solution is a solution that is not necessary to the problem. It may be a solution that is not possible, or one that makes the problem more difficult. It is often caused by a mistake in solving the problem, or by using a method that is not appropriate to the problem.

How can you tell if a solution is extraneous?

An extraneous solution is a solution that is not required to solve the problem. In other words, it is a "solution" that is not a solution. There are a few ways to tell if a solution is extraneous.

One way to tell if a solution is extraneous is to substitute it back into the original equation. If the solution does not make the equation true, it is extraneous. For example, consider the equation 2x + 3 = 11. One possible solution to this equation is x = 4. However, if we substitute 4 back into the equation, we get 2(4) + 3 = 11, which is not true. Therefore, 4 is an extraneous solution.

Another way to tell if a solution is extraneous is to look at the graph of the equation. If the solution does not make the graph go through the point (0,0), it is extraneous. For example, consider the equation y = 5x + 3. One possible solution to this equation is x = -2. However, if we graph the equation, we can see that the point (-2,3) does not lie on the graph. Therefore, -2 is an extraneous solution.

Extraneous solutions can be tricky to spot, but if you remember these two methods, you should be able to tell if a solution is extraneous.

Why are extraneous solutions a problem?

An extraneous solution is a solution to a problem that is not the intended solution, or is not the simplest or most efficient solution. Extraneous solutions can be a problem because they can mislead people into thinking that they have found the correct solution to a problem when they have not. They can also cause people to waste time and effort on solutions that will not work.

What can happen if you don't check for extraneous solutions?

If you don't check for extraneous solutions when solving a system of equations, you may end up with a false solution. This is because extraneous solutions are solutions that satisfy one or more of the equations in the system, but do not satisfy all of the equations. Therefore, they are not true solutions to the system.

If you mistakenly believe that an extraneous solution is a true solution, you may make errors in your work or in your understanding of the problem. This can lead to incorrect results and flawed conclusions. In some cases, it can even lead to dangerous or life-threatening decisions.

For example, consider a system of equations that represents a chemical reaction. If you incorrectly identify an extraneous solution as a true solution, you may mix the wrong chemicals together. This could cause a explosion or release of toxic fumes.

In short, it is very important to check for extraneous solutions when solving a system of equations. Failure to do so can lead to inaccurate results and potentially dangerous consequences.

How do you check for extraneous solutions when solving a rational equation?

There are a few different ways that you can check for extraneous solutions when solving a rational equation. One way is to simply plug the values back into the original equation and see if they work. If they don't, then you know that those values are not solutions to the equation. Another way is to graph the equation on a graphing calculator or on a piece of graph paper. If there are any points that don't lie on the line, then those are not solutions to the equation.

It is also important to be careful when solving rational equations because sometimes you can accidentally introduce extraneous solutions. For example, if you multiply both sides of an equation by a common denominator, you might end up with an equation that has more solutions than the original equation. In particular, you need to be careful when multiplying both sides of an equation by a variable. For instance, consider the equation . If we multiply both sides of this equation by , we get . Now this new equation has the extraneous solution . So, you need to be careful that you don't accidentally introduce extraneous solutions when solving rational equations.

What is the process for checking for extraneous solutions?

When solving a system of linear equations, you might sometimes come across what is called an extraneous solution. This is a solution that satisfies one equation in the system, but does not satisfy all of them. In other words, it is a solution that works for one equation, but not for the others.

To check for extraneous solutions, you will want to solve each equation in the system for the variable that is not in that equation. For example, if you have the equations 2x+3y=5 and 3x+5y=7, you would want to solve the first equation for y:

2x+3y=5

y=5-2x

=5-(2*3)

=5-6

=-1

You would then plug this value of y back into both equations and see if it is a solution for both. In this case, it is not:

2x+3*-1=5

2x-3=5

2x=8

x=4

3x+5*-1=7

3*4+5*-1=7

12+5*-1=7

12-5=7

7=7

This is not a solution because x does not equal 4 in both equations.

You can use this same process to check for extraneous solutions in any system of linear equations. Just solve each equation for a different variable and plug the solutions back into all of the equations to see if they work. If they do not, then you have found an extraneous solution.

What are some common mistakes people make when checking for extraneous solutions?

There are a few common mistakes people make when checking for extraneous solutions that can often lead to incorrect results. One mistake is forgetting to check for any possible rational roots of the equation. These are any values of x that would make the equation equal to zero when plugged in. Another mistake is assuming that every possible real solution must be an integer. However, this is not always the case and there can be solutions that are irrational numbers. Lastly, people often incorrectly use the sign chart method to determine the number of possible solutions. The sign chart method only works for equations that are in simplifiedradical form, which means that all exponents on the variable are even numbers. If an equation is not in this form, the sign chart method will not accurately show the number of solutions.

What are some tips for avoiding mistakes when checking for extraneous solutions?

There is no one-size-fits-all answer to this question, as the best way to avoid making mistakes when checking for extraneous solutions will vary depending on the particular problem and the individual solver. However, there are some general tips that can be useful in many situations.

First, it is important to have a clear understanding of what extraneous solutions are and why they can be a problem. Extraneous solutions are those that satisfy the equation or inequality being checked, but are not actual solutions to the problem. They can occur when the equation or inequality has been incorrectly simplified, or when the conditions of the problem have been misunderstood.

Extraneous solutions can be a problem because they can lead the solver to believe that they have found the correct answer, when in fact they have not. This can be especially frustrating if the mistake is not discovered until after a great deal of time and effort has been expended on the problem.

To avoid making mistakes when checking for extraneous solutions, it is important to be methodical and careful in your work. Simplify the equation or inequality as much as possible before checking for extraneous solutions, and be sure that you understand the conditions of the problem.

It can also be helpful to check your work by plugging the purported solution back into the equation or inequality to verify that it actually works. If you find that it does not, then you know that you have either made a mistake in your work or that the solution you have found is extraneous.

Finally, don't be afraid to ask for help if you are having difficulty avoiding mistakes when checking for extraneous solutions. A fresh set of eyes on a problem can often spot mistakes that you have missed, and there is no shame in seeking assistance from others when working on difficult problems.

What should you do if you're not sure if a solution is extraneous?

If you're not sure if a solution is extraneous, you should check with your instructor or a tutor. In many cases, extraneous solutions are those that are not algebraic in nature. That is, they do not use algebra to solve the problem. However, there are sometimes exceptions to this rule. If you're not sure, it's always best to ask for help.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an extraneous solution to an equation?

An extraneous solution is any value that does not satisfy the equation.

What is an extraneous root in math?

An extraneous root is a root of a transformed equation that is not a root of the original equation because it was excluded from the domain of the original equation.

How do you find the extraneous solutions of fractions?

If you can isolate the variable x in the denominator, and solve for x, then you can find all of the extraneous solutions.

Is it necessary to check for extraneous solutions in calculus?

No.

What is an extraneous root of an equation?

If x is not a root of the original equation, then x can be an extraneous solution. Extraneous solutions are typically impurities or byproducts of the chemical reaction that led to the equation's formation. In this example, x would represent the extra hydrogen gas produced when alcohol and water react.

Mollie Sherman

Mollie Sherman

Writer at CGAA

View Mollie's Profile

Mollie Sherman is an experienced and accomplished article author who has been writing for over 15 years. She specializes in health, nutrition, and lifestyle topics, with a focus on helping people understand the science behind everyday decisions. Mollie has published hundreds of articles in leading magazines and websites, including Women's Health, Shape Magazine, Cooking Light, and MindBodyGreen.

View Mollie's Profile