
As a business owner, you're likely aware of the growing trend of state mandated retirement plans. Some states require employers to offer retirement plans to their employees, while others provide incentives for businesses that do. This can be a complex and time-consuming process, but understanding the basics can help you navigate it.
In California, for example, employers with five or more employees are required to offer a retirement plan. This can be a traditional pension plan or a defined contribution plan, such as a 401(k). The plan must be designed to provide a minimum level of benefits to employees.
The key is to understand the specific requirements of your state. In Oregon, for instance, employers with 25 or more employees are required to offer a retirement plan, while those with fewer employees are encouraged to do so. This can help you avoid penalties and fines.
Ultimately, the goal of state mandated retirement plans is to ensure that employees have access to retirement savings. By understanding the requirements of your state, you can create a plan that meets their needs and helps you attract and retain top talent.
Related reading: How to Offer 401k to Employees
What Are State Mandated Retirement Plans?
State-mandated retirement plans are government-required retirement savings programs that apply to private-sector employers who don't sponsor their own retirement plan. These plans are designed to expand access to retirement savings without placing financial burdens on employers.
Around 45% of households have zero retirement assets, and the Brookings Institute reports a growing gap between Americans with and without access to retirement plans. This highlights the need for state-mandated retirement plans to help bridge the retirement gap.
State-mandated retirement plans require employers to offer their workers access to a retirement savings program or savings opportunity. This is a state mandate to offer a plan, not to choose a specific plan.
Currently, 19 states have some type of state-facilitated retirement program active or in the works. Most cover private-sector employees, with Massachusetts being the current exception, as their state plan is only available for non-profits.
There are some sobering stats and details out there:
- Around 45% of households have zero retirement assets
- The Brookings Institute reports a growing gap between Americans with and without access to retirement plans
- An estimated 57.3 million private-sector workers don’t have access to a retirement plan through their employer
Studies suggest 75% of workers may be more inclined to save for retirement when their employers offer a 401(k) or other savings program.
States Implementing Plans
Georgia has enacted a state-mandated program called Peach State Saves, which covers employers with 5+ employees and has voluntary employer participation.
Hawaii's program, Hawaii Retirement Savings Program, is mandatory for all employers with 1+ employees.
Minnesota's program, Minnesota Secure Choice Retirement Program, is mandatory for employers with 5+ employees.
Missouri's program, Missouri Show-Me MyRetirement Savings Plan, is voluntary for employers with 50 or fewer employees.
Nevada's program, Nevada Employee Savings Trust, is mandatory for employers with 5+ employees.
New Mexico's program, New Mexico Work and Save IRA, is voluntary for employers with 1+ employees.
New York's program, New York State Secure Choice Savings Program, is mandatory for employers with 10+ employees.
Pennsylvania's program, Keystone Saves, is mandatory for employers with 5+ employees.
Rhode Island's program, RI Savers, is mandatory for employers with 5+ employees.
Washington's program, Washington Saves, is mandatory for employers with 1+ employees.
Here are the states with mandatory programs, listed by state:
Plan Details and Effectiveness
Employers in states with mandates are required to provide employees with access to a retirement savings program or savings opportunity. They may choose their state's plan or a private provider.
Consider reading: 403 B Dc Plan
Most states with mandates require employers with five or more employees who do not currently offer or provide access to a retirement plan to do so.
Fees for noncompliance vary by state and can range from $250 to $750 per employee. This can add up quickly, making it essential for employers to understand their obligations and take action.
Here's a breakdown of the current state of state-mandated retirement plans:
State Laws and Effectiveness
State laws regarding retirement plans vary significantly, and understanding these laws is crucial for businesses operating in different states. The rules of state-mandated retirement programs differ greatly from state to state.
In states with mandates, employers are required to provide employees with access to a retirement savings program or savings opportunity. They may choose their state's plan or a private provider.
Most states with mandates require employers with five or more employees who don't currently offer or provide access to a retirement plan to do so. This is a common threshold for many states.
Broaden your view: 401k Deposit Rules for Employers

Fees for noncompliance can range from $250 to $750 per employee, varying by state. This can add up quickly for larger companies.
Employers in states with mandates are required to provide employees with access to a retirement savings program or savings opportunity, and may choose their state's plan or a private provider.
Employee Contributions
Employee contributions are a crucial aspect of retirement plans. They can significantly impact an employee's ability to save for their golden years.
A 401(k) plan, for instance, enables employees to contribute up to $22,500 annually, which is a much higher limit than what's typically allowed in state-mandated plans, which cap contributions at $7,000 annually.
The IRS start-up costs tax credit can help recoup some administrative costs of an employer-sponsored plan, which can be a big help when set-up fees can range from $1,000 to $3,000 per year.
State-facilitated programs usually limit how much employees can put toward their nest egg, but employer-sponsored plans offer more flexibility in this regard.
Here's a comparison of employee contribution limits for state-mandated and employer-sponsored plans:
It's worth noting that some employer-sponsored plans, like 401(k)s, allow catch-up contributions for employees 50 and older, which can be up to $7,000 annually.
A fresh viewpoint: Retirement Plans for S Corp Owners
More Details
As of October 2021, employers with ten or more employees during the previous calendar year and two years in business must offer a retirement program.
Employers in states with mandates are required to provide employees with access to a retirement savings program or savings opportunity and may choose their state's plan or a private provider. This means business owners have options when it comes to meeting the mandate.
Most states with mandates require employers with five or more employees who do not currently offer or provide access to a retirement plan to do so. This is a key consideration for small businesses and non-profits.
Fees for noncompliance vary by state and can range from $250 to $750 per employee. This can add up quickly, making it essential for business owners to stay on top of these requirements.
Here are some key details on state-mandated plans:
Most state-sponsored plans offer Roth IRAs, but plans differ across states. This means business owners should research their state's specific requirements and options.
Plan Mandates and Penalties
California employers have a deadline to register with the state's retirement plan, and if they fail to comply, they'll face fines of $250 per eligible employee for non-compliance lasting 90 days or more after the notice.
Employers in California who don't offer a qualified retirement plan and meet certain criteria will be fined. The criteria include having 5+ employees, being in business since July 1 of the previous year, and not offering a qualified retirement plan.
Non-compliant employers in California face fines of $250 per unenrolled eligible employee, with a maximum penalty of $5,000 per calendar year. This is a significant penalty, and it's essential to register on time to avoid it.
Businesses in Oregon could face penalties up to $5,000 per calendar year for non-compliance with their state mandate. Illinois employers who ignore their state mandate could face fines of $250 per employee in the first calendar year, which climbs to $500 per employee year two.
Discover more: S Corporation Health Insurance and Retirement Plans
Here's a breakdown of the penalties for non-compliance in some states:
It's crucial to research your state's specific regulations regarding state-mandated retirement plans to avoid these penalties.
Plan Comparison and Alternatives
State-mandated retirement plans can be a good option, but it's essential to consider the alternatives. Some plans to consider include 401(k), Safe Harbor 401(k), Cross Tested Profit-Sharing Allocation, and 401(k) plus Cash Balance Plan.
These plans offer more flexibility than state-mandated plans, which can be rigid. For example, employer-sponsored plans often have administrative fees, but they can also offer more investment options and higher contribution limits.
Here's a comparison of state-mandated and employer-sponsored plans:
It's also worth noting that employer-sponsored plans can offer tax credits to help recoup some administrative costs.
State Plan vs. Independent Provider
Choosing between a state plan and an independent provider for your retirement plan is a crucial decision. State plans can be rigid, while employer-sponsored programs offer more flexibility.

Most state plans don't have upfront costs, but traditional plans have administrative fees that can range from $1,000 to $3,000 per year on average. If you're eligible for the IRS start-up costs tax credit, it can help with up to 50% of your startup costs.
To be eligible for the tax credit, you need to have fewer than 100 employees. The credit can be used for ordinary and necessary costs, such as setting up and administering the plan, and educating employees about the plan.
State-facilitated programs usually limit how much employees can put toward their nest egg, with contribution limits set by the federal government at $6,500 per year for Roth IRAs. In contrast, some traditional 401(k) plans allow employees to contribute up to $22,500 annually.
Here's a comparison of state-mandated and employer-sponsored plans:
How 401(k) Compare
When comparing 401(k) plans, it's essential to consider the different types of plans available, such as the Safe Harbor 401(k) and Cross Tested Profit-Sharing Allocation. These plans offer unique benefits and features that can help businesses meet their retirement plan needs.
Curious to learn more? Check out: 401k Retirement Planning
The 401(k) plus Cash Balance Plan is another option to consider, offering a combination of traditional 401(k) features and a cash balance plan component. This can provide employees with a more comprehensive retirement savings plan.
SIMPLE 401(k) Plans are also worth considering, as they offer a simplified plan design and lower administrative costs. Group 401(k) Plans, such as MEPs, PEPs, and Aggregation Programs, can provide businesses with more flexibility and cost savings.
403(b) Plans are specifically designed for non-profits and can offer tax benefits and flexibility in plan design. By working closely with a trusted partner, businesses can create a customized plan that meets their specific needs and goals.
A unique perspective: Are Small Businesses Required to Offer Retirement Plans
Massachusetts: Voluntary
Massachusetts has a voluntary plan that's available now, but there's a catch - it's only for businesses with more than 25 employees.
Employers of non-profits won't be penalized for not joining the state's plan or offering a qualifying plan because the system is opt-in.

The state is actually considering expanding this program to all businesses with more than 25 employees, but as of now, that legislation hasn't passed.
This means that for now, it's a case-by-case basis, and employers will need to decide whether to join the state's plan or offer their own qualifying plan.
Plan Administration and Costs
Plan administration and costs can be a significant factor in choosing a state mandated retirement plan. State plans usually don't have upfront costs, which can be a big help for small businesses.
However, employer-sponsored plans can have administrative fees, which can range from $1,000 to $3,000 per year on average. These costs can be recouped with tax credits, such as the IRS start-up costs tax credit, which can cover up to 50% of startup costs for eligible employers.
Research is key to understanding the options and costs of different providers. No one provider is the same, and some may offer more value in the long run.
How Common Work Works

Common work arrangements can vary, but some key features are worth noting. Many states offer automatic enrollment for new hires after 30 to 60 days.
You can expect to see deductions of three to five percent of your paycheck, depending on the state. This is a common range, but it's not set in stone.
Employees can opt-out of the plan or change the amount they contribute at any time. It's a flexible system that allows you to take control of your retirement savings.
Here are some key details to keep in mind:
- Automatic enrollment after 30 to 60 days
- Deductions of 3-5% of paycheck
- Ability to opt-out or change contribution amount
Costs and Incentives
Many small businesses can launch a 401(k) at little or no net cost. This makes it an attractive option for entrepreneurs and small business owners who want to offer a retirement plan to their employees.
The costs of 401(k) administration can be minimal, especially for small businesses with fewer employees. In fact, some plans may not have any net cost at all.
Tax incentives can also help offset the costs of 401(k) administration. By offering a 401(k) plan, small businesses can provide a valuable benefit to their employees while also reducing their own tax liability.
Essentials for Business Owners
State-mandated retirement plans can be a complex topic, but understanding the essentials can help small business owners navigate the process.
In some states, employers are required to offer retirement plans, such as CalSavers in California.
Business owners must research their state's specific regulations to ensure compliance.
Ignoring a state mandate can lead to penalties, which vary by state. For example, employers in Oregon could face penalties up to $5,000 per calendar year for non-compliance.
Employers in Illinois could face fines of $250 per employee in the first calendar year, increasing to $500 per employee in the second year.
To stay informed, business owners should check their state's website for the latest information on state-mandated retirement plans.
You might enjoy: What Does a Business Plan Include
Delaware
Delaware has been at the forefront of state-mandated retirement plans, launching its state-sponsored retirement plan, Delaware EARNS, in 2022.
Delaware EARNS promotes individual retirement savings by automatically enrolling employees in a Roth IRA, with the option to opt-out. Employers can choose an independent retirement plan administrator or participate in the state's program.
As of October 15, 2024, Delaware requires employers with five or more employees, who do not offer a retirement savings program, to offer one. This rule applies to private sector employers, including nonprofit organizations.
Employers may choose an independent retirement plan administrator or participate in the state's program, Delaware EARNS. A pilot program was launched in May 2024, and employer registration officially opened on July 1, 2024.
Employers who do not comply with the new rule will be required to participate in the future. Insurance for the program is offered through OnPay Insurance Agency, LLC (CA License #0L29422).
Curious to learn more? Check out: Not for Profit Retirement Plans
Frequently Asked Questions
Are employers required to offer their employees retirement plans? Employers typically decide whether to offer their employees access to retirement savings plans, but some states require eligible employers to provide a retirement savings program.
There is no law requiring employers to provide 401(k) plans to their employees, though many offer this benefit to recruit workers and improve retention.
State-sponsored retirement plans are designed to help individuals save for retirement through automatic payroll contributions set up by their employer. Most plans are Roth IRAs, but others may be 401(k)s.
Here's a quick rundown of the types of retirement plans mentioned:
- Roth IRA: A type of state-sponsored retirement plan that allows individuals to save for retirement on a tax-free basis.
- 401(k): A type of retirement savings plan that allows employees to contribute a portion of their salary to a retirement account, often with employer matching.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are pension plans federally mandated?
No, pension plans are not federally mandated, but employers who establish plans must meet certain minimum standards under ERISA. The law does not dictate specific benefit amounts, giving employers flexibility in designing their retirement plans.
Is a retirement plan mandatory in the USA?
In the USA, a retirement plan is not mandatory at the federal level, but some states require employers to offer a retirement plan by state law. However, employers must comply with federal regulations set by ERISA.
Featured Images: pexels.com


