Understanding Wrongful Trading and Its Impact

Author

Reads 1.4K

Professional handshake sealing a business deal with colleagues observing.
Credit: pexels.com, Professional handshake sealing a business deal with colleagues observing.

Wrongful trading is a serious issue that can have severe consequences for individuals and businesses alike. It's a breach of directors' duties that can lead to personal liability.

Directors have a duty to prevent the company from trading while insolvent, as stated in the Insolvency Act 1986. This duty is not just a recommendation, but a legal requirement.

Trading while insolvent can lead to a significant increase in debt, making it even harder for the company to recover. In fact, research suggests that companies that trade while insolvent are 3 times more likely to enter liquidation.

Personal liability is a major concern for directors who engage in wrongful trading. They can be held personally responsible for the company's debts, which can have a devastating impact on their personal finances.

What is Wrongful Trading?

Wrongful trading occurs when a director knows or should know that a company has no reasonable prospect of avoiding insolvency, yet continues to trade.

Credit: youtube.com, What Is Wrongful Trading

A judgment of wrongful trading can result in a director being disqualified for up to 15 years, plus financial fines and penalties.

Directors have a duty to inform shareholders when a company reaches an insolvent position, and to seek the guidance of a licensed Insolvency Practitioner.

Trading while insolvent is not wrongful per se, but the lack of a reasonable prospect of avoiding insolvent liquidation turns it into wrongful trading.

Directors may become personally liable to contribute to a company's assets if they knew or should have known there was no reasonable prospect of avoiding insolvent liquidation.

It's not advisable for a company to trade while insolvent, as it runs the risk of being classed as wrongful trading in due course.

The director's knowledge of a company's insolvency is key to determining wrongful trading, and they must take steps to minimise losses to creditors.

A director's belief in a company's ability to avoid insolvency may be subjective, but if it's found to be based on unreasonable grounds, wrongful trading will have occurred.

Wrongful trading can result in a director being held personally liable for company debts following liquidation.

Directors' Responsibilities

Women executives in a business meeting discussing strategies with charts and phone communication.
Credit: pexels.com, Women executives in a business meeting discussing strategies with charts and phone communication.

Directors' duties are crucial in determining the fate of a company. A director's primary responsibility is to act in the best interests of the company and its creditors.

The BHS decision highlights the importance of the board determining at each meeting whether the creditor duty has arisen and giving due weight to creditors' interests. This should sit alongside the usual "reasonable prospects" analysis for wrongful trading.

Directors must continuously monitor the financial position of the company and have an accurate view of the company's finances at all times. This can be achieved through cash flow forecasts that show the effect of continuing to trade on the creditors' position.

Some common defences to wrongful trading claims include the statutory defence of taking every step with a view to minimising the potential losses to creditors. This defence is highly dependent on the facts of the case and may involve steps such as not incurring further debt, preserving the assets of the company, and taking professional advice.

Credit: youtube.com, Claims against Directors - wrongful trading or misfeasance?

Directors can reduce their risk of being liable for wrongful trading by holding regular board meetings to discuss the financial viability of the company and what actions should be taken. These meetings should be recorded in detail to evidence the reasoning behind decisions.

Here are some ways directors can limit the likelihood of being accused of wrongful trading:

  • Continuously monitoring the financial position of the company
  • Holding regular board meetings to discuss the financial viability of the company
  • Not taking on any more credit during this time unless it will be repaid
  • Not removing assets from the company
  • Not repaying director loans or loans that personally benefit the directors
  • Ensuring Companies House filings are made on time and salaries and taxes are paid correctly and on time
  • Not paying yourself an unreasonably high salary or bonus
  • Taking legal and financial advice as early as possible

Directors must also keep detailed records of their board meetings and any decision-making process and any advice on which they have relied in making these decisions. This will be crucial in the event that they need to defend a wrongful trading claim.

Consequences

If wrongful trading is proven, the consequences can be severe. The directors of the company can be held liable to pay compensation equivalent to the estimated losses incurred by the company arising from the wrongful trading.

The amount of compensation can be substantial, calculated from the point that the directors knew or ought reasonably to have known that the company would be liquidated to the date of that liquidation.

Businessman in formal attire working on a laptop and smartphone at an indoor office desk.
Credit: pexels.com, Businessman in formal attire working on a laptop and smartphone at an indoor office desk.

Directors can also face disqualification from acting as a company director for up to 15 years.

Trading while insolvent is a civil offence, but if the directors' actions are deemed to be deliberate and fraudulent, it can be a criminal offence.

The Court has wide discretion over the contribution that it can require, traditionally compensatory rather than punitive. The starting point for assessing the appropriate amount is the difference between the net assets of the company at the date that the directors should not have traded beyond, and the net assets at the date of liquidation.

In some cases, the Court may award just a percentage of this, as seen in Re Brian D Pierson (Contractors) Ltd [1999] BCC 903, where 70% of the drop in net assets was awarded to the claimants.

For more insights, see: Timothy Sykes Net Worth

Understanding the Process

To prove wrongful trading, the liquidator or administrator must pinpoint a date when the directors knew or should have known the company was likely to become insolvent.

Crop anonymous female soothsayer with magic ball near shiny candle during divination process at home
Credit: pexels.com, Crop anonymous female soothsayer with magic ball near shiny candle during divination process at home

This can be a challenging task, as it requires a deep understanding of the company's financial situation and the directors' actions.

The court will apply an objective and subjective test to assess the required standard of knowledge, considering both the facts the director ought to have known and the general knowledge, skill, and experience expected of a reasonably diligent person.

The court will also look at the conclusions the director ought to have reached and the steps they ought to have taken, based on their own general knowledge, skill, and experience.

How Can It Be Proved?

Proving wrongful trading is a complex task that requires pinpointing a specific date of knowledge of insolvency. This date is when the directors knew, or should have known, that the company was or was likely to become insolvent.

Retrospectively establishing a specific date for this can be a challenging task for an insolvency practitioner, and it will depend on the circumstances of each case. An example of this is when a company asks creditors for forbearance to secure extra funding but realizes it won't be forthcoming and continues trading anyway.

The courts will apply an objective and subjective test when assessing the required standard of knowledge. They will look at the facts the director ought to have known or ascertained, the conclusions that the director ought to have reached, and the steps that the director ought to have taken.

In proving that creditors suffered further loss, a court will take the point at which it believes the company should have ceased trading but didn't, and then look at the increase in loss to the creditors as a whole from that date until the company actually ceased trading.

Recognising Potential

Real estate agents inspecting a modern kitchen interior for potential sale.
Credit: pexels.com, Real estate agents inspecting a modern kitchen interior for potential sale.

Recognising the potential for wrongful trading requires a keen eye for the signs of insolvency.

One of the most common signs is issues with cash flow, such as refusal of credit, threatened legal action, and consistent, unanswered demands for payment by creditors.

Significant and unusual large debts due to creditors, such as lending companies, banks, or HMRC, can also indicate potential wrongful trading.

Delayed or incorrect financial decisions being made by directors can be a major red flag.

Here are some common signs to look out for:

  • Refusal of credit
  • Threatened legal action
  • Consistent, unanswered demands for payment by creditors
  • Significant and unusual large debts due to creditors

Case List

Let's take a look at some notable cases that have shaped the understanding of wrongful trading and insolvency law in the UK.

Re Produce Marketing Consortium Ltd (No 2) [1989] 5 BCC 569 is a key case that highlighted the importance of directors' duties in preventing insolvency.

One notable aspect of this case is the court's ruling that directors can be held personally liable for wrongful trading if they continue to trade despite knowing or having reasonable grounds to believe that the company is insolvent.

An Elderly Woman in a Business Meeting
Credit: pexels.com, An Elderly Woman in a Business Meeting

Re Purpoint Ltd [1991] BCLC 491 is another important case that emphasizes the need for directors to act with caution when dealing with company finances.

In this case, the court found that the directors had failed to take reasonable steps to prevent the company from becoming insolvent, and as a result, they were held personally liable.

Here are some notable cases related to wrongful trading and insolvency law:

These cases demonstrate the importance of directors taking a proactive approach to preventing insolvency and the potential consequences of failing to do so.

Making a Claim

A claim for wrongful trading can only be taken against a company director, including those who act as directors, have a significant controlling interest, or are non-executive or executive directors.

Resigning as a director won't get you off the hook, so don't think you can escape responsibility by stepping down.

Only a liquidator or administrator can bring a wrongful trading claim, and they'll pursue it on behalf of the creditors for the benefit of all.

Credit: youtube.com, Wrongful Trading and Fraudulent Trading - A 60 Second Guide

They may assign the claim to a third party, like a creditor, if they don't have the resources to pursue it.

There's a six-year limitation period to making a claim, starting from the date the company goes into administration or liquidation.

This means you have a significant amount of time to investigate and potentially take action, but don't wait too long.

Make a Claim

To make a claim for wrongful trading, you need to know who can bring the claim. A claim can only be taken against a company director.

The claim covers not just registered directors, but also those who act as directors, have a significant controlling interest, and even non-executive directors. It's not a matter of resigning as a director to get off the hook.

A claim can only be brought by a liquidator or administrator after the company has entered into formal insolvency proceedings. This is a crucial step in the process.

Scorched banknotes scattered on a dark wooden table, symbolizing financial loss.
Credit: pexels.com, Scorched banknotes scattered on a dark wooden table, symbolizing financial loss.

The liquidator or administrator may choose to assign the claim to a third party, such as a creditor, if they don't wish to pursue it or don't have the resources. This can be a good option if you're a creditor who wants to pursue the claim but can't.

If the claim is successful, the court's discretion is wide, but usually, the director or directors will be ordered to contribute personally to the company's assets. This means the money will go back to the company for the benefit of all creditors.

Is there a time limit for claims?

There is a six year limitation period which runs from the date the company goes into administration or liquidation. This means you have six years to make your claim.

Don't worry, this time limit is a common rule in many types of claims, not just wrongful trading claims.

What Should I Do If Alleged?

If alleged wrongful trading is a concern, take immediate action. Consult with a professional to determine if the company is indeed trading while insolvent and understand the potential consequences.

A businessman in a black suit looks stressed while working outdoors on a laptop with coffee.
Credit: pexels.com, A businessman in a black suit looks stressed while working outdoors on a laptop with coffee.

The test for wrongful trading is objective, not subjective. This means that the focus is on the company's solvency, not the directors' intentions.

Directors should document their decision to continue trading, including a thorough explanation for the choice. This paper trail may be crucial in the event of an insolvency process.

Here are the two main steps to take if wrongful trading is alleged:

  • Seek immediate advice on the company's solvency and potential consequences.
  • Document the decision to continue trading, including a thorough explanation.

Limiting Director Liability

Directors can reduce their risk of being liable for wrongful trading by continuously monitoring the financial position of the company and having an accurate view of the company's finances at all times.

This involves holding regular board meetings to discuss the financial viability of the company and what actions should be taken, and making sure these are recorded in detail should they be required later on to evidence the reasoning behind decisions.

To minimize the risk of being accused of wrongful trading, directors should not take on any more credit during this time unless they can be sure it will be repaid.

A different take: PNC Financial Services

Credit: youtube.com, Wrongful Trading - Who is liable?

Here are some specific steps directors can take to limit their liability:

  • Monitor the company's cash flow forecasts to show consideration for creditors' position.
  • Hold regular board meetings and record decisions.
  • Do not remove assets from the company or sell them at below market value.
  • Do not repay director loans or personally guaranteed loans.
  • Ensure Companies House filings are made on time and salaries and taxes are paid correctly and on time.
  • Do not pay yourself an unreasonably high salary or bonus.
  • Seek legal and financial advice as early as possible.

Limiting Director Liability

You can reduce your risk of being liable for wrongful trading by continuously monitoring the company's financial position and having an accurate view of the company's finances at all times.

This can be achieved by using cash flow forecasts to show that you've considered the effect of continuing to trade on the creditors' position.

Directors can also reduce their risk by holding regular board meetings to discuss the financial viability of the company and what actions should be taken.

These meetings should be recorded in detail, should they be required later on to evidence the reasoning behind decisions.

Not taking on any more credit during this time unless you can be sure it will be repaid is also a good idea.

You should also not remove assets from the company and ensure the sale of any company assets is at market value, having obtained an independent valuation.

A different take: What Is Position Trading

Three professionals in a meeting room engaged in a focused business discussion.
Credit: pexels.com, Three professionals in a meeting room engaged in a focused business discussion.

Here are some key actions to help limit director liability:

  • Continuously monitor the company's financial position
  • Holding regular board meetings
  • Not taking on more credit
  • Not removing assets
  • Ensuring fair market value for asset sales
  • Not repaying director loans or personal loans
  • Maintaining accurate Companies House filings and paying salaries and taxes on time
  • Avoiding unreasonably high salaries or bonuses
  • Seeking early legal and financial advice

Taking legal and financial advice as early as possible can also help minimize your risk.

Common Director Defences

Directors accused of wrongful trading can rely on the statutory defence of taking every step with a view to minimising the potential losses to creditors.

This defence is highly dependent on the facts of the case and will likely involve steps such as not incurring further debt, preserving the assets of the company, and taking professional advice.

Not taking professional advice can make it more difficult for directors to show they've taken every step to minimise losses, but the court will also consider the quality and extent of the advice and whether it was followed by the directors.

Keeping detailed records of board meetings and decision-making processes is crucial in the event of a wrongful trading claim, as it can help directors demonstrate their efforts to minimise losses.

Consider reading: List of Trading Losses

Ginger Wolf

Copy Editor

Ginger Wolf is a meticulous and detail-oriented copy editor with a passion for refining written content. With a keen eye for grammar and syntax, Ginger has honed her skills in ensuring that articles are polished and error-free. Her expertise spans a range of topics, including personal finance and budgeting.

Love What You Read? Stay Updated!

Join our community for insights, tips, and more.