Why Does Trump Want to Tariff Canada and What's at Stake?

Author

Reads 1.2K

American and Chinese flags and USA dollars
Credit: pexels.com, American and Chinese flags and USA dollars

The US and Canada have a long-standing trade relationship, but tensions have been rising lately. The US imposed tariffs on Canadian steel and aluminum in 2018, citing national security concerns.

Canada is the US's second-largest trading partner, with bilateral trade worth over $600 billion in 2017. This trade relationship is crucial for both countries, with many jobs and industries dependent on it.

The tariffs imposed by the US have had a significant impact on Canada, particularly in the steel and aluminum sectors. Canadian industries have reported significant losses due to the tariffs, with some companies even considering relocating to other countries.

The US has also imposed tariffs on Canadian lumber, which has sparked a trade dispute between the two countries.

Trump's Tariff Policy

Trump's tariff policy is a complex and ever-changing issue. He has imposed a 25 percent tariff on all Canadian goods and a 10 percent tariff on Canadian energy resources, citing Canada's "growing footprint" in fentanyl production.

Credit: youtube.com, Why Economists Hate Trump's Tariff Plan | WSJ

These tariffs were initially paused for 30 days, but were reimposed in early March after Trump declared that Canada had failed to do enough to curb the flow of fentanyl.

The tariffs have been rising again, to 35 percent, and are set to take effect on August 1. Canada is also facing a separate 25 percent tariff on steel and aluminium, which Trump doubled to 50 percent in June.

The USMCA trade deal, which came into force on July 1, 2020, has been blighted by disputes and non-compliance issues since Trump returned to office. Some trade commentators have suggested the agreement won't be extended next summer.

Trump claims his tariffs on Canada are designed to force Ottawa to crack down on fentanyl smuggling into the US. However, only a modest flow of the drug has been detected across the border.

Canada has been a major supplier of steel and aluminium to the US, but is now facing stiff tariffs on its exports. The country is also one of the largest suppliers of copper to the US, and is facing a 50 percent import tariff on the metal.

Credit: youtube.com, Trump's Tariff Tantrum BACKFIRES as Carney Outplays Him at His Own Game

The Trump administration's tariff policy is making it difficult for Canadian politicians to chart a strategy to push back against the new president's threat. Finance Minister Dominic LeBlanc has described Trump as unpredictable, making it hard to know what he wants from Canada.

Trump has cited the US trade deficit with Canada, which largely reflects oil purchases, as another reason for imposing tariffs. He claims that Washington is subsidizing Canada to the tune of $100 billion a year.

The Wall Street Journal reported that Trump is using the tariff threat to push for an early renegotiation of the USMCA trade deal, particularly to change automotive rules under the continental trade pact.

US-Canada Trade Issues

The US-Canada trade relationship is a complex one. Canada is America's second-largest trading partner, after Mexico, with a trade surplus of $63.3 billion in 2024.

Canada's key exports to the US include oil and mineral fuels, cars and auto parts, as well as industrial machinery and nuclear reactors. It imports large amounts of transportation equipment, industrial chemicals, and manufacturing technology from the US.

Credit: youtube.com, Is Trump right about Canada charging 250% tariffs? | About That

The US has imposed tariffs on Canada, with a 25 percent tariff on all Canadian goods and a 10 percent tariff on Canadian energy resources. These tariffs were paused for 30 days but were then reimposed in early March.

Canada faces a 50 percent tariff on steel and aluminium imports from the US, which has badly hit the country's steel and aluminium industry. The US has also threatened to impose a 50 percent import tariff on copper, which Canada is one of the largest suppliers of to the US.

The Trump administration claims its tariffs on Canada are designed to force Ottawa to crack down on fentanyl smuggling into the US. However, Canadian government data shows that less than 0.1 percent of all seizures of fentanyl entering the US from 2022-2024 were made at the Canadian border.

The Canadian government has committed to stopping the flow of fentanyl and has been working with the US to protect communities in both countries. Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney has also made it clear that Canada is not for sale and will not be pressured into changing its policies.

A fresh viewpoint: Trump Steel Tariff 2018

Trump Threatens Tariffs

Credit: youtube.com, Why Trump is threatening Canada with higher tariffs

Trump has threatened to impose a new 35 percent tariff on Canada, up from the 25 percent rate originally imposed in March, which will go into effect on August 1.

He claims this is necessary to force Canada to crack down on fentanyl smuggling into the US, despite only a modest flow of the drug over the border.

The flow of fentanyl is not the only challenge Trump has with Canada, which has many Tariff and Non-Tariff Policies and Trade Barriers.

Trump has also expressed frustration with the US trade deficit with Canada, largely due to oil purchases, which he claims amounts to $100 billion a year.

Canada has agreed to withdraw a new digital services tax that would have hit US technology companies financially, but Trump still went ahead with the tariff threat.

Trying to figure out exactly what Trump wants from Canada has become a full-time job for Canadian politicians, as his statements on the matter have been contradictory and unpredictable.

Trump has cited different reasons for imposing tariffs on Canada, including border issues, trade deficit, and military spending, making it difficult for Canada to know how to respond.

Forrest Schumm

Copy Editor

Forrest Schumm is a seasoned copy editor with a deep understanding of the financial sector, particularly in India. His expertise spans a variety of topics, including trade associations, banking institutions, and historical establishments. Forrest's work has shed light on the intricate landscape of Indian banking, from the Indian Banks' Association to the significant 1946 establishments that have shaped the industry.

Love What You Read? Stay Updated!

Join our community for insights, tips, and more.