
A 401k forfeiture occurs when a company recovers an employee's retirement savings due to a plan loan default or other reasons outlined in the plan document.
In the United States, 401k plan forfeiture rates can be as high as 10% of plan assets, with some companies forfeiting even more.
401k forfeitures can happen due to reasons such as employee termination, plan loan defaults, or failure to meet plan requirements.
Companies can use forfeitures to reduce their 401k plan expenses and improve their bottom line.
A different take: Good Reasons to Take Out a 401k Loan
What is 401(k) Forfeiture?
So, you're wondering what 401(k) forfeiture is? A 401(k) forfeiture occurs when a participant leaves a job and hasn't fully vested in their employer's contributions.
Forfeitures are not a full loss, though – you don't lose all the money in your account, only the unearned or unvested portion of the employer's contributions. The participant is still eligible to receive the vested portion of the employer's contributions.
A fresh viewpoint: Multi Participant 401k Plan
Here's how forfeitures work in different scenarios:
In cases where a plan allows multiple types of employer contributions, forfeitures from each type must be applied distinctly, as permitted in the plan documents.
Understanding 401(k) Plans
A 401(k) plan forfeiture occurs when an employee leaves the company before being fully vested in their employer contributions. This means they forfeit the non-vested portion of their account back to the plan.
The plan document or adoption agreement should define how forfeitures can be used, which can include offsetting future employer contributions, paying plan administrative expenses, or allocating to all participants within the plan. Forfeitures can be a useful tool for plan sponsors to maintain control of how these dollars are ultimately distributed.
Here are three common ways forfeitures can be used:
- Redistribute the forfeited amount to the remaining eligible participants.
- Apply the forfeited money towards reasonable plan expenses.
- Use the forfeited money to reduce future contributions.
It's essential for plan sponsors to familiarize themselves with the provisions in their plan documents regarding forfeitures to comply with IRS regulations and defend against potential legal challenges.
Proposed Regulations

The IRS has proposed regulations on forfeitures, which are an essential aspect of 401(k) plan management. Forfeitures incurred under a defined contribution plan must be used within 12 months following the close of the plan year.
The proposed regulations state that forfeitures incurred during any plan year that begins before January 1, 2024 are treated as having been incurred in the first plan year that begins on or after January 1, 2024. This means that those forfeitures must be used no later than 12 months after the end of that first plan year.
These regulations are proposed to apply for plan years beginning on or after January 1, 2024.
You might like: 1 Million in 401k by 50
Understanding Plans
Forfeitures in 401(k) plans can be complex, but it's essential to understand how they work. A plan sponsor's fiduciary responsibility includes directing the use of forfeitures, which can be used to reduce future employer contributions, pay plan administrative expenses, or be allocated to all participants within the plan.
You might like: 401k S and P Index Only Startegy
In cases where a 401(k) plan allows multiple types of employer contributions subject to different vesting schedules, forfeitures from each type must be applied distinctly, as permitted in the plan documents. This means that a participant who is not fully vested in their portion of the employer's contributions will not lose all of the money in their account, but only the unearned or unvested portion.
A terminated plan must vest 100% of the employer's contributions for all current participants. This means that an active participant who is 20% vested would automatically become 100% vested on the effective date of the plan termination.
Certain types of distributions are not subject to forfeitures, namely, upon attainment of normal retirement age and when the plan is terminated. In these cases, the employer contribution is 100% vested.
Here are three ways forfeitures can be used in a 401(k) plan:
- Redistribute the forfeited amount to the remaining eligible participants.
- Apply the forfeited money towards reasonable plan expenses.
- Use the forfeited money to reduce future contributions.
Your retirement plan document spells out exactly how forfeitures are to be treated, so it's essential to review it regularly to ensure compliance with IRS regulations.
Common Misconceptions and Best Practices
Forfeitures from multiple sources must be applied distinctly, as permitted in the plan documents, if a 401(k) plan allows multiple types of employer contributions.
A common misconception is that a participant loses all their money in their account if they're not fully vested in their portion of the employer's contributions, but they only lose the unearned or unvested portion.
Plan sponsors should review their plan's forfeiture account annually to ensure timely use of the forfeitures.
To mitigate risk, plan sponsors should only document fiduciary decisions in meeting minutes, and consider a written forfeiture policy that prioritizes forfeitures for plan expenses before reducing employer contributions.
Plan sponsors should confirm the plan document's forfeiture provisions and discuss them in plan committee meetings, and document these discussions within meeting minutes.
Here are some key takeaways to keep in mind:
When to Use?
Forfeitures need to be used within a specific timeframe to keep your plan in compliance. Most plan documents stipulate that forfeitures must be used by the end of the plan year following the year they occurred.

The IRS has clarified that forfeitures should be exhausted during the year they are incurred, but no later than the end of the following plan year. This means forfeitures shouldn't accumulate and be left untouched.
The proposed regulations require that all forfeitures be used no later than 12 months following the end of the plan year in which the forfeitures occurred. This provides a clear deadline for plan sponsors to follow.
For calendar year plans, any forfeitures that have accumulated and not been used prior to 2024 will need to be used by December 31, 2025. This is a critical deadline that plan sponsors should be aware of.
Plan sponsors can rely on the proposed regulations now, even though they are not yet effective. This can help them get ahead of the deadline and avoid operational failures.
Expand your knowledge: Individual 401k Contribution Deadline
Misconceptions Around 401(k)
Misconceptions around 401(k) plans can be costly and confusing. Many people believe that if they leave a job or are terminated from a 401(k) plan, they'll lose all their employer contributions.
Consider reading: Convert 401k to Roth 401 K
Here's the good news: forfeitures don't mean you lose everything. If you're not fully vested in your employer's contributions, you don't lose all the money in your account, but only the unearned or unvested portion.
In fact, if a 401(k) plan terminates, all participants become 100% vested in their employer's contributions. This means you'll get to keep all the money you've earned.
But what happens to forfeitures when a plan terminates? The plan sponsor has the responsibility to direct the use of the forfeitures account balance. They might choose to use it to reduce future employer contributions or, if that's not possible, they'll need to amend the plan document to guide its use.
Some distributions are exempt from forfeitures, such as those made upon attainment of normal retirement age or when the plan is terminated. In these cases, your employer contributions are 100% vested.
Worth a look: T Rowe 401k Plan
Best Practices for Sponsors
As a plan sponsor, it's essential to understand the best practices for managing forfeitures to avoid legal risk and ensure compliance with plan terms. Recent ERISA lawsuits have highlighted the importance of prioritizing participant interests.

To document fiduciary decisions, only note the final decision reached by the fiduciaries in meeting minutes. This helps keep a clear record of the decision-making process.
A written forfeiture policy can be helpful in prioritizing forfeitures for plan expenses before reducing employer contributions, if the plan allows for it. This approach ensures that forfeitures are used to benefit the plan rather than just reducing employer contributions.
Plan sponsors should confirm the plan document's forfeiture provisions and discuss them in plan committee meetings. These discussions should be documented within meeting minutes to maintain a paper trail.
It's crucial to distinguish between Plan Sponsor/Employer and fiduciary decisions, keeping business and fiduciary matters separate. This helps prevent confusion and ensures that fiduciary decisions are made with the best interests of plan participants in mind.
To ensure timely use of forfeitures, plan sponsors should review the forfeiture balance annually. This helps prevent forfeitures from accumulating and being used for unauthorized purposes.
Here are some key best practices to keep in mind:
- Only document fiduciary decisions in meeting minutes.
- Consider a written forfeiture policy.
- Confirm the plan document's forfeiture provisions.
- Distinguish between Plan Sponsor/Employer and fiduciary decisions.
- Review the forfeiture balance annually.
Retirement Plan Basics
In employee benefit plans, forfeitures occur when an employee leaves before being fully vested, and the non-vested portion of their account is forfeited back to the plan.
Understanding the provisions in your plan documents regarding forfeitures is vital for plan sponsors and fiduciaries. Familiarizing yourself with the specific language and guidelines will help you comply with IRS regulations and defend against potential legal challenges.
Plan sponsors can choose how to use forfeited monies, but the plan document spells out exactly how forfeitures are to be treated. The definition of vesting and forfeitures and how they'll be handled should be clear to you and your employees.
There are three main options for handling forfeited monies:
Quick Takeaways and Definitions
Forfeitures occur when employees leave before full vesting in employer contributions. This can result in a loss of funds for the employee, but it can also be used to offset employer contributions, pay plan expenses, and reinstate balances for rehired employees.
Forfeitures must be used properly, per IRS rules and your plan document, to avoid compliance risks. Mismanagement or delay in using forfeitures can lead to penalties or plan disqualification.
Here are some key facts to keep in mind:
- Forfeitures can be used to offset employer contributions.
- Forfeitures can be used to pay plan expenses.
- Forfeitures can be used to reinstate balances for rehired employees.
Recent ERISA lawsuits have put fiduciary practices around forfeitures under scrutiny. It's essential to document your decisions carefully to avoid any potential issues.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does my 401k show forfeitures?
Forfeiture funds in your 401k are leftover employer contributions that were allocated to former employees who left the company before becoming fully vested in their benefits. This means the contributions were not fully earned and revert back to the plan
Can forfeitures be returned to the employer?
Forfeitures cannot be returned to the employer, but can be used for specific 401(k) plan purposes, such as reducing employer contributions or paying plan expenses.
Featured Images: pexels.com

