Crown Corporation Overview: History, Purpose, and Governance

Author

Reads 8K

Crown Building
Credit: pexels.com, Crown Building

Crown corporations have a long history dating back to the 19th century, with the first crown corporation being the Canadian Pacific Railway, established in 1885.

Their primary purpose is to serve the public interest by providing essential services and goods, often in industries where private companies cannot or will not operate.

Crown corporations are created by an Act of Parliament, giving them a unique status as a hybrid between a private company and a government agency.

Governance is a key aspect of crown corporations, with boards of directors and executives responsible for making key decisions and overseeing operations.

Definition

A Crown corporation is a term that's often used in Canada, but its definition can be a bit murky.

There is no common definition of a Crown corporation among Canadian governments.

The Canadian federal government has its own definition, which states that a Crown corporation must be wholly owned by the government.

This means that the government has complete control over the corporation, which can be a good thing in terms of accountability.

A yellow sign with a crown on it
Credit: pexels.com, A yellow sign with a crown on it

The federal government's definition also requires that the corporation have enabling legislation that sets out its mandate, powers, and objectives.

This legislation serves as a kind of blueprint for the corporation, outlining its goals and how it should operate.

In addition, the federal government's definition states that the corporation must operate at arm's length from the government, but be ultimately accountable to it.

This means that the corporation has a degree of independence, but is still answerable to the government.

The province of Ontario, however, uses a different term to refer to its government-owned entities - "agencies".

For more insights, see: Glass–Steagall Legislation

Economic Impact and Purpose

Crown corporations have a significant economic footprint, with annual commercial operations equivalent to 7% of Canadian GDP.

Government business enterprises had revenues of $199 billion in 2023, with $120 billion generated at the provincial and territorial level.

Crown corporations provide essential services such as electricity, potable and wastewater services, and public transit, often at the local level.

There are hundreds of local government-owned enterprises, such as Metro Vancouver's public transit authority Translink, that operate as Crown corporations.

Some Crown corporations, like Air Canada, are created to be active competitors in markets where private industry may not provide adequate service.

Economic Impact

Aerial shot of bridge construction in Ho Chi Minh City, featuring cranes and scaffolding over a wide river.
Credit: pexels.com, Aerial shot of bridge construction in Ho Chi Minh City, featuring cranes and scaffolding over a wide river.

Crown corporations have a significant economic footprint in Canada, with annual commercial operations equivalent to 7% of the country's GDP.

In 2023, government business enterprises generated $199 billion in revenues, with $120 billion coming from the provincial and territorial level.

The federal government had 47 Crown corporations in 2022, while Ontario had over 170 agencies in 2025, and British Columbia had 29 Crown corporations.

These Crown corporations provide essential services such as electricity, potable and wastewater services, and public transit, with hundreds of local government-owned enterprises operating across the country.

Local services like Metro Vancouver's public transit authority, Translink, are examples of Crown corporations that play a vital role in daily life.

Additional reading: Rochester Transit Corporation

Purpose

Crown corporations are generally formed to fill a need that the government deems in the public or national interest.

Their purpose is to provide services that may not be profitable for private industry to offer, as was the case with Air Canada, which was created to be a competitor in a market with inadequate competition and service.

Some Crown corporations are expected to be profitable organizations, while others rely entirely on public funds to operate.

Their role is often debated, with some questioning whether they should exist at all, but they continue to serve a vital function in the economy.

A unique perspective: Is Abnb Profitable

Structure and Governance

Contemporary interior of new boardroom equipped with wooden table and red office chairs
Credit: pexels.com, Contemporary interior of new boardroom equipped with wooden table and red office chairs

Crown corporations are created through either an Act of Parliament or by articles of incorporation under the Canada Business Corporations Act. Each one is accountable to Parliament through the minister responsible for that particular corporation.

The minister responsible appoints the corporation's board of directors, and the cabinet appoints the CEO and determines their rate of pay. The board and MPs have some input, but the government makes the ultimate decision.

Most Crown corporations have to undergo an annual audit and submit annual corporate plans, operating budgets, and capital budgets for approval by the minister responsible. They also have to submit quarterly financial reports.

Here are some key facts about Crown corporations' governance:

Structure

The structure of the Government of Canada is quite complex, but it can be broken down into a list of departments and agencies.

The Government of Canada has a number of departments and agencies that work together to achieve its goals.

The List of Departments and Agencies of the Government of Canada is a comprehensive resource that outlines all the different departments and agencies.

Ownership and Accountability

A yellow sign with a crown on it
Credit: pexels.com, A yellow sign with a crown on it

Crown corporations are directly owned by the government as the enterprise's sole legal shareholder.

In Canada, governments are sometimes referred to as "the Crown", which makes it easy to understand why they're called Crown corporations.

The government owns each Crown corporation, and they're ultimately accountable for the conduct of their affairs to the federal parliament or a provincial legislature through the relevant minister.

Crown corporations are operated with much greater managerial autonomy than government departments, giving them greater freedom from direct political control.

They're shielded from constant government intervention and legislative oversight, which allows them to make decisions without constant interference.

The government can still have some influence, however, by issuing directives to the board of directors ordering them to take specific actions.

These directives must be tabled in both houses of Parliament within 15 sitting days of being issued.

Crown corporations also have to undergo periodic mandate reviews to assess their performance and cost-effectiveness.

Provincial and Territorial Crown Corporations

A shiny pink miniature crown in a still life setting with bright lighting.
Credit: pexels.com, A shiny pink miniature crown in a still life setting with bright lighting.

Provincial Crown Corporations operate similarly to their federal counterparts, with accountability to the provincial government and directors appointed by the provincial cabinet. They are involved in various sectors, including utilities, gaming, liquor, and telecommunications.

Hydro-Québec is a prominent example of a provincial Crown corporation, responsible for generating and transmitting electricity. In Alberta, the term "public agency" is used to describe organizations established by government, but not part of a government department.

Some provinces have a long history of using Crown corporations to diversify their economies and preserve jobs. In Quebec, for instance, Crown corporations have been instrumental in the steel, oil, and gas, forestry, and asbestos industries.

Here's a list of some notable provincial Crown corporations:

  • Utilities: Hydro-Québec, NB Power, BC Hydro
  • Gaming: Ontario Lottery and Gaming Corporation, BCLC, Manitoba Liquor & Lotteries Corporation
  • Liquor: LCBO in Ontario, SAQ in Quebec, New Brunswick Liquor Corporation
  • Culture: Royal Ontario Museum, Film Nova Scotia, Yukon Arts Centre
  • Telecommunications: SaskTel, BC Telecom

Provincial Crown corporations have also faced controversy, such as the 2006 price-fixing scheme involving two vice-presidents of Quebec's liquor control board. This led to new governance rules for Crown corporations.

History and Evolution

Crown corporations have been around since 1841, when the Board of Works was established to construct shipping canals in Canada.

Credit: youtube.com, The Crown Corporation

The first major crown corporations were created in the 20th century to meet transportation needs, including the Canadian National Railway Company (CN), Air Canada, and the St. Lawrence Seaway Authority.

In 1938, the Bank of Canada became a Crown corporation, expanding its reach to financial services.

Crown corporations have been involved in various industries, including transport, telecommunications, utilities, power generation, and even alcohol sales.

Some notable crown corporations include Petro-Canada, founded in 1975, and Canada Post Corporation, established in 1981.

The 1970s saw a debate about the role and effectiveness of crown corporations, leading to privatization efforts in the 1980s and 1990s, including the sale of Air Canada, Petro-Canada, and Canadair.

For more insights, see: Petro (token)

History

The history of Crown corporations in Canada dates back to 1841 with the establishment of the Board of Works to construct shipping canals.

Crown corporations were created to provide essential services in a large and sparsely populated country, where the private sector was often unable or unwilling to step in.

Two young girls in princess crowns enjoying a playful moment indoors on a white background.
Credit: pexels.com, Two young girls in princess crowns enjoying a playful moment indoors on a white background.

The first significant Crown corporations were created to meet transportation needs, including the Canadian National Railway Company (CN) in 1922, Air Canada, and the St. Lawrence Seaway Authority.

The Bank of Canada, originally privately owned, became a Crown corporation in 1938.

Crown corporations have been involved in a wide range of industries, including transport, telecommunications, utilities, and power generation.

Some notable Crown corporations include Petro-Canada, founded in 1975, and Canada Post Corporation, which replaced the federal Post Office Department in 1981.

In the 1970s, a debate emerged about the role and effectiveness of Crown corporations, and whether they had become too prominent in the economy.

Many Crown corporations were privatized in the 1980s and 1990s, including Air Canada, Petro-Canada, and Canadair, under the leadership of Prime Minister Brian Mulroney.

Some provinces, such as British Columbia, Saskatchewan, and Nova Scotia, also privatized their phone companies, electricity companies, and other assets.

However, new Crown corporations have since been created, such as the Canadian Air Transport Security Authority (CATSA), which was formed in response to the 11 September 2001 attacks to provide passenger and baggage screening at airports.

Former

Aerial view of the Azerbaijan House of Government building in Baku, highlighting its grand architecture.
Credit: pexels.com, Aerial view of the Azerbaijan House of Government building in Baku, highlighting its grand architecture.

As we explore the history and evolution of Crown corporations in Canada, it's fascinating to learn about those that have undergone significant changes or ceased to exist.

Several private Canadian companies were once Crown corporations, while others have gone defunct.

Here are some notable examples of former Crown corporations:

The list of former Crown corporations is quite extensive, and it's interesting to see how some of these companies have evolved over time.

List of Federal

A federal Crown corporation is a business or organization that is owned and controlled by the federal government. These corporations are responsible for providing various services and goods to Canadians, and they operate independently of the government.

The Bank of Canada is a federal Crown corporation responsible for managing the country's monetary policy and regulating the banking system.

Canada has a total of 35 federal Crown corporations, each with its own mandate and area of expertise.

Here is a list of some of the federal Crown corporations, grouped by ministry:

As you can see, these corporations play a vital role in supporting various aspects of Canadian society, from transportation and finance to arts and culture.

Provincial Crown Corporations

Government Building in City
Credit: pexels.com, Government Building in City

Provincial Crown Corporations are accountable to the provincial government and their directors are appointed by the provincial cabinet.

They function similarly to their federal counterparts, with a mix of traditional and modern roles. Provincial Crown Corporations have traditionally been involved in utilities, such as Hydro-Québec, which generates and transmits electricity.

Some provinces have also used Crown Corporations to diversify their economies and preserve jobs. In Quebec, for example, Crown Corporations have been used to nurture francophone managers and create jobs.

Provincial Crown Corporations have also been involved in gaming and lotteries, such as Manitoba Lotteries Corporation, and selling liquor, like the Liquor Control Board of Ontario. In some provinces, they have even operated railways.

Hydro-Québec is a major example of a Crown Corporation that has been successful in diversifying the economy and creating jobs. It's a great model for other provinces to follow.

Mixed Economy and Privatization

Canada's crown corporations are a key part of its "mixed" economy, a combination of government and privately-owned enterprise.

Woman in Face Paint and Crown Sitting on Ground Holding Skull
Credit: pexels.com, Woman in Face Paint and Crown Sitting on Ground Holding Skull

In 1841, the first Canadian crown corporation, the Board of Works, was established to construct a shipping canal system in the Province of Canada, and by 2019, there were 47 crown corporations in operation across the country.

Many crown corporations were created to meet transportation needs, such as Canadian National Railways (CN) and Air Canada, which have since been privatized.

Crown corporations provide important services in a vast, sparsely populated nation, often where the private sector is unable or unwilling to provide them.

The federal government has also owned and operated coal mines, such as the Cape Breton Development Corporation, and a major integrated oil and gas company, Petro-Canada, which is now privatized.

In contrast to the United States, where state-owned enterprises are less common, Canada's crown corporations create a distinct difference in the industrial organization of the two countries.

In the mid-1980s, the Canadian government began a process of privatization, selling off iconic crown corporations like Petro-Canada and Air Canada.

Mixed Economy

Close-up of a modern building corner featuring a BMO logo on its glass facade.
Credit: pexels.com, Close-up of a modern building corner featuring a BMO logo on its glass facade.

Canada's mixed economy is characterized by the presence of crown corporations, which are government-owned enterprises that provide essential services. By 2019, there were 47 crown corporations operating across the country.

The first Canadian crown corporation, the Board of Works, was established in 1841 to construct a shipping canal system in the Province of Canada. It was a response to the private sector's inability or unwillingness to provide this service.

Many crown corporations were created to meet transportation needs, such as Canadian National Railways and Air Canada, although both have since been privatized. The St. Lawrence Seaway Authority, now known as the St. Lawrence Seaway Management Corporation, is another example.

The federal government also established crown corporations to provide financial services to groups that were not well-served by private institutions. These include the Farm Credit Corporation for farmers and the Export Development Corporation for exporters.

In some cases, the federal government has owned and operated industries such as coal mining, as seen with the Cape Breton Development Corporation.

Here's an interesting read: Abbott Established Pharmaceuticals

Privatization

Design of Brand Logo
Credit: pexels.com, Design of Brand Logo

In the mid-1980s, a significant sell-off of public assets occurred in the United Kingdom under British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher.

The government of Prime Minister Brian Mulroney responded by appointing a minister of state for privatization, overseeing the sale of iconic crown corporations such as Petro-Canada and Air Canada.

Between the mid-1980s and mid-1990s, various other key crown corporations were privatized by Ottawa and the provinces, including CN and the Alberta Liquor Control Board.

In Canada, the provinces were also involved in privatization efforts, with Nova Scotia Power being privatized during this time.

The sale of crown corporations continued, with Petro-Canada and Air Canada being sold in the mid-1980s.

Stephen Harper's government introduced measures in its 2013 budget bill giving it new powers over collective bargaining, salaries, and working conditions at four crown corporations, including the CBC.

Government Oversight and Funding

Crown corporations are accountable to Parliament through the minister responsible for that particular corporation. This minister, with approval of the federal cabinet, appoints the corporation's board of directors, and the cabinet appoints the CEO and determines the rate of pay for all directors and the CEO.

For another approach, see: Who Appoints the Sec Chair

Headquarters of the Hrvatska Radiotelevizija and surrounding Houses in Summer
Credit: pexels.com, Headquarters of the Hrvatska Radiotelevizija and surrounding Houses in Summer

The government can intervene in the management of a Crown corporation by issuing a directive to the board of directors. This directive must be tabled in both houses of Parliament within 15 sitting days of being issued.

All Crown corporations have to undergo an annual audit, and most have to submit annual corporate plans, operating budgets, and capital budgets for approval by the minister responsible. This ensures that the corporation is being managed economically and efficiently.

Crown corporations can be funded in different ways, with some being fully funded by government appropriations and others being financially self-sufficient or profit-making corporations that pay dividends. Profit-making corporations like Canada Post, the Royal Canadian Mint, and the Canada Development Investment Corporation have greater autonomy in how they operate and are subject to less government oversight.

Here's a breakdown of the different types of Crown corporations and their funding:

Government Funding

Crown corporations are funded by the government, but the degree of financial support varies. Some are fully funded by government appropriations.

Blue emblem sticker of World Health Organization on carton boxes heaped on table
Credit: pexels.com, Blue emblem sticker of World Health Organization on carton boxes heaped on table

Some Crown corporations are financially self-sufficient or profit-making, paying dividends to the government. The government, as the sole shareholder, collects these dividends.

Canada Post, the Royal Canadian Mint, and the Canada Development Investment Corporation are examples of profit-making corporations that operate in a competitive environment. They have greater autonomy and less government oversight compared to other Crown corporations.

These three organizations do not have to submit an annual operating budget for government approval. They are listed in Schedule III Part II of the Financial Administration Act.

Crown corporations that are not profit-making may still have some financial autonomy. However, they typically require government approval for their annual operating budgets.

Readers also liked: Operating Ratio

Oversight Sufficiency

Crown corporations are accountable to Parliament through the minister responsible for that particular corporation. This means that the minister has some level of control over the corporation's operations.

The government can intervene in the management of a Crown corporation by having the minister responsible issue a directive to the board of directors ordering them to take some specific action. This directive must be tabled in both houses of Parliament within 15 sitting days of being issued.

Credit: youtube.com, Revisiting Federal Funding Oversight

Most Crown corporations have to undergo a "special examination" at least every 10 years to verify that their finances are in order and that they are being managed "economically and efficiently." This examination is usually carried out by the auditor general.

The government also carries out periodic mandate reviews to assess a corporation's performance, its cost-effectiveness, whether it's meeting the objectives of its mandate and whether there is a continuing need for it. These reviews can lead to changes in the corporation's operations or even its eventual privatization.

Following the 2003 auditor general's report into the federal sponsorship program, the government instituted a series of reforms to tighten oversight and improve accountability and transparency at Crown corporations. These reforms included splitting the CEO and the chairperson of the board into two distinct positions and making the CEO the sole representative of management before the board.

As a result of these reforms, Crown corporations are now subject to more stringent oversight and accountability measures. For example, the auditor general is now the sole or joint internal auditor for all Crown corporations except the Bank of Canada.

Here is a list of the key reforms implemented by the government:

  • Split the CEO and the chairperson of the board into two distinct positions
  • Restricted the participation of public servants on the boards of Crown corporations
  • Appointed the auditor general as the sole or joint internal auditor for all Crown corporations except the Bank of Canada
  • Instituted new guidelines for the process of appointing directors and CEOs that allowed for greater input from the board of directors and members of Parliament
  • Made several Crown corporations subject to the Access to Information Act that previously were not

Federal vs. Provincial Differences

Credit: youtube.com, Federal vs Provincial Incorporation in Canada

Provincial Crown corporations are accountable to the provincial government, with their directors appointed by the provincial cabinet.

Their areas of involvement include gaming, liquor stores, utilities, and culture. For example, the Ontario Lottery and Gaming Corporation and Hydro-Québec are both provincial Crown corporations.

The SAQ, Quebec's liquor control board, has had its share of controversy, including a price-fixing scheme in 2006.

The first Crown corporation of the modern era was the Canadian National Railway Company, created in 1922 out of more than 200 companies.

In contrast, federal Crown corporations are accountable to the federal government, but specific details about their differences are not mentioned in the article.

Controversy and Reform

The controversy surrounding crown corporations has been a long-standing issue in Canada. The 1970s saw a major debate emerge about their roles and effectiveness.

Many observers felt that major crown corporations, particularly CN, had escaped political control. Successive auditors-general criticized the financial management of crown corporations.

Credit: youtube.com, Who Staffs Crown Corporations?

The controversy was so severe that it led to the passing of Bill C-24 in 1984. The law established new schedules or types of crown corporations and extended the Cabinet's ability to issue directives.

However, critics felt that Bill C-24 generally codified existing procedures and policies, breaking little new ground. Despite this, it did clarify the process of budgetary approval and ensured that corporate plans be submitted to Cabinet for approval and to Parliament for discussion.

The controversy continued, with an auditor-general investigation in 2003 revealing financial management concerns at a number of crown corporations. This led to major reforms at crown corporations and the 2006 Federal Accountability Act.

The Act extended the list of crown corporations accountable under the Access to Information Act and brought changes to the appointment of board members. It also restricted the number of civil servants on boards and split the Chief Executive Officer and Chair roles into two distinct positions.

A fresh viewpoint: Extended Care Health Option

List of

Credit: youtube.com, Crown corporation control

Air Canada was privatized in 1988, marking a significant shift in the company's ownership structure.

The list of former Crown corporations in Canada is extensive, with many companies having undergone privatization or restructuring over the years.

Here are some notable examples:

The privatization of these companies has led to changes in their ownership structures and operations, with some companies being sold to private investors or merged with other companies.

Business or Government Agency?

Crown corporations are a unique blend of government and business. They're created to advance certain policy objectives, but also have to operate in a business capacity.

They're often created to fill a need the government feels is not being met by the private sector. This can be due to the private sector being unable or unwilling to provide certain services the government deems necessary or in the national interest.

Canada Post is an example of a Crown corporation that provides a service that wouldn't be economically feasible for a private enterprise to undertake. They deliver mail in remote or sparsely populated parts of the country.

Crown corporations can also provide public services or functions that don't quite fall under the purview of a federal or provincial ministry. The Atlantic Pilotage Authority, for instance, licenses and employs marine pilots who navigate vessels through waterways in and around the Atlantic provinces.

Business or Government Agency?

Credit: youtube.com, How to Do Business With the Government

Crown corporations are a unique blend of government and private enterprise. They're created to advance specific policy objectives and operate at arm's length from government.

Some Crown corporations have to balance their policy mandate with commercial interests and competitive pressures. This can lead to conflicts, but it's a necessary part of their role.

Crown corporations are often created to fill a need that the private sector can't or won't meet. They might provide services that aren't economically feasible for a private enterprise, such as delivering mail to remote areas.

Examples of such corporations include Canada Post and Marine Atlantic. Canada Post delivers mail in rural areas, while Marine Atlantic operates a ferry service between Newfoundland and Labrador and Nova Scotia.

Crown corporations can also provide public services that don't fit within a government ministry. The Atlantic Pilotage Authority, for instance, licenses and employs marine pilots to navigate vessels through waterways.

The BC Assessment Authority produces independent annual property assessments for property owners in British Columbia. This is just one example of a Crown corporation performing a specific function that's not part of a government ministry.

Sectors of Operation

Low angle of diverse elegant women with identity badges working in government office and discussing building in town
Credit: pexels.com, Low angle of diverse elegant women with identity badges working in government office and discussing building in town

Crown corporations have been most common in sectors such as transportation and telecommunications.

They also operate in utilities and power generation, which are essential services for many communities.

Crown corporations have extended into many parts of the economy, including alcohol sales and gaming.

Some Crown corporations provide administrative services to certain industries, like the Canadian Dairy Commission, which sets reference prices and monitors supply for the dairy industry.

The Canadian Commercial Corporation brokers defence contracts between foreign governments and Canadian companies, showing how they can facilitate business development and international trade.

Sectors of Operation

Crown corporations operate in a wide range of sectors, including transportation and telecommunications.

They also extend into sectors like utilities and power generation, making them a significant presence in many parts of the economy.

Some Crown corporations provide administrative services to certain industries, such as setting reference prices and monitoring supply for the dairy industry, as seen with the Canadian Dairy Commission.

Others, like the Canadian Commercial Corporation, broker defence contracts between foreign governments and Canadian companies.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is CN Rail a Crown corporation?

No, CN Rail is not a Crown corporation. It was privatized in 1995 after being a Canadian Crown corporation from its founding in 1919.

Rodolfo West

Senior Writer

Rodolfo West is a seasoned writer with a passion for crafting informative and engaging content. With a keen eye for detail and a deep understanding of the financial world, Rodolfo has established himself as a trusted voice in the realm of personal finance. His writing portfolio spans a range of topics, including gold investment and investment options, where he provides readers with valuable insights and expert advice.

Love What You Read? Stay Updated!

Join our community for insights, tips, and more.