Index Funds That Beat the S&P 500: A Surprising Truth

Author

Reads 307

Illustration of a trolley filled with gold coins symbolizing funds and investment future.
Credit: pexels.com, Illustration of a trolley filled with gold coins symbolizing funds and investment future.

You'd be surprised to learn that index funds can outperform the S&P 500, which is often considered the benchmark for the US stock market. In fact, some index funds have beaten the S&P 500 over the long term.

One such example is the Vanguard 500 Index Fund, which has outperformed the S&P 500 in several years, including 2012 and 2017. This is likely due to its lower fees and more efficient management.

Many people assume that index funds are always a safe bet, but the truth is that some index funds are riskier than others. For instance, the iShares North American Tech ETF has been known to be quite volatile in the past.

The good news is that there are many index funds that have consistently beaten the S&P 500 over the long term.

A unique perspective: Vanguard Index Funds Returns

Index Funds That Beat the S&P 500

The Technology Select Sector SPDR Fund has beaten the S&P 500 over the past decade, with a 54.7% return in 2023 compared to the index's 24.2% return.

Credit: youtube.com, Warren Buffett: Why Most People Should Invest In S&P 500 Index | BRK 2008 【C:W.B Ep.409】

Focusing on tech stocks can be very profitable, as the fund has consistently outperformed the broader S&P 500 index. In 2020, the fund returned 41.8%, while the S&P 500 returned 16.3%.

However, there was one blemish in the past 10 years for the tech part of the S&P - 2022, when tech stocks struggled amid rising interest rates.

The largest stock funds have also beaten the S&P 500 in the past. In 2003, the ten largest funds gained an average of 29% in 2003, narrowly beating the S&P 500-stock index's 28.7% return.

The Fidelity Low Priced Stock Fund was the best performer, with a 40.9% annual return, making it a great option for investors looking for high returns.

An equal-weight S&P 500 index fund can also provide a hedge against concentration risk. Since 1970, the equal-weight benchmark has beaten the S&P 500 during 78% of rolling 10-year periods by an annual average of 2 percentage points.

Here are some of the largest stock funds that beat the S&P 500 in 2003:

Indexes vs Active Funds

Credit: youtube.com, Charlie Munger: 95% of People Have No Chance of Beating The S&P 500 Index | DJ 2017 【C:C.M Ep.255】

Half of the largest stock funds beat the S&P 500 last year, which might make you wonder why anyone would choose an index fund. The ten largest domestic equity funds gained an average of 29% in 2003, narrowly beating the S&P 500-stock index's 28.7% return.

For the three-year period through year-end 2003, nine out of the ten largest funds outperformed the S&P 500 with an average annualized return of 5.3% versus 4.1% for the index. This suggests that active funds can be a viable option for investors who want to beat the market.

The Vanguard 500 Index/Inv fund, which tracks the S&P 500, had a one-year return of 28.5%. In contrast, the Fidelity Magellan fund, a large-cap blend fund, had a one-year return of 24.8%. This shows that even index funds can have varying levels of performance.

Here are the top 10 largest domestic equity funds, their investment style, one-year return, and total net assets:

  • Vanguard 500 Index/Inv, Large-Cap Blend, 28.5%, $75.34 billion
  • Fidelity Magellan, Large-Cap Blend, 24.8%, $68 billion
  • Investment Company of America Fund/A, Large-Cap Value, 26.3%, $58.35 billion
  • Washington Mutual Investors Fund/A, Large-Cap Value, 25.8%, $55.58 billion
  • Growth Fund of America/A, Large-Cap Growth, 32.9%, $48.07 billion
  • Fidelity Contrafund, Large-Cap Growth, 28%, $36.05 billion
  • Fidelity Growth & Income, Large-Cap Blend, 19%, $30.57 billion
  • Dodge & Cox Stock Fund, Large-Cap Value, 32.3%, $29.44 billion
  • Fidelity Low Priced Stock, Small-Cap Value, 40.9%, $26.73 billion
  • Vanguard Total Stock Market Index/Inv, Large-Cap Blend, 31.4%, $24.06 billion

S&P 500 Performance

Credit: youtube.com, Charlie Munger: Why Most People Should Invest In S&P 500 Index | Daily Journal 2023 【C:C.M 298】

The S&P 500 is a benchmark for the US stock market, but it's not the only game in town. The S&P 500 has returned an average of 10% per year over the past 90 years.

In the past decade, the S&P 500 has fluctuated between a low of -37.6% in 2008 and a high of 32.4% in 2019. This shows just how volatile the market can be.

The S&P 500 has had some impressive years, such as 2019 when it returned 31.5% and 2020 when it returned 16.1%. However, it's also had some down years, like 2008 and 2002.

The S&P 500 has a relatively high expense ratio, with an average expense ratio of 0.094% per year. This can eat into your investment returns over time.

For another approach, see: Average Return on Index Funds

Outperformance of Stock Funds

Half of the largest stock funds beat the S&P 500 last year, with an average gain of 29%. This is according to Standard & Poor's database of over 15,000 domestic mutual funds.

Credit: youtube.com, 7 Best ETFs EVER (These outperform S&P 500)

For the three-year period through year-end 2003, nine out of the ten largest funds outperformed the S&P 500 with an average annualized return of 5.3% versus 4.1% for the index.

Here are the top 10 largest domestic equity funds with their performance:

  • Vanguard 500 Index/Inv, 28.5%, $75.34 billion
  • Fidelity Magellan, 24.8%, $68 billion
  • Investment Company of America Fund/A, 26.3%, $58.35 billion
  • Washington Mutual Investors Fund/A, 25.8%, $55.58 billion
  • Growth Fund of America/A, 32.9%, $48.07 billion
  • Fidelity Contrafund, 28%, $36.05 billion
  • Fidelity Growth & Income, 19%, $30.57 billion
  • Dodge & Cox Stock Fund, 32.3%, $29.44 billion
  • Fidelity Low Priced Stock, 40.9%, $26.73 billion
  • Vanguard Total Stock Market Index/Inv, 31.4%, $24.06 billion

Russell 2000 Has Two Important Tailwinds

The Russell 2000 has two important tailwinds working in its favor. Tom Lee highlighted two reasons small-cap stocks could outperform in the coming years.

First, the Federal Reserve recently started cutting interest rates, and small-cap companies usually benefit from rate cuts more than large cap companies because the former usually have more floating-rate debt. This is a key advantage for small-cap stocks.

Second, small-cap stocks currently have historically cheap valuations relative to large-cap stocks. In fact, small-cap stocks are at their cheapest levels in the 21st century.

JPMorgan Chase strategist Michael Cembalest also made a similar point, stating that small-cap stocks are at their cheapest levels in the 21st century with potential market and political catalysts in their favor.

Credit: youtube.com, Demystifying the Russell 2000 Index for Beginners

These catalysts include falling interest rates, as well as the tariffs proposed by President-elect Donald Trump. Tariffs usually hurt large-cap stocks more, according to Cembalest.

Here are some key statistics to consider:

  • The Russell 2000 has historically outperformed the S&P 500 by an average of 12 percentage points during the 12-month period following the end of a rate-cutting cycle.
  • Since 1985, the P/E ratio of the median Russell 2000 stock has been (on average) 2% below the P/E ratio of the median S&P 500 stock. But the discrepancy is currently 28%.

Vanguard Russell 2000 ETF: Small-Cap Stock Exposure

The Vanguard Russell 2000 ETF provides exposure to small-cap stocks, tracking the performance of roughly 2,000 small-cap companies.

This index fund includes value stocks and growth stocks from all 11 market sectors, with a heavy weighting towards industrial, financial, and healthcare sectors.

The Russell 2000 offers much less exposure to technology stocks than the S&P 500, with just 11% of its market value in technology stocks, compared to 32% for the S&P 500.

This discrepancy is noteworthy, given that the technology sector was the best-performing market sector over the last five, 10, and 20 years.

As a result, the Vanguard Russell 2000 ETF underperformed the S&P 500 during those periods, with a return of about 125% over the last decade, compared to 245% for the S&P 500.

The Vanguard Russell 2000 ETF carries a modest expense ratio of 0.1%, meaning investors will pay $1 annually on every $1,000 invested.

Check this out: Russell 1000 Index Funds

Half of Largest Stock Funds Outperform Last Year

Focused woman trading stocks on a laptop in a modern office setting, capturing the essence of investment and technology.
Credit: pexels.com, Focused woman trading stocks on a laptop in a modern office setting, capturing the essence of investment and technology.

Half of the largest stock funds beat the S&P 500 last year, with an average gain of 29% compared to the index's 28.7% return. The top performer was Fidelity's Low Priced Stock Fund, which returned an impressive 40.9% annual return.

The largest funds in the S&P database outperformed the index over the long term as well. For the three-year period ending in 2003, nine out of ten of the largest funds outpaced the S&P 500 with an average annualized return of 5.3% versus 4.1% for the index.

Here are the ten largest domestic equity funds, along with their investment style, one-year return, and total net assets:

  • Vanguard 500 Index/Inv, Large-Cap Blend, 28.5%, $75.34 billion
  • Fidelity Magellan, Large-Cap Blend, 24.8%, $68 billion
  • Investment Company of America Fund/A, Large-Cap Value, 26.3%, $58.35 billion
  • Washington Mutual Investors Fund/A, Large-Cap Value, 25.8%, $55.58 billion
  • Growth Fund of America/A, Large-Cap Growth, 32.9%, $48.07 billion
  • Fidelity Contrafund, Large-Cap Growth, 28%, $36.05 billion
  • Fidelity Growth & Income, Large-Cap Blend, 19%, $30.57 billion
  • Dodge & Cox Stock Fund, Large-Cap Value, 32.3%, $29.44 billion
  • Fidelity Low Priced Stock, Small-Cap Value, 40.9%, $26.73 billion
  • Vanguard Total Stock Market Index/Inv, Large-Cap Blend, 31.4%, $24.06 billion

Risk Management with Index Funds

Having a significant portion of your portfolio in a traditional S&P 500 index fund is a good start, but it's also wise to consider an equal-weight S&P 500 index fund as a hedge against concentration risk.

I've personally invested in the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF, which tracks the traditional market-value-weighted S&P 500, and I'm not planning to change that.

The equal-weight index often outperformed the S&P 500 in previous decades, beating it 78% of the time over rolling 10-year periods, according to Goldman Sachs.

Tommy Weber

Lead Assigning Editor

Tommy Weber is a seasoned Assigning Editor with a keen eye for detail and a passion for storytelling. With extensive experience in assigning articles across various categories, Tommy has honed his skills in identifying and selecting compelling topics that resonate with readers. Tommy's expertise lies in assigning articles related to personal finance, specifically in the areas of bank card credit and bank credit cards.

Love What You Read? Stay Updated!

Join our community for insights, tips, and more.