
The Anti-Monopoly Law of China is a significant piece of legislation that aims to promote fair competition and prevent monopolistic practices. The law was enacted in 2008 and has undergone several amendments since then.
The law specifically prohibits anti-competitive agreements, abuse of dominant market positions, and mergers that may lead to a monopoly. These provisions are designed to prevent companies from engaging in practices that stifle innovation and limit consumer choice.
The Anti-Monopoly Law of China applies to all industries, including high-tech and pharmaceutical sectors. This broad scope ensures that companies operating in China must comply with the law's provisions, regardless of their field of operation.
The law also establishes the State Administration for Market Regulation (SAMR) as the primary enforcement agency, responsible for investigating and punishing anti-monopoly practices.
On a similar theme: Accident Injury Lawyer Insurance Companies Okc
Administration
The administration of the Anti-Monopoly Law in China is a complex process. It involves several regulatory bodies working together to prevent monopolistic activities.
The State Council has established two key regulatory bodies: the Anti-Monopoly Committee (AMC) and the Anti-Monopoly Enforcement Agency (AEA). The AMC is responsible for developing competition legislation and policy, while the AEA enforces the Anti-Monopoly Law.
The AEA's enforcement powers are divided among three agencies: the National Development & Reform Commission (NDRC), the State Administration for Industry & Commerce (SAIC), and the Ministry of Commerce (MOFCOM). The NDRC focuses on price-related offenses, the SAIC handles monopoly agreements, abuses of dominant market position, and abuses of administrative powers, while the MOFCOM deals with merger control.
Administrative enforcement is conducted by the NDRC and SAIC at both national and provincial levels. This means that depending on the matter, enforcement can take place at either the national or provincial level.
Here's a breakdown of the enforcement authorities:
- NDRC: price-related offenses
- SAIC: monopoly agreements, abuses of dominant market position, and abuses of administrative powers
- MOFCOM: merger control
In 2018, the public enforcement right was consolidated under the State Administration for Market Regulation (SAMR). The SAMR authorizes provincial administration for market regulation (local AMRs) to investigate monopoly agreements, abuse of market dominance, and administrative monopoly within their administrative regions.
Private enforcement is also possible, with enterprises harmed by monopolistic practices using litigation for self-protection. First-instance civil monopoly cases are brought before the intellectual property courts and intermediate people's courts designated by the Supreme People's Court.
Suggestion: Contract Law of the People's Republic of China
Anti-competitive Conduct
Anti-competitive Conduct is a major focus of the Anti-Monopoly Law of China. The AML prohibits horizontal monopoly agreements between competitors, including those to fix prices, share markets, or limit production.
To determine if an agreement is monopolistic, the AML considers factors such as market shares, financial capabilities, and technological advantages. If an undertaking has a market share of over 50%, it is presumed to have market dominance.
The AML also covers vertical monopoly agreements, such as fixing resale prices or setting minimum resale prices. However, safe harbours have been introduced, which exempt vertical agreements if the market shares of undertakings involved are below a certain threshold.
Typical abusive behaviours by undertakings with market dominance include selling at unfairly high prices, refusal to deal, and discriminatory treatment. The AML provides rules to presume a dominance based on market shares, which can be a key factor in determining abuse of market dominance.
You might enjoy: Secondary Mortgage Market Enhancement Act
The AML also regulates acquisitions of equity or assets, establishment of new joint ventures, and acquisitions of control by contracts or other means, subject to merger control regulations. Transactions with a combined global turnover exceeding CNY 12 billion or a combined turnover within China exceeding RMB 4 billion are subject to filing requirements.
Transactions below the turnover thresholds may still be subject to filing requirements if deemed to have an anti-competitive effect. The Chinese authorities may require the transaction parties to submit a filing in such cases.
For your interest: Merger Control
Anti-competitive Conduct
Monopoly agreements are prohibited by the AML, including horizontal agreements between competitors, such as fixing resale prices or setting minimum resale prices.
The AML also covers vertical monopoly agreements, including fixing resale prices and setting minimum resale prices, which is also known as resale price maintenance (RPM). Undertakings can defend against RPM claims by demonstrating the absence of anti-competitive effects.
Organising and substantially assisting in monopoly agreements is also prohibited, including hub-and-spoke agreements, which involve both vertical and horizontal relationships.
A fresh viewpoint: 2 Hour Minimum Pay California
Typical abusive behaviors of market dominance include selling at unfairly high or low prices, refusal to deal, exclusive dealing, and discriminatory treatment.
The AML provides rules to presume a dominance based on market share, and the most intuitive factor is the market share itself. The AML outlines factors for determining market dominance, including shares in the relevant markets, ability to control over sales market or inputs market, financial and technological capabilities, other undertakings’ reliance, and market entry.
The Chinese authorities require transactions to submit a filing if a transaction below the turnover thresholds is considered to have an anti-competitive effect.
Transactions are subject to merger control regulations if the combined global turnover exceeds CNY 12 billion and the turnover of at least two undertakings within mainland China exceeds RMB800 million, or if the combined turnover within China exceeds RMB4 billion and the turnover of at least two undertakings within mainland China exceeds RMB800 million.
The Chinese authorities may require the transaction parties to submit a filing if a transaction below the turnover thresholds is considered to have an anti-competitive effect.
For more insights, see: Depository Institutions Deregulation and Monetary Control Act
Leniency
Leniency is a key concept in anti-competitive conduct, and it's worth understanding how it works. The SAMR may offer a reduction in or exemption from the penalty to an undertaking that reports its involvement in a horizontal monopoly agreement.
To be eligible for leniency, the undertaking must take the initiative to report to the antimonopoly enforcement authority. This means proactively coming forward with information about its involvement in the agreement.
The undertaking must also provide important evidence that is critical to the launch of an investigation or the determination of a violation. This evidence can be a game-changer in the eyes of the SAMR.
Leniency can be granted at any time before the SAMR adopts a decision imposing fines. This means that even after an investigation has begun, an undertaking can still come forward and receive leniency if it provides valuable evidence.
Take a look at this: What Is the Difference between an Agreement and a Contract
Rules and Regulations
The Anti-Monopoly Law of China prohibits agreements that eliminate or restrict competition. These agreements are called "monopoly agreements" and are divided into two categories: horizontal and vertical monopoly agreements.
Horizontal monopoly agreements include agreements to fix or change the price of goods. This means that if companies in the same industry agree to raise or lower prices, it could be considered a monopoly agreement.
Vertical monopoly agreements involve agreements between different levels of a supply chain. For example, if a company that produces raw materials agrees with a company that sells the finished product to set a minimum price, it could be considered a vertical monopoly agreement.
Some monopoly agreements are presumed to be illegal. These include:
- Agreements to fix or change the price of goods;
- Agreements to restrict the quantity of goods produced or sold;
- Agreements to divide a sales market or a raw materials procurement market;
- Agreements to restrict the purchase of new technology or new equipment, or to restrict the development of new technology or new products;
- Concerted refusals to deal; and
- Resale price maintenance (RPM).
Exceptions
Exceptions to the Anti-Monopoly Law of China exist for agreements that safeguard legitimate interests in foreign trade and foreign economic cooperation. These exemptions are specified by law or by the State Council.
Under the Anti-Monopoly Law, undertakings can apply for an exemption if their agreements meet certain conditions. To qualify, the agreements must not substantially restrict competition in the relevant market.
Consumers must also receive a fair share of the benefits resulting from the agreement. This is a crucial consideration, as the law aims to ensure that agreements do not harm consumers.
Worth a look: Anti Selection
Agreements with a qualifying purpose, such as technological advancement or product development, may also be exempt. This includes improvements in product quality, increases in efficiency, and reductions in costs.
The following conditions must be met for an exemption to be granted:
- The agreements will not substantially restrict competition in the relevant market;
- Consumers will receive a fair share of the resulting benefits;
- The agreement had a qualifying purpose, such as technological advancement and/or product development, improvement in product quality, increases in efficiency, and reduction in costs.
There is no mechanism under the Anti-Monopoly Law to apply for an exemption, so parties must rely on self-assessment.
Curious to learn more? Check out: Regulation Z Banking
Private Actions
In China, individuals and companies can bring private actions against undertakings that have engaged in monopolistic conduct. This is a significant development, as it allows parties to seek redress for competition complaints.
The number of private enforcement actions has been increasing in recent years, with a significant number of cases pertaining to allegations of abuse of a dominant market position. This includes horizontal and vertical anti-competitive agreements, such as price fixing and resale price maintenance.
A notable example is the case of a seafood wholesale association that was ordered to cease its infringement of the Anti-Monopoly Law by arranging seafood dealers to sell scallops at a fixed price. The association was also fined for dealers that did not adhere to the price fixing agreement.
On a similar theme: Minimum Wage Fixing Convention 1970
In some cases, private actions have been successful in winning damages. For instance, in a 2013 case, an international medical device manufacturer was ordered to pay damages of RMB 530,000 to a distributor for imposing resale price maintenance conditions.
The burden of proof for a plaintiff is addressed in the SPC Rules, which create a presumption of dominance for state-owned companies and public utilities. Expert testimony may be presented in evidence in proceedings before the courts.
Private actions can be brought directly to the court or after a decision on the alleged monopolistic conduct by one of the Antimonopoly Law enforcement authorities. This allows for both stand-alone and follow-on actions.
Here are some notable cases involving private actions:
- In August 2013, the Shanghai Higher People’s Court concluded that an international medical device manufacturer had infringed the Anti-Monopoly Law by imposing resale price maintenance conditions on its distributor.
- In April 2014, the Beijing Higher People’s Court concluded that a seafood wholesale association had infringed the Anti-Monopoly Law by arranging seafood dealers to sell scallops at a fixed price.
Penalties and Liabilities
The Anti-Monopoly Law of China imposes significant penalties on companies that engage in monopolistic conduct. Fines can be as high as 10% of a company's total turnover in the preceding year for concluding and implementing monopoly agreements or abusing a dominant position.
Confiscation of illegal income is also possible under the law. In addition, fines of up to RMB500,000 can be imposed for violations of merger control provisions.
The law also allows for private actions to be brought by parties who have suffered loss as a result of the contravention, with no criminal penalties for monopolistic conduct.
Here are the possible penalties under the Anti-Monopoly Law:
- Fines of up to 10% of total turnover for monopoly agreements or dominant position abuse
- Confiscation of illegal income
- Fines of up to RMB500,000 for merger control violations
- Invalidation of agreements and cease and desist orders
In particularly egregious cases, fines can be increased up to five times, resulting in a maximum fine of 50% of a company's turnover.
Extraterritorial Application
The Anti-Monopoly Law of China has a significant reach beyond its borders. It applies to conduct both within China and outside China that has the effect of eliminating or restricting competition in the Chinese market.
Conduct outside China is considered anti-competitive if it affects the Chinese market. This means that foreign companies must also comply with the law if their actions harm competition in China.
The law's merger control provisions are applicable to foreign mergers where the parties meet specified turnover thresholds in the PRC. This means that foreign companies must report their mergers to the Chinese authorities if they meet certain criteria.
Foreign companies must be aware of the law's extraterritorial reach, as it can have significant consequences for their business in China.
Consider reading: Foreign Investment in Real Property Tax Act
Mergers and Acquisitions
Mergers and Acquisitions in China are heavily regulated under the Anti-Monopoly Law (AML). The Anti-Monopoly Bureau of the State Administration for Market Regulation (SAMR) is responsible for enforcing the merger control regime in China.
If a foreign investor acquires control of a domestic target in certain industry sectors, such as military-industrial and military related enterprises, or major farm products, energy and resources, infrastructures, transportation services, key technologies and major equipment manufacturing involving in the national security, it will be reviewed under the security review regime.
Transactions that trigger certain thresholds must be notified to the SAMR, including when the combined worldwide turnover of all business operators exceeds RMB10 billion, or when the combined domestic turnover of all business operators exceeds RMB2 billion.
Additional reading: Indiana Social Security Insurance Law Firm
The SAMR envisages a two-stage process for reviewing concentration transactions, with a preliminary review that usually takes 30 calendar days, and a potential further review that can take up to 90 days, extendable to another 60 days of advanced review.
Business operators that implement notifiable concentrations without notifying the SAMR and obtaining approval may be ordered to halt the transaction and/or dispose of shares or transfer the business by a certain deadline.
Here are the key thresholds for notification to the SAMR:
Reform
The Chinese government has been working on reforming its anti-monopoly laws, with regulatory bodies drafting rules on antitrust enforcement related to intellectual property rights since 2009.
These draft rules have been under consideration for a long time, with the latest version being issued in June 2014 for public consultation. Delays have been numerous, but the rules are expected to be finalized in 2015.
The Anti-Monopoly Law (AML) appears to allow private enforcement against not just anticompetitive agreements and abuse of dominance, but also against mergers and other concentrations falling within the scope of the merger control provisions in the AML. However, the position on this remains uncertain.
The Supreme People's Court has issued the Provisions of the Supreme People’s Court on the Application of Laws in the Trial of Civil Disputes arising from Monopolistic Practices (SPC Provisions), which regulate private actions under the AML, but make no mention of private action against mergers and other concentrations.
Suggestion: Private Wealth Attorney
Main Features
The Anti-Monopoly Law of China is a comprehensive law that prohibits various types of anti-competitive behavior. It aims to protect competition and consumer welfare in China.
One of the main features of the law is its prohibition on monopoly agreements, abuses of dominance, anticompetitive mergers, and abuses of administrative power. These are all serious offenses that can have significant consequences.
The law also comes with high fines for non-compliance, which serves as a deterrent for companies that might otherwise engage in anti-competitive behavior. These fines can be substantial, making it clear that the law is serious about enforcing its provisions.
The law has an extraterritorial effect, meaning it can apply to companies and individuals from outside China. This is an important aspect of the law, as it shows that China is committed to enforcing its antitrust laws globally.
Here are the main features of the law in a concise list:
- Prohibition on monopoly agreements
- Prohibition on abuses of dominance
- Prohibition on anticompetitive mergers
- Prohibition on abuses of administrative power
- High fines for non-compliance
- Extraterritorial effect
Trends
The Anti-Monopoly Law of China has seen significant changes in enforcement trends over the past few years. Enforcement has focused on digital marketplaces, online sales restrictions and exclusivities, and a significant increase in M&A transactions subject to review.
Major areas of focus include cartels and restrictive practices. The number of M&A transactions subject to review is expected to decrease due to new merger control thresholds.
The technology sector, particularly digital platforms and marketplaces, has been subject to increased scrutiny. This focus is likely to continue, with specific provisions in the Antimonopoly Law addressing competition issues in the digital economy.
A new merger control regime allows the SAMR to review transactions involving small parties with a possible significant impact on competition. This will lead to a more efficient review process.
The SAMR is expected to introduce higher turnover thresholds for mandatory merger clearance. Alternative transaction value thresholds will also be introduced, requiring large domestic Chinese companies to seek clearance for significant acquisitions.
Here are some key trends in enforcement:
- Major focus on digital marketplaces, online sales restrictions and exclusivities
- Significant increase in number of M&A transactions subject to review
- Focus on cartels and restrictive practices
- Increased scrutiny of digital platforms and technology companies
- New merger control thresholds expected to lead to a decrease in the number of M&A transactions subject to review
Frequently Asked Questions
Is monopoly banned in China?
Yes, monopoly is banned in China through the Antimonopoly Law, which prohibits restrictions on competition. The law has four main sets of rules to prevent monopolies and promote fair market practices.
Featured Images: pexels.com


