Why I Stopped Selling on Etsy and What I Learned

Selling on Etsy was a dream come true for many artisans, including myself. The platform offered a unique opportunity to showcase handmade goods to a global audience.

As I dug deeper into the world of Etsy, I realized that the fees were quite steep, with a listing fee of $0.20 per item and a transaction fee of 3.5%. This added up quickly, especially for sellers with large inventories.

The time-consuming process of taking high-quality photos and writing detailed descriptions was also a significant challenge. I had to spend hours perfecting my product listings to stand out in a crowded marketplace.

The fees and time-consuming process were just the beginning – I also struggled with the platform's strict policies and the constant fear of being suspended or removed.

I stopped selling on Etsy for several key reasons. One major factor was the increasing fees on the platform, which eroded my profit margins and made it difficult to maintain a sustainable business.

Etsy's fees, including listing fees, transaction fees, and payment processing fees, have been steadily rising over the years. This can make it tough for sellers to stay afloat.

I also found that the intense competition on Etsy made it challenging for me to stand out and attract a consistent customer base. With numerous sellers offering similar products, it's hard to get noticed.

Lack of control over my shop, pricing, and branding was another issue I faced. Etsy has strict policies and guidelines that sellers must adhere to, which can limit our ability to customize our business.

Changing product demand was another reason I stopped selling on Etsy. As trends and consumer preferences shift, products can go out of style quickly, making it necessary to pivot and explore new product offerings.

Some sellers may also feel that they need more visibility for their products and brand, which Etsy's platform can't provide. A dedicated e-commerce website or presence on other marketplaces can be a more effective way to showcase products and reach customers.

Here are the top reasons why sellers stop selling on Etsy:

Etsy fees can add up quickly, eating into your profits, especially if you're selling low-priced items. This can be a significant challenge for sellers who aren't making enough sales to cover their fees.

The lack of sales is a common reason why sellers stop selling on Etsy. Despite the large number of buyers on the platform, it can be challenging to get your products noticed.

Fees can be a major obstacle for sellers who are struggling to make a profit. With Etsy's fees, it may not be worth it to continue selling on the platform if you're not making enough sales to cover them.

For another approach, see: Rate Making

Selling on Etsy can be a challenging experience, especially with the lack of sales being a common reason why sellers stop selling on the platform.

Despite the large number of buyers on Etsy, it can be difficult to get your products noticed, which can be frustrating and demotivating, especially if you've put a lot of time and effort into creating them.

Negative reviews can also be a major obstacle, as they have the power to discourage new customers from purchasing from you.

Customer reviews are often the first thing buyers look at when considering a purchase, and low stars and negative reviews can lead them to leave your product and shop altogether.

You can't delete or hide negative customer reviews on Etsy, even if the customer is wrong, but you can reply to the customer offering an explanation, support, or a refund.

However, if the issues are due to the customer's lack of knowledge and understanding, it can penalize the shop owner and be difficult to overcome.

Some sellers have managed to overcome negative reviews by providing great customer service and persevering, but it's a challenging process.

Etsy's payment account reserve policy has also been a source of controversy in the community, with many sellers expressing frustration and concern about the policy.

Check this out: Is Venmo Secure for Sellers

Etsy charges fees for each sale, which can add up quickly. If you're not making enough sales to cover your fees, it may not be worth it to continue selling on Etsy.

Etsy's fees are reasonable, but they can eat into your profits, especially if you're selling low-priced items. This is because the fees are a percentage of the sale price, so smaller items will have a bigger fee-to-profit ratio.

Additional reading: Shipping Insurance for High Value Items

Your customers are a valuable asset, but Etsy's system can make it hard to keep in touch with them. You make a sale on Etsy, but they become an Etsy customer, not yours.

Etsy doesn't give you their email, making it tough to target them for future sales. You're left in the dark, unable to build a relationship with them.

Having your own website is a game-changer. It's much easier to convert those people into customers time and time again.

Additional reading: Get to Know Your Customers Day

If you've decided to stop selling on Etsy, don't worry, there are plenty of alternatives to explore. Establishing a personal e-commerce website can give you more control over your brand and customer relationships.

Selling on other marketplaces like Amazon, eBay, or specialized craft-focused platforms can help you reach a different customer base. These platforms often have built-in customer bases, which can be a huge advantage.

Selling directly to customers through social media, local craft fairs, or wholesale relationships with brick-and-mortar stores can also be a viable option. This approach allows you to connect with customers on a personal level and build lasting relationships.

If you're looking to leave Etsy behind, you have several options to consider. Establishing a Personal E-commerce Website can provide sellers with more control over their brand, pricing, and customer relationships.

Building a dedicated online store can be a great way to showcase your products and connect with customers directly. However, it requires a significant investment of time and resources.

Selling on Other Marketplaces like Amazon, eBay, or specialized craft-focused marketplaces can offer new opportunities for sellers to reach a different customer base. These platforms often have a large customer base and can help you reach a wider audience.

You can also explore Selling Directly to Customers through social media channels, local craft fairs, or by establishing wholesale relationships with brick-and-mortar stores. This can be a great way to connect with customers and build relationships.

Expanding into Wholesale or B2B Sales can provide a more stable and predictable revenue stream. This can be a good option for sellers who want to focus on business-to-business relationships rather than direct-to-consumer sales.

Recommended read: Garden Reach Shipbuilders & Engineers

Email marketing is a powerful tool for growing and scaling a handmade business. It's a huge advocate for its use, and for good reason.

You can use email marketing to reach a large audience, with some people receiving thousands of emails a day. The key is to make your emails stand out and engage your audience.

A good email marketing strategy can help you build a loyal customer base, which is essential for any handmade business. This is because loyal customers are more likely to return and recommend your business to others.

With email marketing, you can also promote your products and services to a targeted audience, increasing the chances of making sales.

Etsy's brand pivot has led to a change in what they allow sellers to offer on their platform. They now focus on unique and creative goods, including vintage and pre-manufactured items. This shift in focus has also led to a change in who they're targeting.

Related reading: Focus Group Holdings Limited

Etsy is no longer just a marketplace for handmade products. They're now open to digital products and print-on-demand items. This change may be beneficial for some sellers, but not so much for those who focus solely on handmade goods.

The consequences of this pivot are two-fold. If you don't sell handmade products, you may not notice a significant impact. However, if handmade products are your main focus, you may feel that the brand's identity has been diluted.

As I continued to sell on Etsy, I noticed that the fees kept adding up. I was losing about 3.5% of my sales to Etsy's transaction fees, which was a significant amount considering the small prices of my handmade items.

The other issue I had was with the competition. I was finding it increasingly difficult to stand out among the thousands of other sellers offering similar products. I had to spend a lot of time and money promoting my shop just to get noticed.

Eventually, I decided to stop selling on Etsy and focus on my own website. This allowed me to keep the entire profit from each sale, which was a big relief.

I've been fortunate enough to have a few different streams of income from my creative pursuits. I still have an Etsy shop where I sell physical Cricut projects, which has great reviews.

I've found that I've been able to sell most of my Cricut projects through other means, which has been a welcome surprise.

Broaden your view: List of Video Game Crowdfunding Projects

I started selling on Etsy in 2018, and my first shop focused solely on selling SVG files.

It was a great way to earn passive income, and I enjoyed the process of creating and selling them.

I eventually decided to start a second Etsy shop to separate my digital and physical products.

This was because I didn't want to mix selling digital SVG files with selling physical products made using my Cricut machine.

I started making physical products like confetti of various sizes, adhesive vinyl decals, and cake toppers.

Take a look at this: Meta Has Started Laying off Employees from across the Company

Pricing on Etsy can be a real challenge, especially when you're trying to make a profit. Many sellers are under-pricing their products, which creates a race to the bottom and makes it harder for others to compete.

Here's an interesting read: Surety Bond Pricing

A lot of sellers are selling products that are manufactured or print-on-demand, which lowers prices overall. This can be a problem, especially for sellers who are offering truly handmade items.

Etsy's design philosophy focuses on keeping customers shopping for anyone's products, not just yours. This means that you're competing with a wide range of sellers, which can make it tough to stand out.

The platform's fees and policies can also be a source of frustration. For example, if you make more than $10,000 a year, Etsy will automatically add you to their offsite ads campaigns and charge a 12% fee.

A fresh viewpoint: Does Amazon Pay for Shipping for Sellers

Pricing on Etsy can make it difficult to price for profit, with many sellers under-pricing their products. This creates a race to the bottom, where everyone tries to lower their prices to compete.

A lot of sellers on Etsy are completely under-pricing their products, not because they're trying to be cheap, but because they don't know how to price for profit. Some sellers are even selling for a hobby and just want to cover their costs.

Suggestion: Performance Bond Pricing

The competition on Etsy is tougher price-wise, making it harder to sell at higher prices. As a whole, the prices on Etsy are generally lower due to the presence of sellers who manufacture or print-on-demand products.

Etsy designs the customer experience at the marketplace level, not at the shop level, which means they want to keep people shopping for anyone's products, not just yours. This can make it difficult to stand out and charge higher prices.

Many buyers on Etsy are tempted to choose the lowest price when comparing options, even if they're looking for a truly handmade item. This can make it harder to sell your products at a premium price.

Suggestion: Pennsylvania Higher Education Assistance Agency

Selling on Etsy can be a great way to reach a large customer base, but it can also feel like you're losing control over your business.

You lose control on layouts and fees, and customer data, which can be frustrating.

Etsy has the power to change their policies and fees without warning, which can be a huge problem for sellers.

They announced that if you make more than $10,000 a year, they'll automatically add you to their offsite ads campaigns and charge a 12% fee.

This can be a significant cut for sellers who didn't budget for it.

The Etsy Payment Account Reserve is another example of something that can be problematic and unexpected.

It's another thing that Etsy can control, and it can be a huge burden for sellers who aren't prepared.