
The Intel Corp. Investment Policy Committee v. Sulyma ERISA Fiduciary Breach Case is a significant example of a fiduciary breach in the context of employee benefit plans.
The case involved Intel's 401(k) plan, which included an automatic enrollment feature that invested plan participants' contributions in a target-date fund.
Intel's Investment Policy Committee was responsible for managing the plan's investments, but they failed to disclose the plan's investment options and fees to participants.
This lack of disclosure led to a breach of fiduciary duty, as the committee had a responsibility to act in the best interests of plan participants.
On a similar theme: R (Kwik-Fit (GB) Ltd) V Central Arbitration Committee
Key Issues
The Supreme Court's decision in Intel Corp. Investment Policy Committee v. Sulyma will have significant implications for employees and employers alike.
The key issue at hand is the interpretation of Section 413(2) of ERISA, which sets a three-year statute of limitations for alleged breaches of fiduciary duty.
The question is, when does this clock start ticking? The Supreme Court needs to decide whether it's when the plaintiff has actual knowledge of the violation or when they have access to relevant information, even if they don't read or understand it.
A unique perspective: Scion S Capital Meaning Michael Burry
The statute of limitations is a critical factor in determining when a plaintiff can file a lawsuit. If the clock starts running too soon, it may prevent employees from seeking justice.
Both parties agree that the text of Section 413(2) establishes that the three-year statute of limitations runs from the date on which the plaintiff had actual knowledge of a violation.
The disagreement lies in what constitutes actual knowledge. The petitioner argues that it means being in possession of proof of the violation, whether or not the plaintiff is aware of it.
Background and Context
Christopher Sulyma worked at Intel from 2010 to 2012, participating in two of the company's retirement plans governed by ERISA. He had his accounts managed by an Intel investment committee.
The investment committee invested Sulyma's accounts in the Intel Global Diversified Fund and the Intel Target Date 2045 Fund. These funds included investments in hedge funds and other alternative investments.
Sulyma accessed some information about his investments but wasn't aware his retirement accounts were involved.
See what others are reading: Individual Savings Account
Statutory Interpretation of Section 1113(2)
Statutory interpretation of Section 1113(2) is crucial in understanding the context of bankruptcy law.
This section is often referred to as the "absolute priority rule."
The absolute priority rule states that senior creditors must be paid in full before junior creditors receive any payment.
In other words, senior creditors have a higher claim on the assets of the bankrupt company than junior creditors.
This rule is essential in ensuring that creditors are treated fairly and that the rights of senior creditors are protected.
For your interest: Absolute Return
Background
Christopher Sulyma worked at Intel from 2010 to 2012, where he participated in two of the company's retirement plans governed by ERISA.
He had his accounts invested in alternative investments like hedge funds, which didn't perform as well as comparable portfolios.
Intel disclosed the investment decisions and fund performance on two websites, but Sulyma claimed he wasn't aware his retirement accounts were involved.
On October 29, 2015, Sulyma filed charges against Intel, alleging the investment committee had imprudently invested in alternative investments and failed to disclose information about the investments.
A unique perspective: Two Sigma Investments Interview Questions

Intel argued that Sulyma's complaint was untimely under ERISA's three-year statute of limitations, which begins on the earliest date the plaintiff had actual knowledge of the breach or violation.
The United States District Court for the Northern District of California initially granted summary judgment in favor of Intel, but the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals reversed and remanded the ruling.
Sulyma's case highlights the importance of understanding ERISA's statute of limitations and the concept of actual knowledge in ERISA cases.
Impact and Decision
The 9th Circuit's decision in this case gives plaintiff lawyers a very friendly forum for digging up old ERISA fiduciary breach claims.
The court's reasoning makes it difficult for employers to assert a statute-of-limitations defense against ERISA fiduciary claims.
Even employers that have fully complied with plan disclosure obligations might find it hard to defend themselves.
This is because plaintiffs can simply argue they never read the information provided to them.
As a result, employers need to be extra cautious when it comes to plan disclosure obligations.
Court Process
The court process in the Intel Corp. Investment Policy Committee v. Sulyma case centers around a specific statute of limitations. The three-year limitations period in Section 413(2) of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act is key to understanding the court's decision.
This statute of limitations runs from the earliest date on which the plaintiff had actual knowledge of the breach or violation. The plaintiff's knowledge is what triggers the clock, not when they received the information.
The court must determine whether the plaintiff's choice to ignore or not recall reading the information affects the start of the limitations period. In other words, did the plaintiff's inaction or lack of recall prevent the clock from starting?
Curious to learn more? Check out: Payback Period
Featured Images: pexels.com


