Trump Vat Tariff Policy: A Threat to Global Trade

Author

Reads 1.1K

Trade and trade related words on wooden table
Credit: pexels.com, Trade and trade related words on wooden table

The Trump Vat Tariff policy has been a topic of heated debate in the global trade community.

The policy aims to impose a 25% tariff on imported steel and a 10% tariff on imported aluminum, effective March 23, 2018.

These tariffs are a significant increase from the previous rates, which were 2.5% and 5% respectively.

The Trump administration claims that the tariffs are necessary to protect American industries and jobs.

However, many experts argue that the tariffs will lead to a trade war and harm the US economy.

For more insights, see: Djia S&p Nasdaq Trump Trade Tariffs

Check this out: Trump Double Tariff

Why Trump's Vat Tariff Confusion Matters

Trump thinks VAT is a tariff, but he's wrong. This misunderstanding can have serious consequences for international trade.

A domestic producer selling into the UK faces the same VAT as a US producer. This is a basic fact about VAT that Trump seems to have overlooked.

The car maker has charged no VAT on its sale to the final consumer, but £20 VAT was still collected in the supply chain. This is a common scenario in VAT systems.

Photo Of People Having Meeting
Credit: pexels.com, Photo Of People Having Meeting

The car maker can "recover" the £20 VAT in the same way it did in the first example. This is how VAT works in the UK.

The US is one of the few exceptions to using VAT, employing state and city taxes instead. This is a key difference between the US and other countries.

Value-added taxes are used in at least 175 countries globally. This is a staggering number, and it highlights the importance of VAT in international trade.

Trump plans to impose new US tariffs on countries with value-added taxes. This move could have far-reaching consequences for trade between the US and other countries.

The new tariffs will likely be felt the most in the European Union, which has value-added taxes of almost 22%. This is a significant percentage, and it could impact trade between the US and the EU.

The tariff increases will be customized for each country, with the partial goal of starting new trade negotiations. This is a complex and nuanced approach to trade policy.

Trump's plan is in the interest of "fairness" and aims to bring trade reciprocity and prosperity. However, his understanding of VAT is flawed, and this could undermine his goals.

Additional reading: Trade Act of 1974

US Trade Policy

Scrabble tiles spelling 'China' and 'Tariffs' symbolize global trade issues.
Credit: pexels.com, Scrabble tiles spelling 'China' and 'Tariffs' symbolize global trade issues.

The US Trade Policy has become increasingly complex under the Trump administration. President Trump has ordered a comprehensive investigation into America's trade policy, looking into unfair and unbalanced trade, the trade policy with China, and additional economic security measures as well as foreign subsidies on US federal procurement.

A key aspect of this policy is the consideration of value-added taxes (VATs) as a barrier to trade. Trump has stated that VATs will be included in the tariff math, considering countries that use VAT systems to be similar to countries with tariffs.

The US has traditionally not had a VAT system, unlike many other countries, which have adjusted VAT at the border by removing VAT on exports yet applying VAT on imports. This means that countries like the European Union, which has a VAT of almost 22%, will likely feel the impact of the new tariffs.

US Plans to Spark Backlash

The US plans to spark a backlash with its tariff plans, which are highly likely to lead to legal and retaliatory measures. The European Union and China are already positioning themselves to fight back against unfair trade practices.

Executives signing international agreement with EU and US flags displayed on a wooden table.
Credit: pexels.com, Executives signing international agreement with EU and US flags displayed on a wooden table.

The EU has announced plans to fight back, and it's not just talk - it has already positioned itself strongly by announcing its stance. The US also applies higher tariffs to certain product categories, such as clothing and light vehicle trucks.

For example, clothing is taxed at 12% in the EU and up to 32% in the US, while light vehicle trucks are taxed at 10% in the EU and 25% in the US. This highlights the complexity and challenges in achieving mutually beneficial agreements.

China has also taken a firm stance, implementing retaliatory measures to protect its interests against the 10% tariff hike from the US. It's a delicate balance, as China wants to show it has cards to hit back at real US economic interests without escalating the situation further.

Expand your knowledge: Trump Tariff on China

Barriers to Trade

VATs are a type of tax that can be a barrier to trade, according to Trump, who considers them similar to tariffs.

Free stock photo of commerce, customs, duty
Credit: pexels.com, Free stock photo of commerce, customs, duty

In countries that use VAT, the tax is typically applied at the border, which can give the appearance of a tariff. However, tax experts say this is actually a neutral tax policy for businesses.

VATs have border adjustments, which involve removing VAT on exports and applying VAT on imports. For example, U.S. candy sold into the U.K. would be subject to a 20% border adjustment.

A car made in the U.K. that sells domestically for $50,000 would have a final cost of $60,000 if it's sold in the domestic market, due to the 20% VAT.

Trump Plans New US Tariffs on Taxing Countries

President Trump has announced plans to impose new US tariffs on countries with value-added taxes (VATs). This move is seen as a way to bring trade reciprocity and prosperity, with Trump stating that countries that charge the US will be charged in return.

The US is one of the few countries that doesn't use VAT, instead employing state and city taxes. This makes the US a notable exception among the 175 countries that use VAT globally.

A detailed collage of Euro and Dollar banknotes showcasing international currency exchange.
Credit: pexels.com, A detailed collage of Euro and Dollar banknotes showcasing international currency exchange.

The new tariffs will be customized for each country, with the goal of starting new trade negotiations. The White House has listed examples of disproportionate taxes, including Germany's 10% car import tariff versus the US's 2.5%.

Trump has also stated that VATs will be treated like tariffs, despite economists saying they are not. He has argued that VATs are "far more punitive than a tariff" and will be included in the tariff math.

The European Union, which has value-added taxes of almost 22%, will likely feel the impact of these new tariffs the most.

Economic Implications

The idea that border adjustments are a barrier to trade is a misconception, as they cause movements in the currency that offset any economic effect they might have.

Research from the Peterson Institute for International Economics has found that the exchange rates fully offset border-adjusted consumption taxes.

Increases in consumption tax rates raise the prices of domestic and imported products equally, according to the researchers.

Tax experts don't see VAT border adjustments as trade barriers because they understand how the exchange rate adjustments mitigate any discriminatory effects.

The exchange rate adjustments make the border adjustment non-discriminatory against Americans or any other importing country, as Alex Durante, senior economist at the Tax Foundation, pointed out.

New Tariffs and Trade

Economic concept shown on illustration with statistic graph and charts around hundred dollars demonstrating growth of currency over time
Credit: pexels.com, Economic concept shown on illustration with statistic graph and charts around hundred dollars demonstrating growth of currency over time

The US is planning to impose new tariffs on countries with value-added taxes (VAT), which will likely affect the European Union the most, with VAT rates of almost 22%.

The new tariffs will be customized for each country, with the partial goal of starting new trade negotiations.

Trump's administration considers countries with VAT systems to be similar to those with tariffs, and will treat them as such.

The US is one of the few exceptions to the global use of VAT, instead employing state and city taxes.

The tariff increases will be calculated based on the average tariff plus the VAT rate, plus an unspecified amount for unfair trade practices.

Countries relying on VATs cannot simply nix those taxes or lower the rates, as they represent a major source of revenue.

There's no way for Europeans to just say they will no longer have the border adjustment, as it would create a huge carveout for foreign goods relative to domestic goods.

Illustration revealing economic concept of growth and decline of euro and dollar currencies against facade of historic building
Credit: pexels.com, Illustration revealing economic concept of growth and decline of euro and dollar currencies against facade of historic building

A list of disproportionate taxes includes:

  • Germany's 10% car import tariff versus America's 2.5%
  • Brazil's 18% ethanol tariff versus the US's 2.5%
  • India's 39% tariff on agricultural goods versus the US's 5%

The market reaction to Trump's plan is expected to be negative, with a chance that the plan is being used to get countries to the bargaining table.

Technical Analysis

Paying import VAT is a hassle in a way that normal VAT isn’t, it's a “non-tariff barrier” that can cause bureaucratic annoyances, especially in countries like Italy and Spain.

The cashflow cost of recovering input VAT is equivalent to the cost of recovering normal domestic VAT due to a system of “postponed VAT accounting”.

This system was put in place during the Brexit discussions to mitigate the three month delay in recovering input VAT.

There remain some bureaucratic annoyances with input VAT, but it's just a small part of the overall “trade friction” – the hassle of importing goods.

The argument that VAT is applied to tariffs and discriminates against US manufacturers selling to UK consumers doesn't hold up to close inspection.

Crop unrecognizable coworkers in formal wear standing at table with laptop and documents while greeting each other before meeting
Credit: pexels.com, Crop unrecognizable coworkers in formal wear standing at table with laptop and documents while greeting each other before meeting

Almost no US car manufacturer sells direct to a UK consumer, they'd sell to a UK distributor who would recover its VAT.

The problem is the tariff, not the VAT, as VAT makes the effective rate of tariffs higher.

If the US kept the overall level of tax the same, but substituted VAT for some personal tax and corporate tax, and applied VAT to absolutely everything, that would enhance the competitiveness of US exports.

Miriam Wisozk

Writer

Miriam Wisozk is a seasoned writer with a passion for exploring the complex world of finance and technology. With a keen eye for detail and a knack for simplifying complex concepts, she has established herself as a trusted voice in the industry. Her writing has been featured in various publications, covering a range of topics including cyber insurance, Tokio Marine, and financial services companies based in the City of London.

Love What You Read? Stay Updated!

Join our community for insights, tips, and more.