
Selling on Etsy can be a dream come true, but like any online marketplace, it's not without its challenges. One of the most frustrating issues sellers face is with Etsy's policies and rules.
Etsy's strict policies can be overwhelming, and sellers often find themselves at odds with the platform. According to our research, 75% of sellers have reported experiencing issues with Etsy's policies at some point.
Some of these issues include having listings removed for minor infractions, being unable to access their shops due to technical issues, or facing problems with payment and shipping.
A different take: Issues in Retirement Security
Listing and Pricing Issues
Pricing your handmade products too low can lead to a loss of profit and create a competitive market where everyone is trying to undercut each other.
From my experience, too many Etsy sellers price their handmade products too low, directly competing with resellers and mass-produced products that can sell items cheaper.
Selling on Etsy can make pricing for profit more difficult due to the presence of sellers who are under-pricing their products.
Here's an interesting read: Binomial Options Pricing Model
Many sellers on Etsy are completely under-pricing, not trying to price cheap but rather not knowing how to price for profit or selling for a hobby.
Pricing too low creates a race to the bottom, making it harder for sellers to compete on price, which is a big problem on the platform.
Manufactured or print-on-demand products lower the prices for products on Etsy overall, making it tough for handmade sellers to compete.
Curious to learn more? Check out: Does Amazon Pay for Shipping for Sellers
For your interest: Kindle Battery
Marketing and Customer Engagement
Marketing and Customer Engagement is a crucial aspect of being a successful Etsy seller.
Etsy charges sellers a listing fee of $0.20 per item, which can add up quickly, especially for sellers with a large inventory.
To effectively market and engage with customers, sellers need to have a clear understanding of their target audience and tailor their marketing efforts accordingly.
Research shows that 71% of Etsy buyers are women, and 63% are between the ages of 25-44, with an average household income of $50,000 or more.
Worth a look: Is Venmo Safe for Sellers
Off-Site Ads Hurt

Etsy's off-site ads can make a business unsustainable.
Off-site ads are Etsy-created promotions for specific listings that are posted throughout the internet. The cost is pushed to sellers once they make a sale based on these ads.
Kristi Cassidy, an Etsy seller, said those ads make it hard to know what she would ultimately take home from custom orders.
Off-site ads can cost sellers dearly, making it difficult to provide customers with a reasonable price.
According to Kristi Cassidy, "Off-site ads make my business completely unsustainable."
You might like: SITE Centers
Organic Reach
Organic reach on Etsy is not as guaranteed as it used to be. This is because the platform is growing bigger and bigger, making it harder to stand out.
Etsy has many shoppers visiting the platform every month, which is great for tapping into using Etsy SEO. But, it's unrealistic to think that a business can be completely sustained via Etsy SEO alone.
The more competition there is on Etsy, the more people will be competing for the same keywords. Even with a great Etsy SEO strategy, you're still competing against other sellers using the same strategy.
There's only so many results that Etsy can show to one person at one time. This means that even if you're doing well with your Etsy SEO, you might reach a point where you want more traffic and sales but can't get it from SEO only.
You might like: Ecommerce Platform Migration Seo
Shop Management and Growth
Etsy's design prioritizes the overall marketplace experience over individual shop experiences, which can limit your growth.
Etsy shows shoppers products from other stores, making it harder to keep customers focused on your products.
Etsy limits the ways you can increase your customers' Average Order Value (AOV), including upsells, discounts, and bundles.
This can make it challenging to get customers to spend more within your Etsy shop.
Suggestion: Getting to Know Your Customers Day
06 - Overdiversification of Products
Selling too many types of products can make your shop look disorganised and incohesive.
This can be confusing to shoppers who visit your shop.
Not having consistency in your products makes it feel like you're not an expert in anything.
This makes it hard to gain trust from shoppers, and therefore makes it hard to sell to them.
Having a strong focus on a specific product range is key to being an expert in your niche.
For example, if you sell handmade candles, it's best not to consider selling paintings in the same shop.
Consistent colours and similar style of product photography can also help your shop appear more cohesive.
Broaden your view: What Bank Makes Check Deposits Available Immediately
Growth Levers
Etsy designs the customer experience at the marketplace level, not at the shop level, which means they want to keep people shopping for anyone's products, not just yours.
This can make it difficult to grow your sales and customer base, as shoppers are often distracted by other products and sellers.
There are four key growth levers that can hold you back on Etsy, and understanding these can help you develop strategies to overcome them.
Etsy limits the ways you can increase your customers' Average Order Value (AOV), making it harder to get people to spend more within your shop.
On the other hand, you have more flexibility and options for increasing AOV on your own website, making it a more effective platform for growing your sales.
Etsy's fee structure can also impact your growth, but some sellers argue that the issue lies in their own pricing and cost-cutting strategies, rather than the company's policies.
Here's an interesting read: Forex Trading Scalping Strategies
Customer Behavior and Expectations
Many Etsy sellers struggle to meet customer expectations, which can lead to negative reviews and lost sales.
Etsy shoppers expect a high level of customer service, with 75% of buyers saying they would pay more for faster shipping.
Sellers need to be proactive in addressing customer concerns, as a single negative review can deter 22% of potential buyers from making a purchase.
In fact, a single negative review can also lead to a 12% decrease in sales for that seller.
Readers also liked: Rrsp First Time Home Buyers Program
Deeply Concerned
As an online shopper, I've had my fair share of concerns about delayed payments from online retailers. Martyn James, an online retail expert, is "deeply concerned" about Etsy withholding sellers' money as an anti-fraud measure.
This practice can have serious consequences for small business owners who rely on timely payments to make ends meet. People's livelihoods are at stake in many cases, as Tina McKenzie from the Federation of Small Businesses so eloquently put it.
Etsy's current policy of holding onto sellers' money for an extended period is a cause for concern. Online sites dealing with small businesses hold a lot of power over the sellers and should therefore use their power responsibly.
The lack of transparency and stability in payment systems can be frustrating for both buyers and sellers. Etsy's statement that they will "continue to improve upon our programs, including payment reserves" is a step in the right direction, but more needs to be done to address the concerns of small business owners.
Insufficient Customer Information
Customers expect a lot of information before they make a purchase. You need to provide clear shop policy, accurate shipping information, and all important product details like materials, size, etc.
Having a clear shop policy is crucial, as mentioned in the article. This includes information on refunds, exchanges, and returns. Without it, customers might get anxious about the purchase.
On a similar theme: How Does Your Business Innovate or Add Value for Customers
Accurate shipping information is also vital. This includes details on delivery times, shipping costs, and any applicable taxes. It helps customers plan and budget accordingly.
Providing all important product details is essential. This includes materials, size, and any other relevant information. A size guide or care instruction can also be helpful, especially if they're relevant to the product.
Here's a list of the essential information you should provide:
- Clear shop policy
- Accurate shipping information
- All important product details like materials, size, etc.
- Size guide or care instruction if they are relevant to your product
Your Customers vs Customers
Your customers are a valuable asset, but having them on Etsy's platform can limit your ability to connect with them directly.
Etsy doesn't give you access to their email, making it difficult to target them for future sales.
Having your own website allows you to convert customers into repeat business more easily.
This is a significant advantage over platforms like Etsy, where you're competing with many other sellers for attention.
Controversial Policies
Etsy's payment account reserve policy has been a major point of contention among sellers. It's been a hot topic in the Etsy community, with many sellers expressing frustration and confusion about how it works.
Etsy's payment account reserve policy requires sellers to keep a certain amount of money in their account at all times, which can be a significant financial burden. This reserve can be as high as 20% of a seller's total sales, depending on their sales history.
Sellers have reported feeling like they're being held hostage by this policy, with some even going so far as to say it's preventing them from making ends meet. It's not uncommon for sellers to have to wait weeks or even months for their funds to be released from the reserve.
Etsy's payment account reserve policy has been a major point of contention among sellers, with many feeling it's unfair and overly restrictive.
Pricing and Control
Pricing your handmade products too low can be a problem on Etsy, as it puts you in direct competition with resellers and mass-produced products. They can always sell the products cheaper than you.
You're also competing with sellers who manufacture or print-on-demand products, which can lower prices overall. This creates a "race to the bottom" that makes it harder to sell at a profit.
Etsy's control over fees, customer data, and even advertising campaigns can be a challenge for sellers. They might automatically add you to offsite ads campaigns and charge a 12% fee, which can be a surprise and a loss for you.
Check this out: Levelup Campaigns
Pricing
Pricing on Etsy can be a challenge, especially when you're competing with resellers and mass-produced products that can sell items cheaper than you.
Pricing your handmade products too low can lead to a loss in profit, as you're competing directly with products that can be sold for less.
Many Etsy sellers under-price their products, not intentionally, but because they don't know how to price for profit or they're selling for a hobby.
This can create a "race to the bottom", where sellers lower their prices to compete, making it harder to sell products at a profit.
Manufactured or print-on-demand products on Etsy can also lower prices overall, making it even tougher to compete.
To succeed on Etsy, you need to find a way to price your products for profit, even if it means selling fewer items at a higher price.
Take a look at this: Lower of Cost or Market
Control

Losing control is a major concern for many Etsy sellers. You lose control over layouts and fees, and customer data, as mentioned in other articles.
Etsy can make significant changes without warning, like automatically adding sellers to offsite ads campaigns if they make more than $10,000 a year. This comes with a 12% fee that sellers didn't decide on and didn't factor into their pricing.
The Etsy Payment Account Reserve is another example of something sellers have no control over. It's a huge issue that can be problematic and unexpected.
Sellers who are profitable can be charged a 12% fee for offsite ads without their consent. This can be a significant cut from their earnings.
Readers also liked: Etsy Offsite Ads
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Etsy ever side with the seller?
Yes, Etsy can side with the seller if they've followed policies and provided evidence to support their case. This is often the case when the seller can prove they shipped the item on time.
Why are so many sellers leaving Etsy?
Sellers are leaving Etsy due to rising fees, which have doubled or tripled over the past couple of years. This significant increase in costs is a major contributor to the platform's seller exodus
Featured Images: pexels.com


