
A 401(k) audit is a thorough examination of your company's 401(k) plan to ensure compliance with regulatory requirements and to identify potential issues. The audit process typically starts with a review of plan documents, including the plan's trust agreement, summary plan description, and amendments.
The IRS requires annual audits of 401(k) plans with 100 or more participants, and the audit must be performed by an independent qualified public accountant (QPA). A QPA has the necessary expertise to identify and correct any errors or discrepancies in the plan's financial statements.
The audit process involves a detailed examination of the plan's assets, liabilities, and income, as well as a review of the plan's investments and fees. The QPA will also verify that the plan's administrative and fiduciary duties are being met.
A successful audit outcome is essential to avoid costly penalties and reputational damage.
Check this out: 401k S and P Index Only Startegy
What is a 401(k) Audit?
A 401(k) audit is a mandatory inspection to ensure your plan meets guidelines and regulations set by the IRS and DOL. It's required for plans with more than 100 participants with account balances on the first day of the plan year.
The audit is conducted by an independent accounting firm using Generally Accepted Audit Standards (GAAS) to ensure your plan complies with DOL and IRS regulations. They also need to adhere to ERISA regulations.
Two primary purposes of a 401(k) audit are to ensure your plan complies with DOL and IRS regulations, and to determine that the financial information reported on Form 5500 and company financial statements is accurate and in compliance with GAAP.
A qualified CPA firm like BPM is usually hired to conduct the audit. They will point out deficiencies in your plan operation that occurred during the year and suggest changes to prevent these deficiencies in the future.
Here are the key requirements for a 401(k) audit:
- Conducted by an independent accounting firm using GAAS
- Must adhere to DOL and ERISA regulations
- Ensures plan compliance with DOL and IRS regulations
- Determines accuracy of financial information reported on Form 5500 and company financial statements
Preparation and Planning
Organizing your documents can save you a lot of time and trouble during a 401(k) audit. Make sure your plan documents, payroll data, and time-stamped communications are in order.
You can avoid a lot of problems during the 401(k) deposit review by integrating your payroll and record-keeping systems. This can help prevent errors and make the audit process smoother.
The most important thing to remember is that the 401(k) auditor is there to make sure your plan is ship-shape and compliant. If the auditor misses something, and then the DoL catches it, it could be very costly.
You should determine whether you are in audit status as soon as possible and provide sufficient time for the audit process in advance of the audit deadline. The audit deadline is July 31 for calendar year-end plans.
Here are some important dates to keep in mind:
Audit Process and Requirements
A 401(k) plan is required to undergo an annual audit if it has more than 100 participants with a balance as of the first day of the plan year.
The audit is a serious business, and you'll need to gather a lot of documents to satisfy the auditor. These include copies of the plan documents, such as the adoption agreement, basic plan document, and summary plan description.
You'll also need to provide a copy of the Plan's Form 5500, which is a annual filing that reports on the plan's financial condition. Additionally, you'll need to show evidence of fidelity insurance bond, which protects the plan from theft or loss.
The auditor will also want to see meeting minutes from the retirement plan/investment committee, as well as an employee census report and payroll reports. They may also request evidence of documented participant birth and hire dates, such as Form I9s.
The auditor will also review the plan's internal controls and procedures, including those for payroll, eligibility, contributions, distribution, and loans. They may also request an audit package from your third-party administrator.
It's worth noting that not all auditors are created equal, and you'll want to choose one who has experience working with 401(k) plans. A good auditor will have detailed processes in place to ensure that everything is done correctly.
Here is a list of the documents you'll need to gather for the audit:
- Copies of the plan documents
- Copy of the Plan's Form 5500
- Copy of the Plan's fidelity insurance bond
- Retirement plan/investment committee meeting minutes
- Employee census report
- Payroll reports
- Evidence of documented participant birth and hire dates (such as Form I9s)
- Schedule of remittances made to the retirement plan trust
- Documentation of internal controls and procedures
- Audit package from your third-party administrator
If your plan has between 80 and 120 participants, you may be able to file a small filer Form 5500, but be aware that you'll still need to undergo an audit eventually.
Audit Process and Requirements
A 401(k) plan is required to undergo an audit if it's a "large" plan for Form 5500 purposes. Plans with more than 100 participants with a balance as of the first day of the plan year must undergo an annual audit.
The DOL regulations include a special "80-to-120 participant rule", which states that if the number of participants with a balance at the beginning of the year is between 80 and 120, and a Form 5500 was filed for the prior plan year, the plan may file a 5500 in the same category as the year before.
To prepare for a 401(k) audit, you'll need to gather various documents, including copies of the plan documents, Form 5500, fidelity insurance bond, retirement plan/investment committee meeting minutes, employee census report, payroll reports, evidence of documented participant birth and hire dates, schedule of remittances made to the retirement plan trust, and documentation of internal controls and procedures.
Explore further: Largest 401 K Balance
The list of required documents may seem overwhelming, but it's essential to have everything in order to ensure a smooth audit process. Here's a list of the documents you'll need:
- Copies of the plan documents, including the Plan's adoption agreement, basic plan document, summary plan description, IRS opinion letter and investment policy.
- Copy of the Plan's Form 5500.
- Copy of the Plan's fidelity insurance bond.
- Retirement plan/Investment committee meeting minutes.
- Employee census report.
- Payroll reports.
- Evidence of documented participant birth and hire dates (such as Form I9s) for selected participants.
- Schedule of remittances made to the retirement plan trust.
- Documentation of internal controls and procedures, including procedures for payroll, eligibility, contributions, distribution and loans.
- Audit package from your third-party administrator.
It's also essential to choose an experienced 401(k) auditor who has worked on similar plans. You'll want to ask how many 401(k) audits they do each year and if 401(k) audits are a main focus of their firm.
A unique perspective: Iesba Group Audits
Audit Process and Requirements
A 401(k) plan is required to undergo an audit if it's a "large" plan for Form 5500 purposes, with more than 100 participants having a balance as of the first day of the plan year.
You'll need to provide a copy of the plan documents, including the adoption agreement, basic plan document, summary plan description, IRS opinion letter, and investment policy, as part of the audit process.
The 80-to-120 participant rule allows plans with 80-120 participants to file a 5500 in the same category as the previous year's filing, but this doesn't exempt them from the required large plan audit until they exceed 120 participants.
To prepare for the audit, gather a list of required documents, which may include copies of the plan's Form 5500, fidelity insurance bond, retirement plan/investment committee meeting minutes, employee census report, payroll reports, evidence of documented participant birth and hire dates, schedule of remittances made to the retirement plan trust, and documentation of internal controls and procedures.
An experienced 401(k) auditor will have detailed processes in place to ensure everything is done correctly, reducing the risk of errors.
A qualified independent accountant can perform a 401(k) audit, but it's essential to find one with experience in auditing similar plans.
You might enjoy: 401k for Retirement
Financial Statements and Reporting
You'll receive audited financial statements as part of your 401(k) audit. These statements include the Statement of Changes in Net Assets for Benefit Plan, which is one of the first pages in the independent auditor's report.
This statement contains much of the financial information that the audit will be reporting on, but it doesn't mention anything about your audit results. You'll need to file this document with your 5500.
If you're unsure about how to file the 401(k) audited financial statement correctly, check out our post on Form 5500 instructions for guidance.
Readers also liked: What Is Audit of Financial Statements
Non Discrimination Testing
Non-Discrimination Testing is a crucial aspect of 401(k) Plan audits. The auditor will secure the Plan testing performed by the third-party administrator.
The auditor will read the results to determine if the 401(k) Plan passed or failed its required non-discrimination testing during the Plan year. If the Plan failed any of its testing, the auditor will review to ensure the Plan sponsor has corrected the failure.
For another approach, see: 401k Testing Rules
Financial Statement Example
You'll receive a 401(k) audited financial statement after the audit, which includes essential documents like the Statement of Changes in Net Assets for Benefit Plan. This page is part of the independent auditor's report and provides an overview of the plan's financial information.
The audited financial statement is a crucial document that contains much of what the audit will be reporting on. You'll need to file it with your 5500, so make sure to check out the instructions on Form 5500 if you're unsure about the filing process.
The audited financial statement example shows that it's a detailed document that requires careful preparation and review. You can expect to receive a stack of paperwork, but don't worry, it's all part of the process.
One of the most important pages in the audited financial statement is the Statement of Changes in Net Assets for Benefit Plan. This page provides a clear picture of the plan's financial activity and is essential for understanding the audit results.
You can expect to see a lot of financial data in the audited financial statement, but don't be overwhelmed. Take your time to review the documents and ask questions if you're unsure about anything.
Broaden your view: T Rowe 401k Loan
Common Issues and Solutions
One of the most common issues with 401(k) audits is failing to meet the plan's minimum participation requirements. This can result in costly penalties.
If a plan fails to meet the minimum participation requirements, the audit may reveal that the plan has not been providing adequate benefits to eligible employees.
Suggestion: 401k Plan Eligibility Rules
Minimize Mistakes with Payroll Integration
Integrating your payroll and recordkeeping systems can help avoid many problems that arise during the 401(k) Deposit Review.
Proper payroll integration can automate the 401(k) deposit process, ensuring that your plan is free of cash transmission mistakes that can be costly to correct.
To set up payroll integration correctly, you need to ensure that it's done in accordance with your plan document.
Many recordkeepers and payroll companies offer integration between the two systems, but these integrations often lack validation checks to ensure compliant data transfer.
You'll want to ask yourself some important questions to ensure your payroll integration is working as intended.
Here are some key questions to consider:
- Is your payroll integration properly applying your plan's definition of compensation?
- Does your payroll integration ensure that only eligible employees are making deferrals or receiving employer contributions?
- Does the payroll integration make sure that loans match the repayment schedule at the recordkeeper?
- Does the payroll integration automatically stop loan payments as soon as the loan is repaid?
Administrative Expenses
Administrative expenses can be a significant part of a 401(k) Plan's budget, and it's essential to understand what expenses are allowed to be paid from the Plan.
The auditor will generally review the Plan document to determine if expenses are allowed to be paid from the 401(k) Plan.

Typical Plan expenses may include investment management fees, which can vary depending on the investment options offered to plan participants.
Custodian fees are also common, as they cover the costs of holding and safeguarding plan assets.
Recordkeeping fees are another typical expense, which can include costs for maintaining participant records and providing plan statements.
Professional fees, such as those for actuaries and lawyers, may also be allowed as expenses.
Other transaction or processing fees can also be included in administrative expenses, such as fees for processing participant transactions or maintaining plan compliance.
You might enjoy: Cashing a 401 K Costs
Auditor and Location Information
There's definitely some debate on where to find a 401(k) auditor, but one thing is clear: having an auditor in the same time zone can be a big plus.
A local auditor can do portions of the audit in person, cutting out time spent on emailing back-and-forth.
Remote audits, on the other hand, can be convenient and more affordable.
Has Auditor Done Similar?

When evaluating an auditor, consider their experience with similar plans. A qualified independent accountant can do your audit, but not all auditors are equal.
You'll want to ask how many 401(k) audits they do each year. This will give you an idea of their level of expertise and focus on 401(k) audits.
An experienced 401(k) auditor will have detailed processes in place to ensure everything is done correctly. This reduces the risk that something slips through the cracks.
Their main focus should be 401(k) audits, not a side project. This ensures they have the necessary expertise and attention to detail for your audit.
A different take: 401 K Pan for Employees Not from Work
Location Inquiry
There's definitely some debate on remote vs. local 401(k) auditors.
Having a local 401(k) auditor can be convenient and more affordable, but it also means they'll be in the same time zone and can do portions of the audit in person, cutting out time spent on emailing back-and-forth.
A local auditor can visit your office and review your records in person, which can be a big time-saver compared to relying on remote communication.
Remote audits can be a convenient option, but they may not offer the same level of personal interaction as a local audit.
Large Plan Audits
Large Plan Audits are required for 401(k) plans with 100 or more eligible participants. This is because the annual 401(k) audit is a mandatory process for large plans.
You might be relieved to know that even if you have 100 participants, you might not need to do the Large Plan Audit this year. This is possible thanks to the audit exemption process.
The Large Plan Audit due date is tied to the Form 5500 submission deadline, which can be extended by 2½ months to October 15th (for plans on the calendar year), or 9½ months after the end of the plan year. Failure to submit the audit by the 7-month deadline can result in costly penalties.
Here are the key steps involved in the Large Plan Audit process:
- Payroll company SOC1 Report
- Payroll Register
- 401(k) Census File
- Recordkeeper SOC1 Report
- Custodian SOC1 Report
- Draft Form 5500
- Participant Contribution Report
- Certification Statement vs. Trust Reconciliation Report
- Executive Summary Report
- Loan Report
- Custodian Statement
- Recordkeeper Register Total Report
- Recordkeeper Register Detail Report
- Compliance Testing Package (top heavy, ADP, ACP, 410b, 402g, etc. results)
- Rollover Report
- Distribution Report
Do You Need a Large
You have a 401(k) plan with 100 or more eligible participants, which means your annual audit is required. This is often called the "Large Plan Audit".
The good news is that even with 100 participants, you might not need to do the Large Plan Audit this year.
To qualify for an exemption, you'll need to meet certain requirements. We'll go over each step to see if you're eligible.
Recommended read: What Does 401 K Plan Generally Provide Its Participants
Process for Large Works

The Large Plan Audit process can be overwhelming, but breaking it down into steps makes it more manageable. The process is divided into three main steps, with the second step consisting of two parts.
The first step involves gathering specific documents from your payroll company, including their SOC1 Report and a Payroll Register. Your 401(k) Census File is also required.
In the second part of step 2, the auditor will ask for a variety of documents from your recordkeeper and custodian. These include a Recordkeeper SOC1 Report, a Custodian SOC1 Report, a Draft Form 5500, and several other reports.
Here are the specific documents requested by the auditor in the second part of step 2:
- Recordkeeper SOC1 Report
- Custodian SOC1 Report
- Draft Form 5500
- Participant Contribution Report
- Certification Statement vs. Trust Reconciliation Report
- Executive Summary Report
- Loan Report
- Custodian Statement
- Recordkeeper Register Total Report
- Recordkeeper Register Detail Report
- Compliance Testing Package (top heavy, ADP, ACP, 410b, 402g, etc. results)
- Rollover Report
- Distribution Report
Once you've gathered all these documents, you'll have completed the bulk of the work in the Large Plan Audit process.
Closing and Follow-up
The auditor's final step is to conduct an interview to determine the plan's internal controls and procedures.
You'll receive an audited financial statement to be submitted with Form 5500, as well as a report of the issues uncovered during the audit.
The plan administrator must answer any final questions from the auditor, fix any remaining mistakes, and then review, approve, and submit the audited financial statement along with the Form 5500.
You'll also likely get a copy of the Control Deficiency Letter, which outlines any issues found during the audit.
The 401(k) administration work is never finished, and there's always the next audit to prepare for.
Frequently Asked Questions
How often does the IRS audit 401k plans?
The IRS audits hundreds of 401(k) plans each year, often randomly selecting plans for review. Audits can also be triggered by participant complaints, inter-agency referrals, or issues discovered on the plan's Form 5500.
How much does a 401k plan audit cost?
401k plan audit costs typically range from $8,000 to $13,000, with many firms offering flat rate fees. Understanding these costs is crucial for plan sponsors to budget accurately and avoid unexpected expenses
Featured Images: pexels.com


