Compare Medicare Supplement Insurance Companies for the Right Plan

Author

Reads 1.1K

Top view of various supplements and capsules arranged on a marble surface with ample copy space.
Credit: pexels.com, Top view of various supplements and capsules arranged on a marble surface with ample copy space.

Choosing the right Medicare Supplement insurance plan can be overwhelming, especially with so many companies to consider. Aetna offers 10 different Medicare Supplement plans, while Cigna offers 9.

Each company has its own strengths and weaknesses. For example, Aetna's Plan F has a $0 deductible, but Cigna's Plan F has a $0 deductible for the first 6 months.

Some plans, like Aetna's Plan G, have a higher premium but lower out-of-pocket costs. Others, like Cigna's Plan N, have lower premiums but higher out-of-pocket costs.

Ultimately, the best plan for you will depend on your individual needs and budget.

Additional reading: Aetna Medicare Supplement Plan

Medicare Supplement Insurance Companies

United American Insurance Company is one option to consider for Medicare Supplement insurance. They can be reached at (800) 755-2137 or [email protected].

Their policy plans for individuals over 65 include A, B, C, D, F, High F, G, High G, K, L, and N. However, they do not offer Group Policy Plans for individuals over 65.

It's worth noting that not all Medicare Supplement insurance companies offer the same plans. For example, North Carolina legislatively mandates eligibility to individuals eligible for Medicare due to disability, guaranteeing them access to Medigap policies A, D, or G.

Credit: youtube.com, The Best Medicare Supplement Plans in 2024 and 2025

AARP/United Healthcare Insurance Company offers various policy plans for individuals and groups. They have a customer service phone number of (800) 523-5800.

Their policy plans include 65 Over Group Special Policy Plans, which are available in types A, B, C, F, G, K, L, and N. Under 65 Group Special Policy Plans are available in types A, B, C, F, G, and K.

Rates for AARP/United Healthcare Insurance Company vary according to Medicare enrollment date and discount eligibility. To be eligible, you must be a member of AARP at the time of issue.

Here are some key details about their policy plans:

Humana Benefit Plan of Illinois, Inc

Humana Benefit Plan of Illinois, Inc offers a range of Medicare Supplement Insurance plans.

You can reach their customer service department by calling (888) 310-8482.

They offer individual policy plans for people over 65, which include plans A, F, G, High G, and N.

Group policy plans are not available for people over 65.

For individuals under 65, Humana Benefit Plan of Illinois, Inc offers individual policy plans A, F, G, High G, and N.

Group policy plans are not available for individuals under 65.

Their premium rates are listed for Preferred (Non-Smoker/Not eligible for Medicare due to disability/Guaranteed Acceptance) customers.

National Health Company

Credit: youtube.com, Medicare Supplement Plans Explained (best plans for 2025)

National Health Insurance Company offers a range of Medicare Supplement Insurance plans. They provide customer service through a phone number: (888) 376-3300, and an email address: [email protected].

Their plans include A, F, High F, G, and N options for individuals under 65, as well as for those 65 and older. However, they do not offer group policy plans to anyone.

You can contact State Farm for customer service, as they don't provide a direct number. State Farm offers plans A, C, D, F, G, and N to individuals under 65 and 65 and older, but not group policy plans.

Some plans have specific requirements, like State Farm's plans C and F, which are only available to those who were previously eligible prior to January 1, 2020.

Here's a summary of National Health Insurance Company's Medicare Supplement Insurance plans:

United American Company

United American Company offers a range of Medicare Supplement Insurance plans. Their customer service phone number is (800) 755-2137, and you can also reach out to them via email at [email protected].

Two Muslim Female Office Workers Holding Documents and Talking
Credit: pexels.com, Two Muslim Female Office Workers Holding Documents and Talking

Their 65 Over Individual Policy Plans include options like Plan A, Plan B, Plan C, Plan D, Plan F, Plan G, and Plan N. However, it's worth noting that rates for Plan B are only available for Open Enrollment/Guarantee issue, while underwritten rates are available at all times.

One thing to keep in mind is that United American Company does not offer High Deductible Under 65 plans anymore. If you're under 65 and looking for a plan, you can consider options like Plan A, Plan B, Plan C, Plan D, Plan F, and Plan N.

Here's a summary of their plans:

Keep in mind that these plans and rates are subject to change, so it's always a good idea to check with United American Company directly for the most up-to-date information.

Choosing a Plan

You can choose from 10 standardized Medicare Supplement plans, each with its own set of benefits and costs. These plans are designated with letters A-N.

Credit: youtube.com, Best Medicare Supplement Companies in 2025 | Top Medigap Providers & Rates

Medigap plans are usually designated with a letter A-N, and you'll want to compare costs and what different plans offer. These benefits may include Part A coinsurance and hospital costs, Part B copays and coinsurance, and your first 3 pints of blood if you need it.

To find a Medigap plan, you can search online at Medicare.gov based on your ZIP code, and compare monthly premiums, copays and coinsurance, deductibles, and plan benefits. You'll also want to consider factors like price and customer service to find the best Medicare Supplement Insurance companies for you.

Here's a breakdown of the types of Medigap plans:

  • Basic benefits: Medigap Plan A
  • Basics plus some extras: Medigap Plan B, Medigap Plan M
  • Highest coverage: Medigap Plan D, Medigap Plan G
  • Lower premiums, but higher copays: Medigap Plan N
  • Lowest premiums — partial coverage: Medigap Plan K, Medigap Plan L
  • No longer for sale to new Medicare members: Medigap Plan C, Medigap Plan F

You can also call and talk to someone about your options through your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) or your State Insurance Department.

Plans

Choosing a Plan can be overwhelming, but let's break it down. There are 10 standardized Medicare supplement insurance plans, labeled A-N. These plans are designed to fill the gaps left by Original Medicare (Parts A and B).

Credit: youtube.com, How To Choose The Best Healthcare Plan (2022!)

You can choose from various plan types, such as Basic benefits (Plan A), Basics plus some extras (Plan B or M), Highest coverage (Plan D or G), or Lower premiums, but higher copays (Plan N). Each plan type offers the same Medicare benefits everywhere and from every company.

Here's a breakdown of the standard Medigap plan types:

Keep in mind that not all plans will cover all benefits, and some will cover only a portion of some costs. You'll want to carefully consider your healthcare needs and the benefits that each plan offers.

It's essential to note that some plans may have additional features, such as a high-deductible option or a copayment for some office visits. Be sure to review the plan details and ask questions before making a decision.

The Parts

Choosing the right Medicare plan can be overwhelming, but let's break it down. Medicare Part A covers hospital insurance, which is a must-have for any Medicare beneficiary.

Seniors Exercising
Credit: pexels.com, Seniors Exercising

There are four main parts to Medicare: A, B, C, and D. Each one serves a different purpose and offers unique benefits.

Medicare Part A is usually free for most people, as it's funded through payroll taxes. However, you'll need to pay for copays and hospital stays out of pocket.

Medicare Part B covers medical insurance, which includes doctor visits, outpatient care, and preventive services. It requires a monthly premium, which is deducted from your Social Security benefits.

Here are the five main parts of Medicare:

  • Medicare Part A (hospital insurance)
  • Medicare Part B (medical insurance)
  • Medicare Part C (Medicare Advantage)
  • Medicare Part D (prescription drug plan)
  • Medicare Supplement Insurance (Medigap)

Medicare Part C, also known as Medicare Advantage, is an alternative to Original Medicare. It's offered by private insurance companies and may offer additional benefits, such as dental and vision coverage.

Medicare Part D covers prescription drug plans, which can be added to Original Medicare or Medicare Advantage. It's essential for managing medication costs and accessing the medications you need.

Medicare Supplement Insurance, also known as Medigap, helps fill the gaps in Original Medicare coverage. It's sold by private insurance companies and can be used to cover copays, deductibles, and other out-of-pocket expenses.

Premium and Cost

Credit: youtube.com, Medicare Plan G vs Plan N (New Info!)

The premium and cost of Medicare Supplement insurance can be a bit confusing, but don't worry, I've got you covered.

The monthly premium of your Medicare Supplement plan will vary by both plan and insurance carrier. A good rule of thumb is that the higher level of coverage a plan offers, the higher the premium is going to be.

Medicare Supplement plan premiums can be affected by factors such as the insurance carrier's financial rating and history of premium increases. You'll want to look at these factors when assessing different insurance carriers.

There are three different ways Medicare Supplement premiums can be rated: Community-rated, Issue-age-rated, and Attained-age-rated. Community-rated premiums are the same for everyone, regardless of age, but may increase due to inflation. Issue-age-rated premiums are based on your age when you purchased the plan, and will not increase as you get older. Attained-age-rated premiums start low and increase as you get older.

An Insurance Agent and an Elderly Man Shaking Hands
Credit: pexels.com, An Insurance Agent and an Elderly Man Shaking Hands

Here's a quick rundown of the three rating systems:

I recommend considering these factors when choosing a Medicare Supplement plan, as they can help you make an informed decision about your premium and cost.

Enrollment and Planning

You should buy Medicare Supplement Insurance during your Medigap open enrollment period, which starts once you're 65 and enrolled in Medicare Part B, and lasts for six months. This is the cheapest and easiest time to get a policy.

If you're still working after 65 and covered by a group employer plan, your six-month period starts after you've ended active employment or no longer have that insurance. Insurance companies can't factor your health or medical history into your price during this time, making it a great opportunity to get a policy.

The prices may go up or you may be denied coverage due to your health status or medical history after the open enrollment period ends.

When to Enroll

An Elderly Man Consulting an Insurance Agent
Credit: pexels.com, An Elderly Man Consulting an Insurance Agent

You should buy Medicare Supplement Insurance during your Medigap open enrollment period, which starts once you're 65 and enrolled in Medicare Part B, and lasts for six months. This is the cheapest and easiest time to get a policy, as insurance companies can't factor your health or medical history into the price.

If you're still working after 65 and covered by a group employer plan, your six-month period starts after you've ended active employment or no longer have that insurance. This is an important consideration, as it can affect when you can enroll in a Medigap policy.

During your Medigap open enrollment period, you won't be denied coverage due to your health status or medical history. However, after this period ends, prices may go up or you may be denied coverage.

Here are some key facts to keep in mind about your Medigap open enrollment period:

If you fail to apply for a Medigap policy within your open enrollment period, you may lose the right to a policy without regard to your health. So, it's essential to apply during this time to ensure you get the best deal.

Benefits of Planning

Insurance Broker Presenting an Offer to an Elderly Couple
Credit: pexels.com, Insurance Broker Presenting an Offer to an Elderly Couple

Having a Medicare Supplement plan can be a game-changer for your healthcare expenses. You'll be able to cover the 20% of costs that Medicare doesn't pay, which can be a significant relief for your retirement savings.

Medicare Supplement plans also cover many of the gaps left by your hospital insurance, Medicare Part A, such as deductibles and coinsurances. This can help you avoid surprise medical bills and reduce your out-of-pocket expenses.

Private insurance can be costly, but Medigap plans have premiums that are much lower than their private counterparts. This can be a huge cost-saver for you.

With a Medicare Supplement plan, you won't have to worry about network limitations. As long as a doctor or hospital accepts Medicare, they'll also take your supplemental insurance.

Here are some key benefits of a Medicare Supplement plan:

  • Covers 20% of costs that Medicare doesn't pay
  • Covers deductibles and coinsurances for Medicare Part A
  • Has lower premiums than private insurance
  • No network limitations
  • No health status requirements for enrollment during open-enrollment window

Benefits and Coverage

Medicare supplement insurance can be a lifesaver for those looking to cover out-of-pocket expenses. Generally, Medigap policies don't cover long-term care, vision services or eyeglasses, dental services, or private nursing.

Senior People in Traditional clothing Waiting on Stage
Credit: pexels.com, Senior People in Traditional clothing Waiting on Stage

A Medigap plan can cover a fair bit of what Medicare doesn't, including the remaining 20% of your costs for medically approved treatment under Medicare Part B. This can be a big relief for those on a fixed income.

Medicare Supplement plans also cover many of the gaps left by your hospital insurance, Medicare Part A, such as deductibles and coinsurances. This can be especially helpful for those with ongoing medical needs.

Private insurance can be costly, but Medigap plans have premiums that are much lower than their private counterparts. You can cut your costs significantly by enrolling in a Medicare supplement plan.

One of the biggest bonuses with having a supplement is that there are no networks to worry about. If a doctor or hospital accepts Medicare, then they will take your supplemental insurance as well.

Here are some benefits of a Medicare Supplement plan:

  • Covers the remaining 20% of your costs for medically approved treatment under Medicare Part B
  • Covers many of the gaps left by your hospital insurance, Medicare Part A, such as deductibles and coinsurances
  • Has lower premiums than private insurance
  • Has no network limitations, so you can see any doctor or hospital that accepts Medicare

Where to Buy and Essentials

To buy a Medicare supplement policy, you'll need to make application directly with the insurance company. You can contact the company that sells the specific policy you want or an agent who sells the policy you're interested in.

Elderly businessman focused on reviewing documents at his office desk.
Credit: pexels.com, Elderly businessman focused on reviewing documents at his office desk.

It's recommended that you apply at least 30 days before you want the policy to start. If you don't have 30 days, apply as soon as possible. You'll need to pay the premiums directly to the insurance company, and they won't be deducted from your Social Security payments.

You can use Medicare's interactive website tool to compare Medicare supplement plans quickly and easily. To start, click the search button on Medicare.gov and enter your zip code. You can then select "Plan Details" to review the coverage for each standardized Medicare supplement plan or "View Policies" to review the list of companies offering that plan along with their estimated premiums.

Here are the steps to compare Medicare supplement plans:

  • Decide which plan you want and compare the benefits each plan helps pay for.
  • Pick your policy, as price is the only difference between policies with the same letter sold by different companies.
  • Contact the company or a licensed insurance agent to get a quote.

Note that prices can change at any time based on when you buy, your health conditions, and more.

Where to Buy Medigap?

You can buy a Medigap plan directly from an insurance company or through a licensed insurance agent.

Senior woman in a swimsuit enjoying leisure time by the indoor pool, promoting health and vitality.
Credit: pexels.com, Senior woman in a swimsuit enjoying leisure time by the indoor pool, promoting health and vitality.

To find a Medigap plan, you can search online at Medicare.gov based on your ZIP code. You’ll be able to compare monthly premiums, copays and coinsurance, deductibles, and plan benefits.

You can also compare Medigap plans by using Medicare's interactive website tool, which allows you to compare plans quickly and easily. To access this tool, simply click the search button on Medicare.gov and enter your zip code.

It's worth noting that prices can change at any time based on when you buy, your health conditions, and more. So, it's a good idea to contact the company or a licensed insurance agent to get a quote.

Here are some options for shopping for a Medigap plan:

  • Medicare.gov (search by ZIP code)
  • Medicare's interactive website tool
  • State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) or State Insurance Department (free advice)

Remember, you won't be auto-enrolled into a Medigap policy, so you'll need to make application directly with the insurance company.

The Essentials of

You'll need to decide which Medicare Supplement plan is right for you, and the good news is that you have a lot of options to choose from. There are many factors that go into determining rates for a policy, including age, gender, tobacco status, where you live, discounts, and medical underwriting if applicable.

An Agent Showing Documents to an Elderly Man
Credit: pexels.com, An Agent Showing Documents to an Elderly Man

You can compare Medicare Supplement plans quickly and easily using Medicare's interactive website tool. This tool allows you to enter your zip code, age, gender, and tobacco status to get an estimate of the premiums for different plans.

To get started with buying a Medicare Supplement policy, you'll need to contact the insurance company that sells the specific policy you want, or work with an agent who sells the specific policy you're interested in. We recommend applying at least 30 days before you want the policy to start, but if you don't have that much time, apply as soon as possible.

Here are the basic steps to follow:

  • Decide which plan you want by comparing the benefits each plan helps pay for.
  • Pick your policy, keeping in mind that price is the only difference between policies with the same letter sold by different companies.
  • Contact the company or a licensed insurance agent to get a quote, as prices can change at any time based on when you buy, your health conditions, and more.

Remember, you're not required to purchase a Medicare Supplement plan, but it's a good idea to consider one to cover the 20% of your healthcare costs that Medicare doesn't cover.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the downside to Medicare Supplement plans?

Medicare Supplement plans come with two main downsides: high premiums and limited coverage, leaving you to pay out of pocket for certain expenses like dental and vision care.

Johnnie Parisian

Writer

Here is a 100-word author bio for Johnnie Parisian: Johnnie Parisian is a seasoned writer with a passion for crafting informative and engaging content. With a keen eye for detail and a knack for simplifying complex topics, Johnnie has established herself as a trusted voice in the world of personal finance. Her expertise spans a range of topics, including home equity loans and mortgage debt consolidation strategies.

Love What You Read? Stay Updated!

Join our community for insights, tips, and more.